ABC chose Bill Beutel and Stephanie Edwards from Ralph Story 's AM to host the program .
Bill Beutel was co-anchor of Eyewitness News on the network 's New York City flagship station WABC - TV .
ABC chose Bill Beutel , who was co-anchor of Eyewitness News on the network 's New York City flagship station WABC - TV , and Stephanie Edwards from Ralph Story 's AM to host the program .