Is it safe to deep fry two turkeys in the same oil for Thanksgiving? Should you deep fry two turkeys in the same oil or is it better to use fresh oil for the second turkey?
Reusing deep frying oil is fine (up to a point - you can't refry indefinitely), and in fact the flavour often improves with use. You should be absolutely fine frying two turkeys one after the other for Thanksgiving. Have a good one!