16424206
A general multiple attribute decision-making approach for integrating subjective preferences and objective information
A general multiple attribute decision-making (MADM) approach is proposed to integrate subjective preferences and objective information and to assess the relative weights of attributes, where subjective preferences are expressed either by a fuzzy preference relation on decision alternatives or by a pairwise comparison matrix on the relative weights of attributes or by both of them and objective information is expressed by a decision matrix. Three special cases of the approach are investigated, which are the weighted least deviation norm (WLDN), the weighted least-square deviation norm (WLSDN) and the weighted minimax deviation norm (WMDN) approaches. The extension of the general approach to group decision-making and the choice of decision parameters are also discussed. A numerical example is examined to show the applications of the proposed MADM approaches.
15538833
An approach to avoiding rank reversal in AHP
Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) has been considerably criticized for possible rank reversal phenomenon caused by the addition or deletion of an alternative. This paper looks into the cause of rank reversal phenomenon and finds that rank reversal is caused by change of local priorities before and after an alternative is added or deleted. An approach is therefore proposed to keep the local priorities unchanged to avoid rank reversal phenomenon. Two well-known numerical examples are re-examined using the proposed approach to demonstrate its validity and practicability in rank preservation.
18488788
A preference aggregation method through the estimation of utility intervals
In this paper, a preference aggregation method is developed for ranking alternative courses of actions by combining preference rankings of alternatives given on individual criteria or by individual decision makers. In the method, preference rankings are viewed as constraints on alternative utilities, which are normalized, and linear programming models are constructed to estimate utility intervals, which are weighted and averaged to generate an aggregated utility interval. A simple yet pragmatic interval ranking method is used to compare and/or rank alternatives. The final ranking is generated as the most likely ranking with certain degrees of belief. Three numerical examples are examined to illustrate the potential applications of the proposed method.
207640585
On fuzzy multiattribute decision-making models and methods with incomplete preference information
In the paper by Li (Fuzzy Sets and Systems 106 (1999) 113), a minimum average weighted deviation method was investigated to determine the weights of attributes using incomplete preference information. It is shown in this paper that the method is flawed and can only be meaningful if it is revised. Two general ways are presented to revise it and are justified by using Lagrange multiplier method and Hessian matrix. Four specific revised models and approaches are investigated and examined through a numerical example. Different membership functions are suggested and utilized to normalize decision matrix so that a credible ranking order can be achieved.
19364030
The evidential reasoning approach for multiple attribute decision analysis using interval belief degrees
Abstract Multiple attribute decision analysis (MADA) problems having both quantitative and qualitative attributes under uncertainty can be modeled using the evidential reasoning (ER) approach. Several types of uncertainties such as ignorance and fuzziness can be modeled in the ER framework. In this paper, the ER approach will be extended to model new types of uncertainties including interval belief degrees and interval data that could be incurred in decision situations such as group decision making. The Dempster–Shafer (D–S) theory of evidence is first extended, which is one of the bases of the ER approach. The analytical ER algorithm is used to combine all evidence simultaneously. Two pairs of nonlinear optimization models are constructed to estimate the upper and lower bounds of the combined belief degrees and to compute the maximum and the minimum expected utilities of each alternative, respectively. Interval data are equivalently transformed to interval belief degrees and are incorporated into the nonlinear optimization models. A cargo ship selection problem is examined to show the implementation process of the proposed approach.
46223238
Environmental impact assessment using the evidential reasoning approach
Environmental impact assessment (EIA) problems are often characterised by a large number of identified environmental factors that are qualitative in nature and can only be assessed on the basis of human judgments, which inevitably involve various types of uncertainties such as ignorance and fuzziness. So, EIA problems need to be modelled and analysed using methods that can handle uncertainties. The evidential reasoning (ER) approach provides such a modelling framework and analysis method. In this paper the ER approach will be applied to conduct EIA analysis for the first time. The environmental impact consequences are characterized by a set of assessment grades that are assumed to be collectively exhaustive and mutually exclusive. All assessment information, quantitative or qualitative, complete or incomplete, and precise or imprecise, is modelled using a unified framework of a belief structure. The original ER approach with a recursive ER algorithm will be introduced and a new analytical ER algorithm will be investigated which provides a means for using the ER approach in decision situations where an explicit ER aggregation function is needed such as in optimisation problems. The ER approach will be used to aggregate multiple environmental factors, resulting in an aggregated distributed assessment for each alternative policy. A numerical example and its modified version are studied to illustrate the detailed implementation process of the ER approach and demonstrate its potential applications in EIA.
34251654
Near-Linear Time Approximation Algorithms for Curve Simplification
We consider the problem of approximating a polygonal curve P under a given error criterion by another polygonal curve P? whose vertices are a subset of the vertices of P. The goal is to minimize the number of vertices of P? while ensuring that the error between P? and P is below a certain threshold. We consider two fundamentally different error measures -- Hausdorff and Frechet error measures. For both error criteria, we present near-linear time approximation algorithms that, given a parameter ? > 0, compute a simplified polygonal curve P? whose error is less than ? and size at most the size of an optimal simplified polygonal curve with error ?/2. We consider monotone curves in the case of Hausdorff error measure and arbitrary curves for the Frechet error measure. We present experimental results demonstrating that our algorithms are simple and fast, and produce close to optimal simplifications in practice.
62532074
A decision-theoretic approach to the evaluation of information retrieval systems
Evaluation research on information retrieval (IR) systems has thus far been narrowly focused and disjointed. This research attempts to narrow the gap by providing a comprehensive and integrated multiple criteria decision-theoretic approach for the evaluation of IR systems. The approach, which is based on the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), is illustrated in the context of a domain-specific IR system. The novelty of this approach lies in the focus on the user aspect and the application of decision-making theories in the IR field.
17202693
Multiobjective programming using uniform design and genetic algorithm
The notion of Pareto-optimality is one of the major approaches to multiobjective programming. While it is desirable to find more Pareto-optimal solutions, it is also desirable to find the ones scattered uniformly over the Pareto frontier in order to provide a variety of compromise solutions to the decision maker. We design a genetic algorithm for this purpose. We compose multiple fitness functions to guide the search, where each fitness function is equal to a weighted sum of the normalized objective functions and we apply an experimental design method called uniform design to select the weights. As a result, the search directions guided by these fitness functions are scattered uniformly toward the Pareto frontier in the objective space. With multiple fitness functions, we design a selection scheme to maintain a good and diverse population. In addition, we apply the uniform design to generate a good initial population and design a new crossover operator for searching the Pareto-optimal solutions. The numerical results demonstrate that the proposed algorithm can find the Pareto-optimal solutions scattered uniformly over the Pareto frontier.
16943053
Towards an indoor location system using RF signal strength in IEEE 802.11 networks
Location is one of the most important contexts used in pervasive computing environments. GPS systems are intensely used to detect the location information; they mainly work in outdoor environment. Applications call for precise, easy-to-build, and easy-to-use indoor location systems. This paper presents our work to implement an indoor location determination system for Microsoft-Windows-based platforms using a preexisting IEEE 802.11 wireless network. The location is determined from radio signal strength information collected from multiple base stations at different physical locations. Our experiments show a high accuracy rate of this approach.
14371503
A comparison of two approaches to pseudorandomness
The concept of pseudorandomness plays an important role in cryptography. In this note, we contrast the notions of complexity-theoretic pseudorandom strings (from algorithmic information theory) and pseudorandom strings (from cryptography). For example, we show that we can easily distinguish a complexity-theoretic pseudorandom ensemble from the uniform ensemble. Both notions of pseudorandom strings are uniformly unpredictable; in contrast with pseudorandom strings, complexity-theoretic pseudorandom strings are not polynomial-time unpredictable.