Tardive dyskinesia during and following treatment with haloperidol, haloperidol + biperiden, thioridazine, and clozapine
In a cross-over trial 16 elderly psychiatric patients with tardive dyskinesia were treated with thioridazine (median dose, 267.5 mg/day) for three months, followed by haloperidol (5.25 mg/day), haloperidol (5.25 mg/day) + biperiden (6 mg/day), thioridazine (267.5 mg/day), and clozapine (62.5 mg/day, only 7 patients), all for periods of 4 weeks with 4-week drug-free intervals. The tardive dyskinesia syndrome and the parkinsonism were evaluated blind according to a self-constructed rating scale and a modified Webster scale from weekly video-tape recordings. At the end of the treatment periods the hyperkinesia score was lower during haloperidol than during either thioridazine for 3 months (total score, 2.2 vs. 3.2, P<0.05), thioridazine for 4 weeks (total score, 2.2 vs. 4.8, P<0.02), or haloperidol + biperiden (score, 2.2 vs. 6.2, P<0.01). Clozapine had no significant antihyperkinetic effect, but in one patient it exerted a clear antiparkinsonian effect. After withdrawal of the initial thioridazine treatment, the hyperkinesia score was lower than after the subsequent haloperidol treatment (6.5 vs. 9.0, P<0.01), but after the second thioridazine period the hyperkinesia was of the same magnitude as after the preceding haloperidol periods. Biperiden increased the tardive dyskinesia syndrome during treatment, but did not significantly influence the syndrome after withdrawal of the treatment. It is concluded that (1) haloperidol (a strong antidopaminergic neuroleptic) has a more pronounced antihyperkinetic effect than thioridazine and clozapine (weaker antidopaminergic neuroleptics); (2) haloperidol might have a greater tendency to induce tardive dyskinesia than thioridazine; (3) administration of anticholinergics concomitant with neuroleptic drugs antagonizes the antihyperkinetic effect of haloperidol, but may not influence the intensity of tardive dyskinesia after withdrawal of the treatment.