The English words with Hartsough 's tune first appeared in the 1872 edition .
Hartsough was musical editor of The Revivalist , a collection of hymns which had begun in 1868 and continued through 11 editions .
The English words with editor 's tune first appeared in the 1872 edition .
Hartsough was musical editor of The Revivalist , a collection of hymns which had begun in 1868 and continued through 11 editions .