In the American League , Don Mattingly won nine times with the New York Yankees for the second - highest total among first basemen .
George Scott won eight awards playing for the Boston Red Sox ( three ) and the Milwaukee Brewers ( five ) .
In the American League , Don Mattingly won nine times with the New York Yankees for the second - highest total among first basemen , and George Scott won eight awards playing for the Boston Red Sox ( three ) and the Milwaukee Brewers ( five ) .