analisis sitasi
225736728
Teori kritis terhadap analisis sitasi untuk kajian kuantitatif sains dan evaluasi kinerja riset
Introduction. Citation is the main indicator in research performance evaluation using the quantitative approach. There have been many criticisms of citations since they were used half a century ago, but they have not yet succeeded in bringing new concepts and methods. This paper aims to criticize and propose a new approach to citation analysis. Data Collection Method. A contemporary critical theory methodology was adopted as a framework to collect and analyze the data. Scientific publications related to citation analysis was collected from several databases such as Google scholar, Microsoft academic search, dan Garuda Ristekdikti. Analysis Data. Publications data were critically reviewed and analyzed narratively by using open coding. Results and Discussions. The results mapped the lack of citation analysis form various aspects: (1) criticism of the positivist paradigm which did not succeed in achieving its objectives, (2) criticism of methods that produce invalid results, and (3) criticism of ethical issues of the researcher and bias in implementation. The proposed solution and recommendation is to change the citation analysis method from a simple measurement of bibliographic data to text and context analysis based on a computer science approach (machine learning techniques) Conclusion. This new method has the potential to be developed within the framework of quantitative in Science and Technology studies to overcome existing criticisms. Subsequent multidisciplinary studies are needed to lay a strong philosophical and technical foundation particularly in applying the in text citation analysis method for evaluating research performance in accordance with the Indonesian context.
Yaniasih Yaniasih
204426417
Evaluasi Koleksi Literatur Ekonomi dan Perbankan Melalui Analisis Sitasi Skripsi Mahasiswa Fakultas Ekonomi dan Bisnis Islam IAIN Purwokerto Tahun 2010 2017
Abstrak Koleksi adalah sumber daya perpustakaan yang harus terus dikembangkan sesuai dengan kebutuhan pemustaka. Memahami nilai keterpakaian koleksi perpustakaan sangat penting dalam rangka meningkatkan kualitas dan efektifitas koleksi. evaluasi koleksi yang dilakukan pada skripsi mahasiswa fakultas ekonomi dan bisnis Islam ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui tingkat keterpakaian koleksi oleh mahasiswa melalui analisis sitasi. Tujuan dari penelitian ini adalah untuk memastikan tingkat ketersediaan koleksi dengan kebutuhan koleksi di perpustakaan IAIN Purwokerto menggunakan analisis sitasi bagi mahasiswa sarjana fakultas ekonomi dan bisnis Islam. Metode yang digunakan dalam melakukan kajian menggunakan metode analisis sitasi dengan objek penelitian pada skripsi tahun 2010 sampai tahun 2017. Penelitian menyimpulkan bahwa koleksi monograf nasional (berbahasa Indonesia) menjadi sumber informasi yang banyak dicari. Sebaliknya akses terhadap jurnal ilmiah sangat kurang karena kendala biaya pengadaan. dampak lain dari masalah minimnya jurnal ilmiah adalah rendahnya literasi informasi pada sumber sumber informasi primer yang terbaru. Hubungannya dengan koleksi dan kecenderungan mahasiswa menggunakan koleksi monograf adalah semakin rendahnya akses ke jurnal ilmiah, maka akan semakin tinggi akses ke monograf sebagai sumber informasi penelitian mereka. Abstract Collections are library resources that must be continuously developed in accordance with the needs of users. Understanding the value of using library collections is very important in order to improve the quality and effectiveness of collections. Collection evaluation conducted on the thesis of students of the Faculty of Economics and Islamic Business aims to determine the level of use of collections by students through citation analysis. The purpose of this study was to ensure the level of availability of collections with collection needs in the IAIN Purwokerto library using citations analysis for undergraduate students of Islamic economics and business faculties. The method used in conducting the study used the citation analysis method with the object of research in the thesis of 2010 to 2017. The study concluded that the collection of national monographs (in Indonesian) was a sought after source of information. On the contrary, access to scientific journals is very lacking due to constraints in procurement costs. another impact of the problem of the lack of scientific journals is the low level of information literacy in the latest primary information sources. its relationship with collections and the tendency of students to use monograph collections is the lower access to scientific journals, the higher access to monographs as a source of information for their research
Aris Nurohman
209942278
TINGKAT KETERSEDIAAN KOLEKSI PERPUSTAKAAN BBRBLPP MELALUI ANALISIS SITASI KARYA TULIS ILMIAH PENELITI BBRBLPP TAHUN 2016 2017
Ketersedian koleksi yang berkualitas dan mampu memenuhi kebutuhan pengguna merupakan bagian yang penting diperhatikan perpustakaan. Tujuan kajian ini adalah untuk mengetahui tingkat ketersedian koleksi yang ada diperpustakaan Balai Besar Riset Budidaya Laut dan Penyuluhan Perikanan (BBRBLPP) Evaluasi dilakukan dengan melakukan kajian terhadap daftar pustaka/sumber acuan yang digunakan peneliti dalam penulisan karya tulis ilmiah (KTI) tahun 2016 dan 2017. Penghitungan dilakukan dengan menggunakan rumus persentase Kerlingger. Hasil analisa menunjukkan bahwa dalam kurun waktu tahun 2016 2017 publikasi yang digunakan sebagai acuan yaitu jurnal sebanyak 65% buku 22 serta prosiding 13% Namun demikian, tidak semua sumber acuan yang digunakan dalam penulisan KTI tersedia di perpustakaan BBRBLPP. Dari total jurnal yang digunakan untuk KTI, hanya 43% yang tersedia, demikian pula dengan ketersediaanbuku 57% dan ketersediaan prosiding dengan kategori paling tinggi yaitu 84%The availability of a quality collection that meet the needs of users is an important part of thelibrary. The purpose of this study is to determine the availability of existing collections in the theInstitute for Mariculture Research and Fisheries Extension (IMFRAFE) Library. Evaluation wasdone by conducting a study of bibliography reference sources used by researchers in their scientific papers from 2016 to 2017. Calculation was done by using Kerlingger percentage formula.The result showed that in the period of 2016 2017 the publication used as the reference is thejournal as much as 65% book 22% and proceedings 13% However, not all of reference sourcesused in scientific paper are available in the IMRAFE library. From the total of used journals, only 43% are available, as well as 57% of books and availability of proceedings with the highestcategory of 84%
Jurnal Pari
ketut masiani
226856025
Analisis Sitasi Tesis Magister Teknik Sipil Universitas Islam Indonesia
Joko Sp
159134201
EVALUASI PEMANFATAAN DATABASE EBSCO DAN PROQUEST DALAM PENYUSUNAN LAPORAN PENELITIAN DOSEN FAKULTAS EKONOMIKA DAN BISNIS UGM TAHUN 2013 2015 MENGGUNAKAN ANALISIS SITASI
Evaluation of the use of journal databases containing the same subject area is indispensable for budget efficiency. The evaluation of database utilization is closely related to the availability of information resources as citation in the preparation of scientific papers.This research is quantitative descriptive research. The research method used is the method of documentation with the object of research citation bibliography of Lecturer Research report FEB UGM year 2013 2015.The results showed that core journals majoring in Accounting is the Journal of Accounting and Economics with the largest citation frequency of 91 times; Department of Management Academy of Management Journal with citation frequency 65 times; and American Economics Review with a frequency of citation 21 times is the core title of the Department of Economics. In general, the utilization of EBSCO database "Business Source Complete" and ProQuest "ABI INFORM Complete" as the citation for preparing the research report of FEB UGM lecturer for the period of 2013 2016 has been well utilized. The percentage of e journal availability in the Business Source Complete database and the ABI INFORM Collection database cited in the preparation of research report of FEB UGM majoring in Accounting as much as 703 titles (62.8% Management Department available 655 titles (64.2% and majors Economics is available 231 titles (44.6% The "Business Source Complete" EBSCO database and ProQuest "ABI INFORM Collection" are database aggregators that collect multiple journals from several publishers. In addition, the EBSCO Database "Business Source Complete" provides more economics and business journals than the ProQuest "ABI INFORM Collection" database. However, ProQuest database "ABI INFORM Collection" is widely used by Lecturer of Management Department in preparing research report.
Maryatun Maryatun Heni Purwaningsih
213444922
EVALUASI KETERSEDIAAN LITERATURDENGAN MENGGUNAKAN ANALISIS SITASI TERHADAP SKRIPSIMAHASISWA FSRD ISI SURAKARTA TAHUN 2018DI UPT PERPUSTAKAAN ISI SURAKARTA
This study entitled "Evaluation of the Availability of Literature by Using Citation Analysis on Thesis Students of ISI Surakarta FSRD in 2018 in UPT Surakarta ISI Library." In relation to this topic, the purpose of this research is, firstly, to know the availability of collection, provided in the library, which was cited in finishing the bachelor theses, the second purpose is to know what kind of literature was reffered to write bachelor theses of the FSRD ISI Surakarta students in 2018 the last one is to know what language and its level of colletion was cited in completing the bachelor these. This research uses quantitative methods. This research is descriptive with the subject of thesis research students FSRD ISI Surakarta in 2018 totaling 49 theses. While the object of this research is the entire citation contained in the bibliography of the thesis. Whereas, the object of the research is all literatures provided by the bachelor theses appeared in the list of reference numbering at 906 items. The result of the research shows that The availability of collection referred in the library is by 488 (53,86% items and the rest, by 418 (46,13% items is not available, there are 5 kinds of literature used as reference in writing the bachelor theses FSRD of ISI Surakarta graduated in 2018, namely; book by 776 (85,65% bachelor thesis by 89 (9,823% journal by 36 (3,98% master thesis by 4 (0,441% and research report by 1 (0,110. In addition to that, there are two languages of the collections referred, namely: Indonesian and English. The first one is mostly referred by 852 (94,039% times, and English 54 (5,96% times.
Raden Lalan Fuandara
214285237
ANALISIS SITASI ARTIKEL PADA JURNAL THAQAFIYYATBERBASIS BIBLIOGRAFI
This study discusses the analysis of citation articles in the Thaqafiyyat Journal. This study aims to describe the type of reference source, the suitability of the reference source, and the suitability of the citation technique. The type of research used is descriptive quantitative. Data collection methods used are literature study, member check or checklist, interviews, and documentation. The results showed that: (1) the type of reference sources used by the author in accordance with the recapitulation of 466 references, the internet numbered 125 references, 90 abstracts, 15 government publications, 10 dictionaries, the earth science sources 5 references, and encyclopedias amount to 4 references, (2) the suitability of the reference source with the rules of writing scientific papers is presented with the results of 28 articles, 6 articles meet 7 components of writing scientific papers with 1 component not included, namely the thank you component. Whereas the other 22 articles fulfill 6 components with 2 components not included namely the research method component and thanks. The results of the entire article calculation then calculate the mean of all articles with a total result of 78% (3) the suitability of the citation technique based on the recapitulation results, namely the total number of citations totaling 711 quotations with the translation of 286 quotations or 40% of the quotations are in accordance with the citation style used editorial Thaqafiyat Journal and 424 citations or 60% of all citations did not fit the citation style used by Thaqafiyyat Journal editorial. INDONESIA Penelitian ini membahas tentang analisis sitasi artikel pada Jurnal Thaqafiyyat. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mendeskripsikan jenis sumber rujukan, kesesuaian sumber rujukan, dan kesesuaian teknik sitasi. Jenis penelitian yang digunakan yaitu kuantitatif deskriptif. Metode pengumpulan data yang digunakan yaitu studi pustaka, membercheck atau ceklis, wawancara, dan dokumentasi. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa: (1) jenis sumber rujukan yang digunakan oleh penulis sesuai dengan rekapitulasi yaitu buku panduan berjumlah 466 referensi, internet berjumlah 125 referensi, abstrak berjumlah 90 referensi, penerbitan pemerintah berjumlah 15 referensi, kamus berjumlah 10 referensi, sumber ilmu bumi berjumlah 5 referensi, dan ensiklopedia berjumlah 4 referensi, (2) kesesuaian sumber rujukan dengan kaidah penulisan karya ilmiah dipaparkan dengan hasil dari 28 artikel, 6 artikel memenuhi 7 komponen penulisan karya ilmiah dengan 1 komponen tidak dicantumkan yaitu komponen ucapan terimakasih. Sedangkan 22 artikel lainnya memenuhi 6 komponen dengan 2 komponen yang tidak dicantumkan yaitu komponen metode penelitian dan ucapan terimakasih. Hasil seluruh perhitungan artikel tersebut kemudian menghitung mean seluruh artikel dengan hasil total 78% (3) kesesuaian teknik sitasi berdasarkan hasil rekapitulasi yaitu jumlah seluruh kutipan sebanyak 711 kutipan dengan penjabaran 286 kutipan atau 40% dari kutipan tersebut sudah sesuai dengan gaya sitasi yang digunakan editorial Jurnal Thaqafiyat dan 424 kutipan atau 60% dari seluruh kutipan tersebut tidak sesuai dengan gaya sitasi yang digunakan editorial Jurnal Thaqafiyyat.
Nim Isma Safitri
165924096
Pengembangan Koleksi untuk Program Internasionalisasi Jurnal Bidang Geosains di Indonesia: Analisis Sitasi
Internasionalisasi jurnal topik geosains menjadi harapan ditengah rendahnya peringkat Indonesia. Sehingga jurnal jurnal terprogram didalamnya menarik dikaji, terutama sumber koleksi yang kedepannya digunakan kembali untuk membantu penulis dan tersedia secara berkala. Dengan analisis sitasi, dua terbitan berkala geosains program internasionalisasi periode 2014 2016 dikaji untuk menginvestigasi frekuensi pengutipan, usia sitasi, penerbit, dan indeks tertimbang jurnal. Hasil menunjukkan dari 1742 referensi yang dianalisis, koleksi jurnal lebih diperhitungkan dengan jumlah sitasi hingga 58.27% Sitasi secara berulang sebesar 40.2% dari 408 judul, mengindikasikan adanya kontribusi jurnal jurnal lain yang lebih besar untuk kesempurnaan artikel penulis. Distribusi usia sitasi yang ditampilkan untuk manajemen penyediaan akses, penyimpanan, dan penyiangan, diketahui rasionya 17.06 dengan rentang 0 126 tahun. Kendati masih lebih pendek dari sejumlah studi yang pernah dilaporkan, sitasi jurnal berusia tinggi membuktikan mutunya terbangun secara baik. Temuan lainnya, terdapat 191 penerbit dimana Elsevier, Wiley, dan Springer lebih diminati penulis. Tren ini dapat menjadi landasan untuk mempertahankan sejumlah penerbit sebagai penyedia jurnal. Fakta menarik lain, para penulis tidak selamanya mengandalkan sumber jurnal terindeks Scopus. Bahkan menurut peringkat indeks tertimbang, jurnal jurnal Indonesia mampu bersaing dan teruji manfaatnya. Sebagai upaya kesinambungan serta percepatan internasionalisasi jurnal jurnal geosains lainnya di Indonesia, konsistensi perpustakaan termasuk diandalkan melalui pengembangan koleksi serial tepat guna dan berkualitas. ABSTRACT The geoscience journal internationalization is a hope amidst low rating of Indonesia. So the journals programmed in it are interesting to be studied, especially the collection sources that in the future can re used to support authors and are available periodically. By citation analysis, two internationalization program geoscience journals for the period 2014 2016 are examined to find the citation frequencies, citation ages, publishers, and weighted index. Results show that from 1742 references analyzed, journal collection is more taken into account with 58.27% citation. Repeated citation reached 40.2% of 408 titles, indicates the existence contribution of other journals which larger for author article perfections. Citation age distributions which displayed for management of access, storage and weeding, is known ratio reached 17.06 with 0 126 year range. Although still shorter than studies have ever been reported, old journal citations prove their quality is well established. Another finding, there are 191 publishers where Elsevier, Wiley, and Springer are more in demand by authors. This trend can be basis for retaining a number of publishers as journal providers. Another interesting fact, the authors not always rely on Scopus indexed journal sources. Even according to weighted index rating, Indonesian journals are able to compete and have proven their benefits. As an sustain effort and accelerating the internationalization of other geoscience journals in Indonesia, the consistency of libraries include be relied through journal collection development which appropriate and qualified.
Himawanto Himawanto Luki Wijayanti
194317711
EVALUASI PEMANFAATAN KOLEKSI DENGAN MENGGUNAKAN ANALISIS SITASI
Abstrak Peran perpustakaan dalam menunjang terlaksananya Tri Dharma di Perguruan Tinggi sangatlah penting, sebagaimana jantung dalam tubuh manusia, perpustakaan merupakan jantung dari suatu Perguruan Tinggi. Oleh karena itu perpustakaan di perguruan tinggi harus dapat menyediakan bahan pustaka yang dibutuhkan oleh pemakainya (mahasiswa dan civitas akademika) sesuai dengan program perguruan tinggi tempatnya bernaung melalui pemanfaatan koleksi. Koleksi merupakan unsur utama dalam perpustakaan, karena dengan tersedianya koleksi maka fungsi perpustakaan dapat dilaksanakan dalam memenuhi kebutuhan informasi. Baik tidaknya kualitas dan kuantitas suatu koleksi perpustakaan dapat di ukur salah satunya melalui analisis sitasi. Dengan menggunakan analisis sitasi tergambar dan terjelaskan seberapa sering suatu karya ilmiah (skripsi mahasiswa) jurusan PAI Fakultas Tarbiyah dan Keguruan disitir dari koleksi perpustakaan. Jenis penelitian ini adalah penelitian kepustakaan library riset) dengan menggunakan pendekatan kualitatif deskriptif, yaitu mengambarkan kejadian/masalah apa adanya dengan cara melihat, membaca dan menganalisis sitiran koleksi skripsi mahasiswa jurusan PAI Fakultas Tarbiyah dan Keguruan UIN Imam Bonjol tahun 2017. Hasil penelitian menujukkan dari hasil analisis sitasi dari pemanfaatan koleksi skripsi di perpustakaan Fakultas Tarbiyah dan Keguruan UIN Imam Bonjol Padang menunjukan bahwa daftar pustaka yang disitir yaitu buku buku pendidikan dan pendidikan Islam terkategori baik dan terpenuhi, walaupun ada beberapa buku Agama Islam yang terkategori kurang terpenuhi. Kata kunci Evaluasi, Koleksi, Analisis Sitasi
Ratnawita Ratnawita
149516596
KAJIAN SITASI KARYA ILMIAH DOSEN FIKOM UNPAD DALAM SKRIPSI MAHASISWA: ANALISIS SITASI KARYA ILMIAH DOSEN DALAM SKRIPSI MAHASISWA PADA DATABASE GDL DI FIKOM LIBRARY AND KNOWLEDGE CENTER (FLKC) UNIVERSITAS PADJADJARAN PADA SEMESTER GENAP TAHUN 2011
This study aims to determine the citation analysis of scientific papers of undergraduate theses of students of the Faculty of Communication Sciences, University of Padjadjaran during the Even Semester of the Academic Year 2011. This study aims to determine the characteristics (shape, author sources, language) which are frequently cited in scientific papers, publications of source of information, the frequency of citations of scientific papers and the development of Communication Information Science and Library Studies based on distribution subject of the cited references. The population studied is 227 titles of undergraduate theses from 4 departments (Journalism, Public Relations, Management Communication Library and Information Science) The population consists of 7089 citations. The results showed that the students appear to scientific papers from the Faculty of Communication's lecturers. Especially those published in book form. The scientific papers of the Faculty of Communication's lecturers are not yet cited in proper proportion. Besides that, there are students who still cite from private blogs. In general, student's skill to cite is still below standard. The study recommended the socialization of scientific products of Faculty of Communication's lecturers. A guide to standardization of bibliography writing is highly recommended.
Wina Erwina Yulianti Sodikin