Welcome to Stirling
Rogers, John
Williams, Cat
Zijlstra, Hans
- Welcome to the University of Stirling: John Rogers (University of Stirling, UK). - Introduction to the 6:AM Altmetrics Conference: Cat Williams (Altmetric, UK) & Hans Zijlstra
 I'm delighted to join with our Piper and welcome you to the University of Stirling. This is fairly typical Scottish weather at this time of year. It's a lovely autumnal day in between the showers of rain. Do take the opportunity to walk around our beautiful campus if you've not already done so and see a bit of what makes this place very special. This is a historic designed Parkland estate for the Airfrey Castle which is on the other side of campus. You can walk across to it. So the whole campus environment was designed as a Parkland back in the 18th century. We almost go as far as the Wallace Monument which celebrates a very famous battle just outside the University campus down in the middle of Stirling. So we have a great natural and built heritage here on campus and that's part of what makes this university we think a very special place. Just a word or two about the University not to give you all the stats and the details of that but to say something a little bit about the kind of organisation that we are. The University of Stirling was founded in 1967. We're one of the Robins University's part of the initial large scale expansion of higher educational opportunity in the UK. And we were founded very much on values of access to education, inclusion and innovation and enterprise. We were also founded very deliberately on a blend of the science and the arts. For a university of our age we actually have a very substantial art collection and that use of the visual arts, the creative arts, the arts and humanities and the social sciences woven in with our science base has always been a core part of the university's ethos. And I'll say a little more about the research here at Stirling in a moment. We're still very much a university that values ability. We want to be open to all of those who have the ambition and aspiration and ability to succeed in the courses and the programmes of study that we offer. Our intake, our domestic intake is overwhelmingly from state schools, from Scottish state schools but we're also a highly international university. So there's a really interesting mix and blend of the student body here in the university which we really value. Our core business we define as being transformational, encouraging transformation primarily in individuals. The students that pass through the university in terms of the mindsets, the approaches, the beliefs, the values that they take out into the wider world, whether here in Scotland or in all parts of the globe. And we see our role very much as preparing our graduates for the future world of work and for being able to make a deep and sustained personal and collective impact on that world. We are a modestly sized university, one of the smallest research universities in the UK. We have a very distinctive subject mix and subject blend. We do some things really well, we do other things not at all and we're not troubled about that in the slightest because another core part of our approach is to work in partnership and in collaboration with a whole range of different organisations, whether academic, company, public sector or whatever. And we work both here in Scotland and across the globe. We are very proud of our strap line which is be the difference because that says to us that we're always looking for new ways to do things. We always want to be challenging the status quo, challenging the conventional and thinking and doing through our innovation programmes, thinking about and finding new ways of doing things. And I think very much relevant to the discussion that you'll be having over the next couple of days. And Sterling has always been an institution very much committed to open scholarship. We were one of the very first UK universities to make mandatory the deposit of scholarly articles and scholarly output in our online repository. We still have a very large scale repository and we link that through to all of our web based material and our propagation of research findings. And I'll say more about that just in a moment. Our research is highly interdisciplinary. You don't have to believe me that it's highly interdisciplinary. Has that gone off? No, you're still okay. You don't have to believe me that it's highly interdisciplinary. If you run the SciVal evaluation on Sterling you will see that we are uncharacteristically interdisciplinary in our approach. That in part is a product of our size, it in part is a product of our subject mix, but it's largely because all the research that we do, all the work that we do is focused on outcomes. It's focused not on identifying that there are problems, it's focused on identifying the solutions to those program problems. We're doing a great deal of work at the moment with our regional economy here in the Fourth Valley to develop new approaches to business that both support shared prosperity, what we call in Scotland inclusive growth, which is a core government priority. But that shared prosperity needs to be delivered in ways that protect and enhance our natural resources. And our work in environmental science and in the combination of environmental science and economic development typifies that interdisciplinary solution focused approach to all that we do. There's lots more information on our website about the research that we do in Sterling. I think it's fantastic. I've been here about 15 years. This is a great quirky little university. I've worked in many other universities before and they all have their own strengths, but there's something highly distinctive that I certainly take great professional satisfaction from in the way in which we go about our work. I'm particularly delighted that the Altmetrics conference is here in Sterling because I think the work that Altmetrics do and that we and other institutions do with Altmetric is really, really essential. And there's a couple of ways in which I'd just like to illustrate that. The first is that in our strategic plan you'll see quite an interesting commitment to enhance our research profile by 100%. When I first saw that written down in the draft strategy I thought, what does that actually mean? Because it's not about measuring the easy thing to measure. It's not about measuring research money. It's not about measuring research students. How do you measure research profile? Well, of course, one of the things that we all do is we publish our research evaluation framework, our research excellence framework in ARIE scores, don't we? We put out the marks of academic excellence. We publish our field-weighted citations. We publish all sorts of different metrics. We look at the league tables which are generated both domestically and internationally. And we publish all of those marks of success that absolutely nobody outside the academic world understands or cares about. That's not how you communicate the importance of what we as a sector do. One of the things that we've been doing for the last two or three years is systematically ranking and publishing on our web our most popular papers, our most popular papers identified by the reach that they have outside the conventional academic literature. And we use Altmetric to track that and we publish the donuts alongside each of those. And we track systematically and link the Altmetric coverage to track the very structured approach that we take to getting our research noticed not by other academic colleagues elsewhere but by the people who are impacted by the outcomes of the research that we do. And getting research noticed in ways that actually address the popular understanding of research outcomes is critically important and we need to know as an institution that that approach is working and it's working effectively. And we need to know when we use Altmetric to establish what's trending, what's out there, how can we reinforce those messages. We believe that what we do is important and we want to tell people in language that matters to them. Sorry, it's a bit too early in the day for Johnson and Trump but this to my mind is also critically important. We as a sector, we as universities have long had a responsibility to tell the truth, to evaluate systematically, to understand the evidence and however troublesome and difficult it might be to tell the truth. And we live in a world that is dominated by a type of populism that is not interested very often in the truth. It's interested in a message that is palatable to a significant section of the population. Trump and Johnston in my view, the university of course is apolitical, but Trump and Johnston in my view trade on this populist approach. Trump sample of the tweets denying climate change exists. Johnson, prime minister on the back of a Brexit campaign that was entirely made up of false hoots. I think it's critically important that we get our message collectively about the work that we do, the evidence that we assemble, the evaluations that we create, the truth that we are custodians of, that we get it out there to people again in language that they understand, that resonates with them. We outside the academy will spend long periods of time reading the academic literature. So how we translate our messages, our truths, our information, our evidence into messages that matter to the people that benefit from the research that we're all engaged in, I think is critically important. I hope you'll pick up some of those themes over your conference over the next two days. The agenda looks fascinating. I know that the discussion will be lively and engaged and you hear some fantastic, really expert inputs. So enjoy the University of Stirling. We're delighted to have you here. Thank you very much indeed for the opportunity to welcome you. Thanks for this great introduction and I think it really shows that challenging the status quo is something we should do the upcoming days as well here. And I think it's a great example also to see how practical the University of Stirling is in applying altmetrics in their daily life, right? And that I think is a great example to a lot of universities to follow. Okay, welcome to Stirling again. And on behalf of me and Kat, we do a little introduction to the conference itself. We do a bit of admin for you to know where to go, what to do and all kinds of things coming. We'd like to start a little bit with the organizing committee just to let you know who organized this conference. David Sommer, David's over there. Mike Taylor who will join us a bit later. I think a lot of people know Mike Taylor, although if you Google him, you may be mixing up with the other Mike Taylor. Hans Souser, that's me working at Elsevier as a product manager in research metrics. Joe Woss at CrossRath. Welcome, Tyana Oliveira from the University of Fluminense in Brazil. Great to have you here as well. And last but not least, Kat Williams. I give you the microphone. Thank you very much and thank you everyone for coming. Could we just get our slides up for the next, I think we're a little bit behind. And to the next one. So thank you to all of the organizing committee who have been a huge support in organizing the event this year, but also to all of our sponsors. So to Hindawi, Springer Nature, CWTS, Elsevier and Plum Analytics, Wiley, QDOS, Altmetric, Minso Solutions and Research Information. Many of these organizations have supported the conference for several years now and we're really grateful for the financial backing that they give that enables us to run it every year to keep the ticket prices low. Hopefully that will continue and of course take about travel grants where we can to enable some people here to come. So thanks again to them. And to the next slide. Thank you very much of course to all of you for coming and making this trip to beautiful sterling. I'm afraid we didn't order the rain, but it's decided to turn up anyway. Hopefully it might stop at some point. We'd really encourage you over the next two days to have some fun, meet some new people. One of the things that we often find about this conference that is quite nice and that you don't always get is the mixture of people that you get. So some of you will be very technical in your background, some of you will be working in libraries or in publishers. Others will of course be Altmetric's providers or those working with the libraries and publishers who are using these data. So take a chance to say hi to some people you don't know. Learn a bit about what they do, see how they're using this type of data and perhaps take something away that could be useful for your own roles. So definitely I think I would encourage you to learn some new stuff, whether it's on the technical side or the more practical side. And use the time to question and consider. There are some very big themes within Altmetric's and some of the decisions that you make in how you use these data potentially have some quite big impacts on how your future roles or the future workings of your organisations might develop. A little bit of admin. The coffee breaks and the silver Glen restaurant which is basically a little bit if you go back in the corridor on the right and there's coffee tea etc. The lunch is held in the so called Abbey Craig dining room which is familiar to people who already had their breakfast this morning but it's basically if you come in directly to the right. So if you come into the hotel turn right and you are in the Abbey Craig dining room for lunch. Please join the conversation also on Twitter right. We're here talking about Altmetric's not only the results but also a bit of the input. So be welcome to actively tweet about this conference. There's also a Twitter account at 6am conf. So both the hashtag and the Twitter account itself are available. If you like to make photos you're welcome. Also for example the backpiper was heavily photographed and filmed and he gave permission for that to be clear on that. But there may be some people who don't like to be on photos or film. They should have taken a red sticker and put them on their blouse or whatever they were. Please don't include these people in pictures. Drinks and poster sessions are this evening. You can still sign up also at the registration desk for dinner. So there's a kind of dinner together downtown. If you're interested to join you can do so by registering before 2 o'clock this afternoon at the registration desk. That's a bit of the general admin. I had some last minute admin things about the technical stuff. We have a microphone available for audience questions. So if you'd like to ask a question raise your hand then you'll be handed a microphone. There are two headsets for speakers. So if there's a line up of four speakers please make sure after you've spoken hand it over to one of the upcoming speakers. And for those speakers in sessions that haven't met their session host yet please report to them in one of the breaks so that also the session host know who they are hosting. It's not always clear if they haven't met before. Anything else I think that's for the admin right? Okay over to Kathika. Thank you. So hopefully you'll have noticed this is 6 a.m. we started at 1 a.m. six years ago and have slowly moved through the years. And I think it's been really interesting over the last six years to see how not just the data that we're talking about and the way that it's used have evolved but actually the conversations that we have around it. So in the last few years in particular we've noticed that we've really managed to move away from talking about just the numbers to get into much more detail about the underlying data and what it actually is telling you about how and why people might be engaging with different types of research. And that's conversation that we're really keen to continue this year. You'll hopefully see it in the themes of a lot of the presentations and in how people are going about applying the data in their daily workflows. At the same time of course you know what metrics doesn't exist in a silo it's very much part of the wider research landscape. And that landscape is changing all the time and perhaps now more radically than ever. There are increasing publisher challenges as we shift more and more to open access and funders are starting to play a bigger role in the conversations there. And of course the role of librarians and research administrators and others that work to support researchers and in their institutions is changing a lot as well. Altmetrics have a part to play in that but of course there are many other things that come into that as well. And we're keen at this conference to really start connecting those things together. There is a wider increase focused on scholarly communication and societal reach and impact. You just heard from John how much that is changing the focus that they have here at Sterling and we'll hear shortly from Martin at King's College London about what they are doing in that regard. And of course there are new challenges in the data and the underlying infrastructure which as an Altmetrics provider I can tell you is no easy challenge and I'm sure there are others in the room that will relate to that. So as researchers and publishers are wanting to change the way that they are producing and disseminating research we need to think through what that really means for us and how we can continue to ensure that the data we provide and the way that we collect it is useful and can be used. And then of course as an event setting ourselves up for the future so thinking about what value do we bring to the community by hosting this event, how do we see it evolving in future. And this year we've put a particular focus on trying to become more sustainable which I think is a responsibility we all share. If you're staying in this hotel you might still be getting used to your bathroom lights coming off and on at random times I am. But Sterling as a venue was chosen particularly because of its sustainable credentials and the work that they do here to try and invest in the environment and put that as a focus in all of the activities that they do. As an event we've made some small steps in this direction so I'm afraid the program is online only but that has massively saved the amount of paper that we're producing. All of your neckties are made from sustainable resources. You might have noticed the cardboard banner stand that we have out the front which I think is going to become quite popular actually. I was quite impressed with it. So a big thanks to the team that we work with at Bioscientifica for helping us to source all of those materials and helping us in this regard. And of course we'd encourage you to do anything that you can here too. But as much as there have been some really happy times over the last six years in the last year in particular we've had some really sad news in the Oatmetrics community and we wanted to give the people who worked most closely with the people affected a chance to say a few words. So Joe. Can we have the next slide? So last year some of you may have met my colleague Christine. Christine Hone. Maybe some of you knew her as Christine Buske. And last year's conference was her first outing as a member of Crossref but many of you knew her from previous roles that she had in publishing. She died back in May from a short illness but she brought tremendous energy to us at Crossref and her presentation last year which came from her perspective as a researcher in her previous life I think really communicated really well these really difficult kind of abstract ideas that we're trying to work with and I think her presentation communicated to some people I think better than we could have done before. So like I say she's no longer with us. Rest in peace. Thank you. Thanks Joe. And sadly that wasn't the only person that we lost in the last year so I'd like to invite Isabella and Rodrigo to say a few words about Judith. The next slide please. So this summer we received the sad news that Judith has lost her battle with cancer. We were in the middle of preparing the Altmetrics 19 workshop and I received one of Judith's last emails when we had to decide who to accept to this workshop. No words can describe this loss for our community. Judith has received some of the most prestigious awards in the information science and bibliometrics community but these awards really only describe her outstanding research but not really her personality. Judith was an inspiring researcher, a role model and a good friend and mentor. She loved to travel. She loved to travel and to engage with the younger members of the community as you all may know. She always had a lot of energy. She was bursting with new ideas and she was always very kind to all the people, genuine and truly reliable. If something has her name on it you can be sure that it really contains Judith's thoughts and words. So it was about a year ago that we actually shared the stage with Judith in this very same venue, this very same place. At that time we were presenting to you the journal of Altmetrics whose editor-in-chief Judith was. The journal was really important for her so we would really like to invite you and encourage you to submit your papers along with a way of honoring Judith's work and Judith's memory. So we would like to keep her alive also through our work and the work that we can share through her journal. Thank you very much. Thank you for these kind words and again it's not only the joy of Altmetrics but let's keep these people alive in their work and also with the journal. Thank you. Just as some final comments before I give the microphone again to Kat to introduce Martin. So apart from this conference days Wednesday, Thursday, Friday there will be the Altmetrics workshop so if people may have missed that and only thought well it's only on Wednesday and Thursday they can still sign up at the registration if they like to join the workshop on Friday which is headed by Isabella. I think that's it for the admin and over to you. I would add that yesterday there was a very interesting looking duet on which ran here, that Jo and Lou from Altmetrics ran so do corner them and ask them about it. I think there were some interesting discussions that took place and we might even persuade them to do a blog right above it if we're lucky.
 I'm delighted to join with our Piper and welcome you to the University of Stirling.  This is fairly typical Scottish weather at this time of year.  It's a lovely autumnal day in between the showers of rain.  Do take the opportunity to walk around our beautiful campus if you've not already done  so and see a bit of what makes this place very special.  This is a historic designed Parkland estate for the Airfrey Castle which is on the other  side of campus.  You can walk across to it.  So the whole campus environment was designed as a Parkland back in the 18th century.  We almost go as far as the Wallace Monument which celebrates a very famous battle just  outside the University campus down in the middle of Stirling.  So we have a great natural and built heritage here on campus and that's part of what makes  this university we think a very special place.  Just a word or two about the University not to give you all the stats and the details  of that but to say something a little bit about the kind of organisation that we are.  The University of Stirling was founded in 1967.  We're one of the Robins University's part of the initial large scale expansion of higher  educational opportunity in the UK.  And we were founded very much on values of access to education, inclusion and innovation  and enterprise.  We were also founded very deliberately on a blend of the science and the arts.  For a university of our age we actually have a very substantial art collection and that  use of the visual arts, the creative arts, the arts and humanities and the social sciences  woven in with our science base has always been a core part of the university's ethos.  And I'll say a little more about the research here at Stirling in a moment.  We're still very much a university that values ability.  We want to be open to all of those who have the ambition and aspiration and ability to  succeed in the courses and the programmes of study that we offer.  Our intake, our domestic intake is overwhelmingly from state schools, from Scottish state schools  but we're also a highly international university.  So there's a really interesting mix and blend of the student body here in the university  which we really value.  Our core business we define as being transformational, encouraging transformation primarily in individuals.  The students that pass through the university in terms of the mindsets, the approaches,  the beliefs, the values that they take out into the wider world, whether here in Scotland  or in all parts of the globe.  And we see our role very much as preparing our graduates for the future world of work  and for being able to make a deep and sustained personal and collective impact on that world.  We are a modestly sized university, one of the smallest research universities in the UK.  We have a very distinctive subject mix and subject blend.  We do some things really well, we do other things not at all and we're not troubled about  that in the slightest because another core part of our approach is to work in partnership  and in collaboration with a whole range of different organisations, whether academic,  company, public sector or whatever.  And we work both here in Scotland and across the globe.  We are very proud of our strap line which is be the difference because that says to  us that we're always looking for new ways to do things.  We always want to be challenging the status quo, challenging the conventional and thinking  and doing through our innovation programmes, thinking about and finding new ways of doing  things.  And I think very much relevant to the discussion that you'll be having over the next couple  of days.  And Sterling has always been an institution very much committed to open scholarship.  We were one of the very first UK universities to make mandatory the deposit of scholarly  articles and scholarly output in our online repository.  We still have a very large scale repository and we link that through to all of our web  based material and our propagation of research findings.  And I'll say more about that just in a moment.  Our research is highly interdisciplinary.  You don't have to believe me that it's highly interdisciplinary.  Has that gone off?  No, you're still okay.  You don't have to believe me that it's highly interdisciplinary.  If you run the SciVal evaluation on Sterling you will see that we are uncharacteristically  interdisciplinary in our approach.  That in part is a product of our size, it in part is a product of our subject mix, but  it's largely because all the research that we do, all the work that we do is focused  on outcomes.  It's focused not on identifying that there are problems, it's focused on identifying  the solutions to those program problems.  We're doing a great deal of work at the moment with our regional economy here in the Fourth  Valley to develop new approaches to business that both support shared prosperity, what  we call in Scotland inclusive growth, which is a core government priority.  But that shared prosperity needs to be delivered in ways that protect and enhance our natural  resources.  And our work in environmental science and in the combination of environmental science  and economic development typifies that interdisciplinary solution focused approach to all that we do.  There's lots more information on our website about the research that we do in Sterling.  I think it's fantastic.  I've been here about 15 years.  This is a great quirky little university.  I've worked in many other universities before and they all have their own strengths, but  there's something highly distinctive that I certainly take great professional satisfaction  from in the way in which we go about our work.  I'm particularly delighted that the Altmetrics conference is here in Sterling because I think  the work that Altmetrics do and that we and other institutions do with Altmetric is really,  really essential.  And there's a couple of ways in which I'd just like to illustrate that.  The first is that in our strategic plan you'll see quite an interesting commitment to enhance  our research profile by 100%.  When I first saw that written down in the draft strategy I thought, what does that actually  mean?  Because it's not about measuring the easy thing to measure.  It's not about measuring research money.  It's not about measuring research students.  How do you measure research profile?  Well, of course, one of the things that we all do is we publish our research evaluation  framework, our research excellence framework in ARIE scores, don't we?  We put out the marks of academic excellence.  We publish our field-weighted citations.  We publish all sorts of different metrics.  We look at the league tables which are generated both domestically and internationally.  And we publish all of those marks of success that absolutely nobody outside the academic  world understands or cares about.  That's not how you communicate the importance of what we as a sector do.  One of the things that we've been doing for the last two or three years is systematically  ranking and publishing on our web our most popular papers, our most popular papers identified  by the reach that they have outside the conventional academic literature.  And we use Altmetric to track that and we publish the donuts alongside each of those.  And we track systematically and link the Altmetric coverage to track the very structured approach  that we take to getting our research noticed not by other academic colleagues elsewhere  but by the people who are impacted by the outcomes of the research that we do.  And getting research noticed in ways that actually address the popular understanding  of research outcomes is critically important and we need to know as an institution that  that approach is working and it's working effectively.  And we need to know when we use Altmetric to establish what's trending, what's out there,  how can we reinforce those messages.  We believe that what we do is important and we want to tell people in language that matters  to them.  Sorry, it's a bit too early in the day for Johnson and Trump but this to my mind is  also critically important.  We as a sector, we as universities have long had a responsibility to tell the truth, to  evaluate systematically, to understand the evidence and however troublesome and difficult  it might be to tell the truth.  And we live in a world that is dominated by a type of populism that is not interested  very often in the truth.  It's interested in a message that is palatable to a significant section of the population.  Trump and Johnston in my view, the university of course is apolitical, but Trump and Johnston  in my view trade on this populist approach.  Trump sample of the tweets denying climate change exists.  Johnson, prime minister on the back of a Brexit campaign that was entirely made up of false  hoots.  I think it's critically important that we get our message collectively about the work  that we do, the evidence that we assemble, the evaluations that we create, the truth  that we are custodians of, that we get it out there to people again in language that  they understand, that resonates with them.  We outside the academy will spend long periods of time reading the academic literature.  So how we translate our messages, our truths, our information, our evidence into messages  that matter to the people that benefit from the research that we're all engaged in, I  think is critically important.  I hope you'll pick up some of those themes over your conference over the next two days.  The agenda looks fascinating.  I know that the discussion will be lively and engaged and you hear some fantastic, really  expert inputs.  So enjoy the University of Stirling.  We're delighted to have you here.  Thank you very much indeed for the opportunity to welcome you.  Thanks for this great introduction and I think it really shows that challenging the status  quo is something we should do the upcoming days as well here.  And I think it's a great example also to see how practical the University of Stirling is  in applying altmetrics in their daily life, right?  And that I think is a great example to a lot of universities to follow.  Okay, welcome to Stirling again.  And on behalf of me and Kat, we do a little introduction to the conference itself.  We do a bit of admin for you to know where to go, what to do and all kinds of things  coming.  We'd like to start a little bit with the organizing committee just to let you know who organized  this conference.  David Sommer, David's over there.  Mike Taylor who will join us a bit later.  I think a lot of people know Mike Taylor, although if you Google him, you may be mixing  up with the other Mike Taylor.  Hans Souser, that's me working at Elsevier as a product manager in research metrics.  Joe Woss at CrossRath.  Welcome, Tyana Oliveira from the University of Fluminense in Brazil.  Great to have you here as well.  And last but not least, Kat Williams.  I give you the microphone.  Thank you very much and thank you everyone for coming.  Could we just get our slides up for the next, I think we're a little bit behind.  And to the next one.  So thank you to all of the organizing committee who have been a huge support in organizing  the event this year, but also to all of our sponsors.  So to Hindawi, Springer Nature, CWTS, Elsevier and Plum Analytics, Wiley, QDOS, Altmetric,  Minso Solutions and Research Information.  Many of these organizations have supported the conference for several years now and we're  really grateful for the financial backing that they give that enables us to run it every  year to keep the ticket prices low.  Hopefully that will continue and of course take about travel grants where we can to enable  some people here to come.  So thanks again to them.  And to the next slide.  Thank you very much of course to all of you for coming and making this trip to beautiful  sterling.  I'm afraid we didn't order the rain, but it's decided to turn up anyway.  Hopefully it might stop at some point.  We'd really encourage you over the next two days to have some fun, meet some new people.  One of the things that we often find about this conference that is quite nice and that  you don't always get is the mixture of people that you get.  So some of you will be very technical in your background, some of you will be working in  libraries or in publishers.  Others will of course be Altmetric's providers or those working with the libraries and publishers  who are using these data.  So take a chance to say hi to some people you don't know.  Learn a bit about what they do, see how they're using this type of data and perhaps take something  away that could be useful for your own roles.  So definitely I think I would encourage you to learn some new stuff, whether it's on the  technical side or the more practical side.  And use the time to question and consider.  There are some very big themes within Altmetric's and some of the decisions that you make in  how you use these data potentially have some quite big impacts on how your future roles  or the future workings of your organisations might develop.  A little bit of admin.  The coffee breaks and the silver Glen restaurant which is basically a little bit if you go back  in the corridor on the right and there's coffee tea etc.  The lunch is held in the so called Abbey Craig dining room which is familiar to people who  already had their breakfast this morning but it's basically if you come in directly to  the right.  So if you come into the hotel turn right and you are in the Abbey Craig dining room for  lunch.  Please join the conversation also on Twitter right.  We're here talking about Altmetric's not only the results but also a bit of the input.  So be welcome to actively tweet about this conference.  There's also a Twitter account at 6am conf.  So both the hashtag and the Twitter account itself are available.  If you like to make photos you're welcome.  Also for example the backpiper was heavily photographed and filmed and he gave permission  for that to be clear on that.  But there may be some people who don't like to be on photos or film.  They should have taken a red sticker and put them on their blouse or whatever they were.  Please don't include these people in pictures.  Drinks and poster sessions are this evening.  You can still sign up also at the registration desk for dinner.  So there's a kind of dinner together downtown.  If you're interested to join you can do so by registering before 2 o'clock this afternoon  at the registration desk.  That's a bit of the general admin.  I had some last minute admin things about the technical stuff.  We have a microphone available for audience questions.  So if you'd like to ask a question raise your hand then you'll be handed a microphone.  There are two headsets for speakers.  So if there's a line up of four speakers please make sure after you've spoken hand it over  to one of the upcoming speakers.  And for those speakers in sessions that haven't met their session host yet please report to  them in one of the breaks so that also the session host know who they are hosting.  It's not always clear if they haven't met before.  Anything else I think that's for the admin right?  Okay over to Kathika.  Thank you.  So hopefully you'll have noticed this is 6 a.m. we started at 1 a.m. six years ago and  have slowly moved through the years.  And I think it's been really interesting over the last six years to see how not just the  data that we're talking about and the way that it's used have evolved but actually the  conversations that we have around it.  So in the last few years in particular we've noticed that we've really managed to move  away from talking about just the numbers to get into much more detail about the underlying  data and what it actually is telling you about how and why people might be engaging with  different types of research.  And that's conversation that we're really keen to continue this year.  You'll hopefully see it in the themes of a lot of the presentations and in how people  are going about applying the data in their daily workflows.  At the same time of course you know what metrics doesn't exist in a silo it's very much part  of the wider research landscape.  And that landscape is changing all the time and perhaps now more radically than ever.  There are increasing publisher challenges as we shift more and more to open access and  funders are starting to play a bigger role in the conversations there.  And of course the role of librarians and research administrators and others that work  to support researchers and in their institutions is changing a lot as well.  Altmetrics have a part to play in that but of course there are many other things that  come into that as well.  And we're keen at this conference to really start connecting those things together.  There is a wider increase focused on scholarly communication and societal reach and impact.  You just heard from John how much that is changing the focus that they have here at  Sterling and we'll hear shortly from Martin at King's College London about what they are  doing in that regard.  And of course there are new challenges in the data and the underlying infrastructure  which as an Altmetrics provider I can tell you is no easy challenge and I'm sure there  are others in the room that will relate to that.  So as researchers and publishers are wanting to change the way that they are producing  and disseminating research we need to think through what that really means for us and  how we can continue to ensure that the data we provide and the way that we collect it  is useful and can be used.  And then of course as an event setting ourselves up for the future so thinking about what value  do we bring to the community by hosting this event, how do we see it evolving in future.  And this year we've put a particular focus on trying to become more sustainable which  I think is a responsibility we all share.  If you're staying in this hotel you might still be getting used to your bathroom lights  coming off and on at random times I am.  But Sterling as a venue was chosen particularly because of its sustainable credentials and  the work that they do here to try and invest in the environment and put that as a focus  in all of the activities that they do.  As an event we've made some small steps in this direction so I'm afraid the program is  online only but that has massively saved the amount of paper that we're producing.  All of your neckties are made from sustainable resources.  You might have noticed the cardboard banner stand that we have out the front which I think  is going to become quite popular actually.  I was quite impressed with it.  So a big thanks to the team that we work with at Bioscientifica for helping us to source  all of those materials and helping us in this regard.  And of course we'd encourage you to do anything that you can here too.  But as much as there have been some really happy times over the last six years in the  last year in particular we've had some really sad news in the Oatmetrics community and we  wanted to give the people who worked most closely with the people affected a chance  to say a few words.  So Joe.  Can we have the next slide?  So last year some of you may have met my colleague Christine.  Christine Hone.  Maybe some of you knew her as Christine Buske.  And last year's conference was her first outing as a member of Crossref but many of you knew  her from previous roles that she had in publishing.  She died back in May from a short illness but she brought tremendous energy to us at  Crossref and her presentation last year which came from her perspective as a researcher  in her previous life I think really communicated really well these really difficult kind of  abstract ideas that we're trying to work with and I think her presentation communicated  to some people I think better than we could have done before.  So like I say she's no longer with us.  Rest in peace.  Thank you.  Thanks Joe.  And sadly that wasn't the only person that we lost in the last year so I'd like to invite  Isabella and Rodrigo to say a few words about Judith.  The next slide please.  So this summer we received the sad news that Judith has lost her battle with cancer.  We were in the middle of preparing the Altmetrics 19 workshop and I received one of Judith's  last emails when we had to decide who to accept to this workshop.  No words can describe this loss for our community.  Judith has received some of the most prestigious awards in the information science and bibliometrics  community but these awards really only describe her outstanding research but not really her  personality.  Judith was an inspiring researcher, a role model and a good friend and mentor.  She loved to travel.  She loved to travel and to engage with the younger members of the community as you all  may know.  She always had a lot of energy.  She was bursting with new ideas and she was always very kind to all the people, genuine  and truly reliable.  If something has her name on it you can be sure that it really contains Judith's thoughts  and words.  So it was about a year ago that we actually shared the stage with Judith in this very  same venue, this very same place.  At that time we were presenting to you the journal of Altmetrics whose editor-in-chief  Judith was.  The journal was really important for her so we would really like to invite you and encourage  you to submit your papers along with a way of honoring Judith's work and Judith's memory.  So we would like to keep her alive also through our work and the work that we can share through  her journal.  Thank you very much.  Thank you for these kind words and again it's not only the joy of Altmetrics but let's  keep these people alive in their work and also with the journal.  Thank you.  Just as some final comments before I give the microphone again to Kat to introduce Martin.  So apart from this conference days Wednesday, Thursday, Friday there will be the Altmetrics  workshop so if people may have missed that and only thought well it's only on Wednesday  and Thursday they can still sign up at the registration if they like to join the workshop  on Friday which is headed by Isabella.  I think that's it for the admin and over to you.  I would add that yesterday there was a very interesting looking duet on which ran here,  that Jo and Lou from Altmetrics ran so do corner them and ask them about it.  I think there were some interesting discussions that took place and we might even persuade  them to do a blog right above it if we're lucky.
Welcome_to_Stirling_0_47.png Welcome_to_Stirling_48_107.png Welcome_to_Stirling_108_1511.png Welcome_to_Stirling_1512_6479.png Welcome_to_Stirling_6480_8831.png Welcome_to_Stirling_8832_12251.png Welcome_to_Stirling_12252_12551.png Welcome_to_Stirling_12552_15371.png Welcome_to_Stirling_15372_15959.png Welcome_to_Stirling_15960_16043.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16044_16091.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16092_16211.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16212_16259.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16260_16307.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16308_16355.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16356_16403.png Welcome_to_Stirling_16404_17735.png Welcome_to_Stirling_17736_17999.png Welcome_to_Stirling_18000_18071.png Welcome_to_Stirling_18072_18167.png Welcome_to_Stirling_18168_18839.png Welcome_to_Stirling_18840_19379.png Welcome_to_Stirling_19380_19463.png Welcome_to_Stirling_19464_20591.png Welcome_to_Stirling_20592_25343.png Welcome_to_Stirling_25344_25583.png Welcome_to_Stirling_25584_27371.png Welcome_to_Stirling_27372_28403.png Welcome_to_Stirling_28404_30911.png Welcome_to_Stirling_30912_33107.png Welcome_to_Stirling_33108_36251.png Welcome_to_Stirling_36252_36587.png Welcome_to_Stirling_36588_36911.png Welcome_to_Stirling_36912_37319.png Welcome_to_Stirling_37320_37835.png Welcome_to_Stirling_37836_37883.png Welcome_to_Stirling_37884_38083.png
I'm delighted to join with our Piper and welcome you to the University of Stirling. This is fairly typical Scottish weather at this time of year. It's a lovely autumnal day in between the showers of rain. Do take the opportunity to walk around our beautiful campus if you've not already done so and see a bit of what makes this place very special. This is a historic designed Parkland estate for the Airfrey Castle which is on the other side of campus. You can walk across to it. So the whole campus environment was designed as a Parkland back in the 18th century. We almost go as far as the Wallace Monument which celebrates a very famous battle just outside the University campus down in the middle of Stirling. So we have a great natural and built heritage here on campus and that's part of what makes this university we think a very special place. Just a word or two about the University not to give you all the stats and the details of that but to say something a little bit about the kind of organisation that we are. The University of Stirling was founded in 1967. We're one of the Robins University's part of the initial large scale expansion of higher educational opportunity in the UK. And we were founded very much on values of access to education, inclusion and innovation and enterprise. We were also founded very deliberately on a blend of the science and the arts. For a university of our age we actually have a very substantial art collection and that use of the visual arts, the creative arts, the arts and humanities and the social sciences woven in with our science base has always been a core part of the university's ethos. And I'll say a little more about the research here at Stirling in a moment. We're still very much a university that values ability. We want to be open to all of those who have the ambition and aspiration and ability to succeed in the courses and the programmes of study that we offer. Our intake, our domestic intake is overwhelmingly from state schools, from Scottish state schools but we're also a highly international university. So there's a really interesting mix and blend of the student body here in the university which we really value. Our core business we define as being transformational, encouraging transformation primarily in individuals. The students that pass through the university in terms of the mindsets, the approaches, the beliefs, the values that they take out into the wider world, whether here in Scotland or in all parts of the globe. And we see our role very much as preparing our graduates for the future world of work and for being able to make a deep and sustained personal and collective impact on that world. We are a modestly sized university, one of the smallest research universities in the UK. We have a very distinctive subject mix and subject blend. We do some things really well, we do other things not at all and we're not troubled about that in the slightest because another core part of our approach is to work in partnership and in collaboration with a whole range of different organisations, whether academic, company, public sector or whatever. And we work both here in Scotland and across the globe. We are very proud of our strap line which is be the difference because that says to us that we're always looking for new ways to do things. We always want to be challenging the status quo, challenging the conventional and thinking and doing through our innovation programmes, thinking about and finding new ways of doing things. And I think very much relevant to the discussion that you'll be having over the next couple of days. And Sterling has always been an institution very much committed to open scholarship. We were one of the very first UK universities to make mandatory the deposit of scholarly articles and scholarly output in our online repository. We still have a very large scale repository and we link that through to all of our web based material and our propagation of research findings. And I'll say more about that just in a moment. Our research is highly interdisciplinary. You don't have to believe me that it's highly interdisciplinary. Has that gone off? No, you're still okay. You don't have to believe me that it's highly interdisciplinary. If you run the SciVal evaluation on Sterling you will see that we are uncharacteristically interdisciplinary in our approach. That in part is a product of our size, it in part is a product of our subject mix, but it's largely because all the research that we do, all the work that we do is focused on outcomes. It's focused not on identifying that there are problems, it's focused on identifying the solutions to those program problems. We're doing a great deal of work at the moment with our regional economy here in the Fourth Valley to develop new approaches to business that both support shared prosperity, what we call in Scotland inclusive growth, which is a core government priority. But that shared prosperity needs to be delivered in ways that protect and enhance our natural resources. And our work in environmental science and in the combination of environmental science and economic development typifies that interdisciplinary solution focused approach to all that we do. There's lots more information on our website about the research that we do in Sterling. I think it's fantastic. I've been here about 15 years. This is a great quirky little university. I've worked in many other universities before and they all have their own strengths, but there's something highly distinctive that I certainly take great professional satisfaction from in the way in which we go about our work. I'm particularly delighted that the Altmetrics conference is here in Sterling because I think the work that Altmetrics do and that we and other institutions do with Altmetric is really, really essential. And there's a couple of ways in which I'd just like to illustrate that. The first is that in our strategic plan you'll see quite an interesting commitment to enhance our research profile by 100%. When I first saw that written down in the draft strategy I thought, what does that actually mean? Because it's not about measuring the easy thing to measure. It's not about measuring research money. It's not about measuring research students. How do you measure research profile? Well, of course, one of the things that we all do is we publish our research evaluation framework, our research excellence framework in ARIE scores, don't we? We put out the marks of academic excellence. We publish our field-weighted citations. We publish all sorts of different metrics. We look at the league tables which are generated both domestically and internationally. And we publish all of those marks of success that absolutely nobody outside the academic world understands or cares about. That's not how you communicate the importance of what we as a sector do. One of the things that we've been doing for the last two or three years is systematically ranking and publishing on our web our most popular papers, our most popular papers identified by the reach that they have outside the conventional academic literature. And we use Altmetric to track that and we publish the donuts alongside each of those. And we track systematically and link the Altmetric coverage to track the very structured approach that we take to getting our research noticed not by other academic colleagues elsewhere but by the people who are impacted by the outcomes of the research that we do. And getting research noticed in ways that actually address the popular understanding of research outcomes is critically important and we need to know as an institution that that approach is working and it's working effectively. And we need to know when we use Altmetric to establish what's trending, what's out there, how can we reinforce those messages. We believe that what we do is important and we want to tell people in language that matters to them. Sorry, it's a bit too early in the day for Johnson and Trump but this to my mind is also critically important. We as a sector, we as universities have long had a responsibility to tell the truth, to evaluate systematically, to understand the evidence and however troublesome and difficult it might be to tell the truth. And we live in a world that is dominated by a type of populism that is not interested very often in the truth. It's interested in a message that is palatable to a significant section of the population. Trump and Johnston in my view, the university of course is apolitical, but Trump and Johnston in my view trade on this populist approach. Trump sample of the tweets denying climate change exists. Johnson, prime minister on the back of a Brexit campaign that was entirely made up of false hoots. I think it's critically important that we get our message collectively about the work that we do, the evidence that we assemble, the evaluations that we create, the truth that we are custodians of, that we get it out there to people again in language that they understand, that resonates with them. We outside the academy will spend long periods of time reading the academic literature. So how we translate our messages, our truths, our information, our evidence into messages that matter to the people that benefit from the research that we're all engaged in, I think is critically important. I hope you'll pick up some of those themes over your conference over the next two days. The agenda looks fascinating. I know that the discussion will be lively and engaged and you hear some fantastic, really expert inputs. So enjoy the University of Stirling. We're delighted to have you here. Thank you very much indeed for the opportunity to welcome you. Thanks for this great introduction and I think it really shows that challenging the status quo is something we should do the upcoming days as well here. And I think it's a great example also to see how practical the University of Stirling is in applying altmetrics in their daily life, right? And that I think is a great example to a lot of universities to follow. Okay, welcome to Stirling again. And on behalf of me and Kat, we do a little introduction to the conference itself. We do a bit of admin for you to know where to go, what to do and all kinds of things coming. We'd like to start a little bit with the organizing committee just to let you know who organized this conference. David Sommer, David's over there. Mike Taylor who will join us a bit later. I think a lot of people know Mike Taylor, although if you Google him, you may be mixing up with the other Mike Taylor. Hans Souser, that's me working at Elsevier as a product manager in research metrics. Joe Woss at CrossRath. Welcome, Tyana Oliveira from the University of Fluminense in Brazil. Great to have you here as well. And last but not least, Kat Williams. I give you the microphone. Thank you very much and thank you everyone for coming. Could we just get our slides up for the next, I think we're a little bit behind. And to the next one. So thank you to all of the organizing committee who have been a huge support in organizing the event this year, but also to all of our sponsors. So to Hindawi, Springer Nature, CWTS, Elsevier and Plum Analytics, Wiley, QDOS, Altmetric, Minso Solutions and Research Information. Many of these organizations have supported the conference for several years now and we're really grateful for the financial backing that they give that enables us to run it every year to keep the ticket prices low. Hopefully that will continue and of course take about travel grants where we can to enable some people here to come. So thanks again to them. And to the next slide. Thank you very much of course to all of you for coming and making this trip to beautiful sterling. I'm afraid we didn't order the rain, but it's decided to turn up anyway. Hopefully it might stop at some point. We'd really encourage you over the next two days to have some fun, meet some new people. One of the things that we often find about this conference that is quite nice and that you don't always get is the mixture of people that you get. So some of you will be very technical in your background, some of you will be working in libraries or in publishers. Others will of course be Altmetric's providers or those working with the libraries and publishers who are using these data. So take a chance to say hi to some people you don't know. Learn a bit about what they do, see how they're using this type of data and perhaps take something away that could be useful for your own roles. So definitely I think I would encourage you to learn some new stuff, whether it's on the technical side or the more practical side. And use the time to question and consider. There are some very big themes within Altmetric's and some of the decisions that you make in how you use these data potentially have some quite big impacts on how your future roles or the future workings of your organisations might develop. A little bit of admin. The coffee breaks and the silver Glen restaurant which is basically a little bit if you go back in the corridor on the right and there's coffee tea etc. The lunch is held in the so called Abbey Craig dining room which is familiar to people who already had their breakfast this morning but it's basically if you come in directly to the right. So if you come into the hotel turn right and you are in the Abbey Craig dining room for lunch. Please join the conversation also on Twitter right. We're here talking about Altmetric's not only the results but also a bit of the input. So be welcome to actively tweet about this conference. There's also a Twitter account at 6am conf. So both the hashtag and the Twitter account itself are available. If you like to make photos you're welcome. Also for example the backpiper was heavily photographed and filmed and he gave permission for that to be clear on that. But there may be some people who don't like to be on photos or film. They should have taken a red sticker and put them on their blouse or whatever they were. Please don't include these people in pictures. Drinks and poster sessions are this evening. You can still sign up also at the registration desk for dinner. So there's a kind of dinner together downtown. If you're interested to join you can do so by registering before 2 o'clock this afternoon at the registration desk. That's a bit of the general admin. I had some last minute admin things about the technical stuff. We have a microphone available for audience questions. So if you'd like to ask a question raise your hand then you'll be handed a microphone. There are two headsets for speakers. So if there's a line up of four speakers please make sure after you've spoken hand it over to one of the upcoming speakers. And for those speakers in sessions that haven't met their session host yet please report to them in one of the breaks so that also the session host know who they are hosting. It's not always clear if they haven't met before. Anything else I think that's for the admin right? Okay over to Kathika. Thank you. So hopefully you'll have noticed this is 6 a.m. we started at 1 a.m. six years ago and have slowly moved through the years. And I think it's been really interesting over the last six years to see how not just the data that we're talking about and the way that it's used have evolved but actually the conversations that we have around it. So in the last few years in particular we've noticed that we've really managed to move away from talking about just the numbers to get into much more detail about the underlying data and what it actually is telling you about how and why people might be engaging with different types of research. And that's conversation that we're really keen to continue this year. You'll hopefully see it in the themes of a lot of the presentations and in how people are going about applying the data in their daily workflows. At the same time of course you know what metrics doesn't exist in a silo it's very much part of the wider research landscape. And that landscape is changing all the time and perhaps now more radically than ever. There are increasing publisher challenges as we shift more and more to open access and funders are starting to play a bigger role in the conversations there. And of course the role of librarians and research administrators and others that work to support researchers and in their institutions is changing a lot as well. Altmetrics have a part to play in that but of course there are many other things that come into that as well. And we're keen at this conference to really start connecting those things together. There is a wider increase focused on scholarly communication and societal reach and impact. You just heard from John how much that is changing the focus that they have here at Sterling and we'll hear shortly from Martin at King's College London about what they are doing in that regard. And of course there are new challenges in the data and the underlying infrastructure which as an Altmetrics provider I can tell you is no easy challenge and I'm sure there are others in the room that will relate to that. So as researchers and publishers are wanting to change the way that they are producing and disseminating research we need to think through what that really means for us and how we can continue to ensure that the data we provide and the way that we collect it is useful and can be used. And then of course as an event setting ourselves up for the future so thinking about what value do we bring to the community by hosting this event, how do we see it evolving in future. And this year we've put a particular focus on trying to become more sustainable which I think is a responsibility we all share. If you're staying in this hotel you might still be getting used to your bathroom lights coming off and on at random times I am. But Sterling as a venue was chosen particularly because of its sustainable credentials and the work that they do here to try and invest in the environment and put that as a focus in all of the activities that they do. As an event we've made some small steps in this direction so I'm afraid the program is online only but that has massively saved the amount of paper that we're producing. All of your neckties are made from sustainable resources. You might have noticed the cardboard banner stand that we have out the front which I think is going to become quite popular actually. I was quite impressed with it. So a big thanks to the team that we work with at Bioscientifica for helping us to source all of those materials and helping us in this regard. And of course we'd encourage you to do anything that you can here too. But as much as there have been some really happy times over the last six years in the last year in particular we've had some really sad news in the Oatmetrics community and we wanted to give the people who worked most closely with the people affected a chance to say a few words. So Joe. Can we have the next slide? So last year some of you may have met my colleague Christine. Christine Hone. Maybe some of you knew her as Christine Buske. And last year's conference was her first outing as a member of Crossref but many of you knew her from previous roles that she had in publishing. She died back in May from a short illness but she brought tremendous energy to us at Crossref and her presentation last year which came from her perspective as a researcher in her previous life I think really communicated really well these really difficult kind of abstract ideas that we're trying to work with and I think her presentation communicated to some people I think better than we could have done before. So like I say she's no longer with us. Rest in peace. Thank you. Thanks Joe. And sadly that wasn't the only person that we lost in the last year so I'd like to invite Isabella and Rodrigo to say a few words about Judith. The next slide please. So this summer we received the sad news that Judith has lost her battle with cancer. We were in the middle of preparing the Altmetrics 19 workshop and I received one of Judith's last emails when we had to decide who to accept to this workshop. No words can describe this loss for our community. Judith has received some of the most prestigious awards in the information science and bibliometrics community but these awards really only describe her outstanding research but not really her personality. Judith was an inspiring researcher, a role model and a good friend and mentor. She loved to travel. She loved to travel and to engage with the younger members of the community as you all may know. She always had a lot of energy. She was bursting with new ideas and she was always very kind to all the people, genuine and truly reliable. If something has her name on it you can be sure that it really contains Judith's thoughts and words. So it was about a year ago that we actually shared the stage with Judith in this very same venue, this very same place. At that time we were presenting to you the journal of Altmetrics whose editor-in-chief Judith was. The journal was really important for her so we would really like to invite you and encourage you to submit your papers along with a way of honoring Judith's work and Judith's memory. So we would like to keep her alive also through our work and the work that we can share through her journal. Thank you very much. Thank you for these kind words and again it's not only the joy of Altmetrics but let's keep these people alive in their work and also with the journal. Thank you. Just as some final comments before I give the microphone again to Kat to introduce Martin. So apart from this conference days Wednesday, Thursday, Friday there will be the Altmetrics workshop so if people may have missed that and only thought well it's only on Wednesday and Thursday they can still sign up at the registration if they like to join the workshop on Friday which is headed by Isabella. I think that's it for the admin and over to you. I would add that yesterday there was a very interesting looking duet on which ran here, that Jo and Lou from Altmetrics ran so do corner them and ask them about it. I think there were some interesting discussions that took place and we might even persuade them to do a blog right above it if we're lucky.
you to the University of Stirling. This is fairly