Therefore , they claimed the inter partes review process violated Article III of the Constitution and the Seventh Amendment .
Oil States stated that patents were considered to be a private right , and challenges to patent validity is a judicial process requiring a jury trial .
Oil States claimed the inter partes review process violated Article III of the Constitution and the Seventh Amendment .
Oil States stated that patents were considered to be a private right , and challenges to patent validity is a judicial process requiring a jury trial .