However , in his trial decision exonerating Duffy in 2016 , Ontario Superior Court Judge Charles Vaillancourt said Duffy had not falsely claimed living expenses .
On November 5 , 2013 the Senate voted to suspend Duffy and two other senators .
In Duffy 's trial decision Duffy Duffy in 2016 , Ontario Superior Court Judge Charles Vaillancourt Duffy Duffy had not falsely claimed living expenses .
On November 5 , 2013 the Senate voted to suspend Duffy and two other senators .