Journal ArticleDOI

# Solid-state NMR characterization of the molecular conformation in disordered methyl α-L-rhamnofuranoside.

20 Jun 2013-Journal of Physical Chemistry A (American Chemical Society (ACS))-Vol. 117, Iss: 26, pp 5534-5541

TL;DR: A concerted rearrangement of OH hydrogens is proposed to account for the observed dynamic disorder in disordered methyl α-L-rhamnofuranoside and the relatively minor differences in non-hydrogen atom positions suggest that characterization of a complete crystal structure by X-ray powder diffraction may be feasible.
Abstract: A combination of solid-state 13C NMR tensor data and DFT computational methods is utilized to predict the conformation in disordered methyl α-l-rhamnofuranoside. This previously uncharacterized solid is found to be crystalline and consists of at least six distinct conformations that exchange on the kHz time scale. A total of 66 model structures were evaluated, and six were identified as being consistent with experimental 13C NMR data. All feasible structures have very similar carbon and oxygen positions and differ most significantly in OH hydrogen orientations. A concerted rearrangement of OH hydrogens is proposed to account for the observed dynamic disorder. This rearrangement is accompanied by smaller changes in ring conformation and is slow enough to be observed on the NMR time scale due to severe steric crowding among ring substituents. The relatively minor differences in non-hydrogen atom positions in the final structures suggest that characterization of a complete crystal structure by X-ray powder d...
Topics: Carbon-13 NMR (57%), Steric effects (52%)

### Introduction.

• For the past century the insights provided by crystallography have help guide the development of science in a remarkably wide range of disciplines.
• A key early development in the pursuit of crystal structure by NMR was the ability to characterize molecular conformation by solid-state NMR.
• Many materials form solids containing molecules that are partially disordered or that consist of mixtures of several lattice types (i.e. mixed phase materials).
• Conformational characterization for each unique structure in these solids is valuable because such structures provide the initial models needed for crystal structure determination by powder diffraction methods.
• Accordingly, the aim of the present study is to characterize the molecular conformations of one such disordered solid, namely, methyl α-L-rhamnofuranoside .

### Experimental and Theoretical Methods.

• Methyl α-L-rhamnofuranoside was synthesized by dissolving L-rhamnose (5.00 g, 30.5 mmol) in MeOH (15 mL) and adding Dowex-50 (H + form).
• Hz per point was obtained in the acquisition dimension.
• Of equal importance, the C2 13 C tensor data computed using this conformation was found to agree well with experimental data.
• To further establish conformations, all combinations of conformations about C4-O, C5-C6 and C6-O had to be considered because none can be considered isolated from the other sites.
• Overall, this process required consideration of 66 conformations rather than the 243 structures that would have been evaluated if isolated regions had not been utilized.

### Characterizing disorder.

• Such NMR spectra can arise from either static or dynamic disorder of the individual molecules.
• Fortunately, solids with Z' > 1 can usually be distinguished from disordered materials since they contain resonances that are relatively insensitive to temperature variations and that occur in approximately 1:1 ratios.
• The disorder was found to be dynamic based upon spectra acquired over a range of spinning speeds from 2.3 -4.8 kHz .
• In these experiments, the number of resonances per position was found to vary with spinning speed.
• This result is consistent with conformational exchanges that occur at rates comparable to the spinning speed with significant differences observed at C2, C3, C4, and C8.

### Assignment of 1 H and 13 C chemical shifts.

• Accurate structural studies require that all chemical shifts be correctly assigned to the corresponding nuclei.
• 14 Since these assignments were based exclusively on 1D data, new solution phase analyses were performed to verify all assignments.
• These new data were conducted in CD 3 OD and rely primarily on DQF-COSY data (see experimental).
• All assignments and important DQF-COSY correlations are listed in Table 1 .
• All chemical shift assignments in solid methyl α-L-rhamnofuranoside were made by comparison to those in solution.

### Conformational predictions.

• Prior work has demonstrated that accurate conformations can be predicted from 13 C chemical shift tensor information.
• In disordered samples, comparison between experimental and calculated tensor shift values is challenging because multiple resonances are observed for each 13 C site in the molecule and identifying one particular set of lines arising from a single conformation can be difficult.
• Thus, most of the experimental values for a given position display differences less than the error in the calculated values.
• When each of these experimental datasets was compared to the model structures, six conformations were found to be compatible with the experimental data.
• The structures selected show that the disorder in methyl α-L-rhamnofuranoside consists primarily of disorder in hydrogen positions.

### Conclusions.

• Solid-state NMR 13 C tensor data are paired with computational methods to establish molecular conformation in a small carbohydrate that is dynamically disordered in the solid state and unsuitable for conventional single crystal diffraction techniques.
• The solid consists of at least six conformations that interconvert on the kHz timescale.
• An evaluation of dozens of candidate structures by computational methods identifies six conformations that are consistent with the NMR data.
• These structures differ primarily at OH hydrogen positions with heavier atoms exhibiting only minor differences that appear to arise from changes in ring conformation that accompany the OH hydrogen reorientations.
• This study serves to define the structure in the crystallographic asymmetric unit and to identify favorable intramolecular hydrogen bonding arrangements.

Did you find this useful? Give us your feedback

Content maybe subject to copyright    Report

http://www.diva-portal.org
Preprint
This is the submitted version of a paper published in Journal of Physical Chemistry A.
Citation for the original published paper (version of record):
Harper, J K., Tishler, D., Richardson, D., Lokvam, J., Pendrill, R. et al. (2013)
Solid-State NMR Characterization of the Molecular Conformation in Disordered Methyl alpha-
L-Rhamnofuranoside.
Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 117(26): 5534-5541
http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/jp4036666
N.B. When citing this work, cite the original published paper.
http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:su:diva-92801

1
Solid-state NMR Characterization of Molecular Conformation in Disordered Methyl α
L–rhamnofuranoside.
James K. Harper,*
a
Derek Tishler,
b
David Richardson,
a
John Lokvam,
c
Robert Pendrill,
d
ran Widmalm.
d
a
University of Central Florida, Department of Chemistry, 4000 Central Florida Blvd.,
Orlando, FL 32816, USA.
b
University of Central Florida, Department of Physics, Orlando, FL 32816, USA.
c
University of California Berkeley, Department of Biology, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA.
d
Department of Organic Chemistry, Arrhenius Laboratory, Stockholm University, S-106
91, Stockholm, Sweden.

2
Solid-state NMR Characterization of Molecular Conformation in Disordered Methyl α
L–rhamnofuranoside.
Abstract.
A combination of solid-state
13
C NMR tensor data and DFT computational
methods are utilized to predict conformation in disordered methyl α–L–
rhamnofuranoside. This previously uncharacterized solid is found to be crystalline and
consists of at least six distinct conformations that exchange on the kHz timescale. A total
of 66 model structures were evaluated and six were identified as being consistent with
experimental
13
C NMR data. All feasible structures have very similar heavy atom
positions and differ most significantly in OH hydrogen orientations. A concerted
rearrangement of OH hydrogens is proposed to account for the observed dynamic
disorder. This rearrangement is accompanied by smaller changes in ring conformation
and is slow enough to be observed on the NMR timescale due to severe steric crowding
among ring substituents. The relatively minor heavy atom differences in the final
structures suggest that characterization of a complete crystal structure by x-ray powder
diffraction may be feasible.
Keywords.
13
C tensor principal values, NMR crystallography.

3
Introduction.
For the past century the insights provided by crystallography have help guide the
development of science in a remarkably wide range of disciplines. Several well-
established diffraction techniques are now available for determining structure in materials
that form crystals and, to a lesser extent, microcrystalline powders. Recently, the
methods of solid-state NMR have been directed toward the problem of crystallographic
characterization and the prospect of performing “NMR crystallography” has become
feasible.
1
Presently, most NMR crystallographic studies emphasize the NMR
characterization of the molecular structure of an individual molecule or the repeating unit
in framework materials.
2
The longer-range lattice order needed to identify a space group
is usually obtained independently from x-ray powder diffraction methods that rely on the
NMR determined structure as a starting model. However, alternative methods
3
including
theoretical crystal structure prediction methods have also been found to be capable of
also providing the lattice structure.
2b,4
Crystallographic analysis by NMR spectroscopy is appealing because NMR is
capable of characterizing a diverse variety of solids that can be difficult to treat by
conventional diffraction methods. A key early development in the pursuit of crystal
structure by NMR was the ability to characterize molecular conformation by solid-state
NMR.
5
Such structural characterizations can now be achieved using a variety of methods
and have been used to elucidate structure in proteins,
6
inorganic materials
2a,2b,2h,2i,2l,2m
and
smaller organic molecules.
7
Presently, these studies have largely been limited to well-
ordered crystalline solids and extension to more challenging materials is desirable. For
example, many materials form solids containing molecules that are partially disordered or

4
that consist of mixtures of several lattice types (i.e. mixed phase materials). In these
cases NMR has the potential to provide molecular conformation for each unique structure
found in the solid because several resonances are usually observed for each atomic
position due to the multiple distinct conformations present in the solid.
Solid-state NMR is remarkably sensitive to even minor differences in structure
and such variations, when present, often result in new resonances for a given site. Thus,
disordered or mixed phase solids usually exhibit several resonances for each atom in the
molecule. Conformational characterization for each unique structure in these solids is
valuable because such structures provide the initial models needed for crystal structure
determination by powder diffraction methods. Accordingly, the aim of the present study
is to characterize the molecular conformations of one such disordered solid, namely,
methyl αL–rhamnofuranoside (Figure 1). Presently, there is no known crystal structure
for methyl αL–rhamnofuranoside and this study will provide the structure of the
crystallographic asymmetric unit for each conformation present. Inspection of the
13
C
NMR spectrum of solid methyl α–L–rhamnofuranoside shows disorder at several of the
carbons and narrow lines characteristic of a crystalline solid. Here,
13
C tensor principal
values are measured for all sites. Assignment of conformation is accomplished using a
previously described approach
5a
that evaluates a wide variety of possible conformations
and retains structures having computed tensors that agree with experimental data.

##### Citations
More filters

Journal ArticleDOI
Gregory J. O. Beran1Institutions (1)
23 Mar 2016-Chemical Reviews
TL;DR: Electronic structure techniques used to model molecular crystals, including periodic density functional theory, periodic second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory, fragment-based electronic structure methods, and diffusion Monte Carlo are reviewed.
Abstract: Interest in molecular crystals has grown thanks to their relevance to pharmaceuticals, organic semiconductor materials, foods, and many other applications. Electronic structure methods have become an increasingly important tool for modeling molecular crystals and polymorphism. This article reviews electronic structure techniques used to model molecular crystals, including periodic density functional theory, periodic second-order Moller-Plesset perturbation theory, fragment-based electronic structure methods, and diffusion Monte Carlo. It also discusses the use of these models for predicting a variety of crystal properties that are relevant to the study of polymorphism, including lattice energies, structures, crystal structure prediction, polymorphism, phase diagrams, vibrational spectroscopies, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Finally, tools for analyzing crystal structures and intermolecular interactions are briefly discussed.

247 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
Paul Hodgkinson1Institutions (1)
TL;DR: It is shown how "NMR crystallography" has been used in a spectrum of applications from resolving ambiguities in diffraction-derived structures to deriving complete structures in the absence of diffraction data.
Abstract: Developments of NMR methodology to characterise the structures of molecular organic structures are reviewed, concentrating on the previous decade of research in which density functional theory-based calculations of NMR parameters in periodic solids have become widespread. With a focus on demonstrating the new structural insights provided, it is shown how "NMR crystallography" has been used in a spectrum of applications from resolving ambiguities in diffraction-derived structures (such as hydrogen atom positioning) to deriving complete structures in the absence of diffraction data. As well as comprehensively reviewing applications, the different aspects of the experimental and computational techniques used in NMR crystallography are surveyed. NMR crystallography is seen to be a rapidly maturing subject area that is increasingly appreciated by the wider crystallographic community.

41 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: This work investigates the solid-state 13C and 15N NMR spectra for multiple crystal forms of acetaminophen, phenobarbital, and testosterone and demonstrates that the use of the hybrid density functional instead of a GGA provides both higher accuracy in the chemical shifts and increased discrimination among the different crystallographic environments.
Abstract: Chemical shift prediction plays an important role in the determination or validation of crystal structures with solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. One of the fundamental theoretical challenges lies in discriminating variations in chemical shifts resulting from different crystallographic environments. Fragment-based electronic structure methods provide an alternative to the widely used plane wave gauge-including projector augmented wave (GIPAW) density functional technique for chemical shift prediction. Fragment methods allow hybrid density functionals to be employed routinely in chemical shift prediction, and we have recently demonstrated appreciable improvements in the accuracy of the predicted shifts when using the hybrid PBE0 functional instead of generalized gradient approximation (GGA) functionals like PBE. Here, we investigate the solid-state 13C and 15N NMR spectra for multiple crystal forms of acetaminophen, phenobarbital, and testosterone. We demonstrate that the use of th...

24 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
Sean T. Holmes1, Robert W. Schurko1Institutions (1)
Abstract: Nuclear electric field gradient (EFG) tensors obtained from solid-state NMR spectroscopy are highly responsive to variations in structural features. The orientations and principal components of EFG tensors show great variation between different molecular structures; hence, extraction of EFG tensor parameters, either experimentally or computationally, provides a powerful means for structure determination and refinement. Here, dispersion-corrected plane-wave density functional theory (DFT) is used to refine atomic coordinates in organic crystals determined initially through single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD) or neutron diffraction methods. To accomplish this, an empirical parametrization of a two-body dispersion force field is illustrated, in which comparisons of experimental and calculated 14N, 17O, and 35Cl EFG tensor parameters are used to assess the quality of energy-minimized structures. The parametrization is based on a training set of 17 organic solids. The analysis is applied subsequently to the...

19 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: It is found that the polymorphic Form A of AZD7624 is maintained at room temperature, although dynamic disorder is present on the NMR timescale, and a method is introduced to enhance confidence in NMR assignments by comparing experimental 13C isotropic chemical shifts against site-specific DFT-calculated shift distributions established using CSP-generated crystal structures.
Abstract: The crystal structure of the Form A polymorph of N-cyclopropyl-3-fluoro-4-methyl-5-[3-[[1-[2-[2-(methylamino)ethoxy]phenyl]cyclopropyl]amino]-2-oxo-pyrazin-1-yl]benzamide (ie, AZD7624), determined using single-crystal X-ray diffraction (scXRD) at 100 K, contains two molecules in the asymmetric unit (Z' = 2) and has regions of local static disorder This substance has been in phase IIa drug development trials for the treatment of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, a disease which affects over 300 million people and contributes to nearly 3 million deaths annually While attempting to verify the crystal structure using nuclear magnetic resonance crystallography (NMRX), we measured 13C solid-state NMR (SSNMR) spectra at 295 K that appeared consistent with Z' = 1 rather than Z' = 2 To understand this surprising observation, we used multinuclear SSNMR (1H, 13C, 15N), gauge-including projector augmented-wave density functional theory (GIPAW DFT) calculations, crystal structure prediction (CSP), and powder XRD (pXRD) to determine the room temperature crystal structure Due to the large size of AZD7624 (ca 500 amu, 54 distinct 13C environments for Z' = 2), static disorder at 100 K, and (as we show) dynamic disorder at ambient temperatures, NMR spectral assignment was a challenge We introduce a method to enhance confidence in NMR assignments by comparing experimental 13C isotropic chemical shifts against site-specific DFT-calculated shift distributions established using CSP-generated crystal structures The assignment and room temperature NMRX structure determination process also included measurements of 13C shift tensors and the observation of residual dipolar coupling between 13C and 14N CSP generated ca 90 reasonable candidate structures (Z' = 1 and Z' = 2), which when coupled with GIPAW DFT results, room temperature pXRD, and the assigned SSNMR data, establish Z' = 2 at room temperature We find that the polymorphic Form A of AZD7624 is maintained at room temperature, although dynamic disorder is present on the NMR timescale Of the CSP-generated structures, 2 are found to be fully consistent with the SSNMR and pXRD data; within this pair, they are found to be structurally very similar (RMSD16 = 030 A) We establish that the CSP structure in best agreement with the NMR data possesses the highest degree of structural similarity with the scXRD-determined structure (RMSD16 = 017 A), and has the lowest DFT-calculated energy amongst all CSP-generated structures with Z' = 2

18 citations

##### References
More filters

Journal ArticleDOI
Abstract: Despite the remarkable thermochemical accuracy of Kohn–Sham density‐functional theories with gradient corrections for exchange‐correlation [see, for example, A. D. Becke, J. Chem. Phys. 96, 2155 (1992)], we believe that further improvements are unlikely unless exact‐exchange information is considered. Arguments to support this view are presented, and a semiempirical exchange‐correlation functional containing local‐spin‐density, gradient, and exact‐exchange terms is tested on 56 atomization energies, 42 ionization potentials, 8 proton affinities, and 10 total atomic energies of first‐ and second‐row systems. This functional performs significantly better than previous functionals with gradient corrections only, and fits experimental atomization energies with an impressively small average absolute deviation of 2.4 kcal/mol.

80,847 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
Chengteh Lee1, Weitao Yang1, Robert G. Parr1Institutions (1)
15 Jan 1988-Physical Review B
TL;DR: Numerical calculations on a number of atoms, positive ions, and molecules, of both open- and closed-shell type, show that density-functional formulas for the correlation energy and correlation potential give correlation energies within a few percent.
Abstract: A correlation-energy formula due to Colle and Salvetti [Theor. Chim. Acta 37, 329 (1975)], in which the correlation energy density is expressed in terms of the electron density and a Laplacian of the second-order Hartree-Fock density matrix, is restated as a formula involving the density and local kinetic-energy density. On insertion of gradient expansions for the local kinetic-energy density, density-functional formulas for the correlation energy and correlation potential are then obtained. Through numerical calculations on a number of atoms, positive ions, and molecules, of both open- and closed-shell type, it is demonstrated that these formulas, like the original Colle-Salvetti formulas, give correlation energies within a few percent.

77,776 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
John P. Perdew1, Yue Wang1Institutions (1)
15 Jun 1992-Physical Review B
TL;DR: A simple analytic representation of the correlation energy for a uniform electron gas, as a function of density parameter and relative spin polarization \ensuremath{\zeta}, which confirms the practical accuracy of the VWN and PZ representations and eliminates some minor problems.
Abstract: We propose a simple analytic representation of the correlation energy ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{c}}$ for a uniform electron gas, as a function of density parameter ${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$ and relative spin polarization \ensuremath{\zeta}. Within the random-phase approximation (RPA), this representation allows for the ${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}3/4}$ behavior as ${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. Close agreement with numerical RPA values for ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{c}}$(${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$,0), ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{c}}$(${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$,1), and the spin stiffness ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}_{\mathit{c}}$(${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$)=${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\partial}}}^{2}$${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathit{c}}$(${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$, \ensuremath{\zeta}=0)/\ensuremath{\delta}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\zeta}}}^{2}$, and recovery of the correct ${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$ln${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$ term for ${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0, indicate the appropriateness of the chosen analytic form. Beyond RPA, different parameters for the same analytic form are found by fitting to the Green's-function Monte Carlo data of Ceperley and Alder [Phys. Rev. Lett. 45, 566 (1980)], taking into account data uncertainties that have been ignored in earlier fits by Vosko, Wilk, and Nusair (VWN) [Can. J. Phys. 58, 1200 (1980)] or by Perdew and Zunger (PZ) [Phys. Rev. B 23, 5048 (1981)]. While we confirm the practical accuracy of the VWN and PZ representations, we eliminate some minor problems with these forms. We study the \ensuremath{\zeta}-dependent coefficients in the high- and low-density expansions, and the ${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$-dependent spin susceptibility. We also present a conjecture for the exact low-density limit. The correlation potential ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\mu}}}_{\mathit{c}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}$(${\mathit{r}}_{\mathit{s}}$,\ensuremath{\zeta}) is evaluated for use in self-consistent density-functional calculations.

19,831 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
Abstract: A unique mean plane is defined for a general monocyclic puckered ring. The geometry of the puckering relative to this plane is described by amplitude and phase coordinates which are generalizations of those introduced for cyclopentane by Kilpatrick, Pitzer, and Spitzer. Unlike earlier treatments based on torsion angles, no mathematical approximations are involved. A short treatment of the four-, five-, and six-membered ring demonstrates the usefulness of this concept. Finally, an example is given of the analysis of crystallographic structural data in terms of these coordinates. Although the nonplanar character of closed rings in many cyclic compounds has been widely recognized for many years, there remain some difficulties in its quantitative specification. An important first step was taken by Kilpatrick, Pitzer, and Spitzer in their 1947 discussion of the molecular structure of cyclopentane.' Starting with the normal modes of out-of-plane motions of a planar regular pentagon,* they pointed out that displacement of the j t h carbon atom perpendicular to the plane could be written 2 112 zj = (/'SI 4 COS (2+ + 4 n ( j 11/51 (11 where q is a puckering amplitude and $is a phase angle describing various kinds of puckering. By considering changes in an empirical potential energy for displacements perpendicular to the original planar form, they gave reasons to believe that the lowest energy was obtained for a nonzero value of q (finite puckering) but that this minimum was largely independent of$. Motion involving a change in fi at constant q was described as pseudorotation. Subsequent refinement of this work has involved models in which constraints to require constant bond lengths are imposed3q4 and extensions to larger rings5-' and some heterocyclic systems are considered.* Although the correctness of the model of Kilpatrick, et a f . , I and the utility of the (q. $) coordinate system is generally accepted, application to a general five-membered ring with unequal bond lengths and angles is not straightforward. Given the Cartesian coordinates for the five atoms (as from a crystal structure), determination of puckering displacements z, requires specification of the plane z = 0. A least-squares choice (minimization of Zz i2) is one possibility, but the five displacements relative to this plane cannot generally be expressed in terms of two parameters q and$ according to eq 1. An attempt to define a generalized set of puckering cordinates which avoids these difficulties was made by Geise, Altona, Romers, and S~ndara l ingam.~l ' Their quantitative description of puckering in five-membered rings involves the five torsion angles 0, rather than displacements perpendicular to some plane. These torsion angles are directly derivable from the atomic coordinates and are all zero in the planar form. They proposed a relationship of the form\

6,267 citations

Journal ArticleDOI
Abstract: A simple two pulse phase modulation (TPPM) scheme greatly reduces the residual linewidths arising from insufficient proton decoupling power in double resonance magic angle spinning (MAS) experiments. Optimization of pulse lengths and phases in the sequence produces substantial improvements in both the resolution and sensitivity of dilute spins (e.g., 13C) over a broad range of spinning speeds at high magnetic field. The theoretical complications introduced by large homo‐ and heteronuclear interactions among the spins, as well as the amplitude modulation imposed by MAS, are explored analytically and numerically. To our knowledge, this method is the first phase‐switched sequence to exhibit improvement over continuous‐wave (cw) decoupling in a strongly coupled homogeneous spin system undergoing sample spinning.

1,980 citations

##### Network Information
###### Related Papers (5)
10 May 2001, Physical Review B

Chris J. Pickard, Francesco Mauri

01 May 2005, Zeitschrift Fur Kristallographie

Stewart J. Clark, Matthew D. Segall +5 more

11 Nov 2013, Journal of the American Chemical Society

Maria Baias, Jean-Nicolas Dumez +4 more

14 Oct 2009, Journal of Chemical Physics

Jessica C. Johnston, Robbie J. Iuliucci +3 more

31 Mar 2009, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics

Elodie Salager, Robin S. Stein +3 more

##### Performance
###### Metrics
No. of citations received by the Paper in previous years
YearCitations
20212
20202
20183
20174
20162
20141