Dave Lovelady left later in the year .
Dave Lovelady was replaced briefly by Brian Redman and then by Gibson Kemp , after Ringo Starr turned down the opportunity to join having been offered more money to join the Beatles .
Dave Lovelady left later in the year , and was replaced briefly by Brian Redman and then by Gibson Kemp , after Ringo Starr turned down the opportunity to join having been offered more money to join the Beatles .