Melissa Etheridge played the part of St. Jimmy on Broadway from February 1 -- 6 , 2011 .
Davey Havok took the role from March 1 -- 15 , 2011 .
Melissa Etheridge played the part of St. Jimmy on Broadway from February 1 -- 6 , 2011 , and Davey Havok took the role from March 1 -- 15 , 2011 .