
96 TREND SYSTEMS
 
 
TABLE 5-1 MPTDIVariables*
 
 
Averoge Number Weighting Entry- ApproximateTrading of Days in Factors Signal Stop-LossRange Calculation Progression Penetration Point50-150 25 days TYPEA 100 pts 150 pts150-250 20 days TYPEB 200 pts 300 pts250-350 15 days TYPEC 250 pts 350 pts350-450 10 days TYPED 350 pts 450 pts450+ S days TYPEE 450 pts 550 pts
 
*100 points = $1 per ounce.
There is a lot to say in favor of the principles of MPTDI. It is individualized withrespect to markets and self-adjusting with changing volatility. The stop-loss serves tolimit the initial risk of the trade and allow the coordination of a money managementapproach. The fixed risk differs from moving averages using standard bands, because amoving average and its band can back away from system-entry points on a gradual rever-sal of the price trend. But there are some rough edges to the system. The incrementalranges for volatility, entry points, and stops seem a crude measure. Even if they are accu-rate in the center of the range, they must get doubtful at the extremes at the point ofchange from one range to another. Analysts will find that they may need to study pricemovement at discrete levels, such as those shown in MPTDI, to be able to generalize aprice or volatility pattern.
The Volatility System
Another method that includes volatility and is computationally simple is the Volatility Sys-tem.’ Signals are generated when a price change is accompanied by an unusually largemove relative to average volatility. If the average volatility measured over N days is
leVu) = yD Deter .where D is the maximum of@ |h- Gal®) | - LI —© Ia-G-al
and H, is the high on day é -Gris the close on day i - :L, is the low on day i
‘Trading rules are given as
Sell if the close drops by more than K x V(W) from the previous close.Buy if the close rises by more than K x V(N) from the previous close.
The value of K is generally about 3.0.
1 Richard Bookstaber, The Complete Investment Book (Scott, Foresman, Glenview, IL, 1984, p. 231).
 
 
APPLICATIONS OF SINGLE TRENDS 97
Note that the average volatility should not include the current day ¢, A comparison oftoday’s volatility using an average containing that value might cause inconsistent signals.
The 10-Day Moving Average Rule
The most basic application of a moving average system was proposed by Keltner in his1960 publication, How to Make Money in Commodities (The Keltner Statistical Service,Kansas City, 1960). Of three mechanical systems presented by Keltner, his choice of a mov-ing average was based on performance and experience. The system itself is quite simple:10-day moving average based on the average of the daily high, low, and closing prices, witha band on each side formed from the 10-day moving average of the high-low range. A buysignal occurs on penetration of the upper band and a sell signal when the lower band isbroken; positions are always reversed.
The 10-Day Moving Average Rule is basic, but it does account for the fundamentalvolatility principle and serves as an example of the actual use of moving averages. Keltnerexpresses his preference for this particular technique because of its identification of minorrather than medium- or long-term trends, and there are some performance figures thatsubstantiate his conclusion. As an experienced trader, he prefers the speed of the 10-daymoving average, which follows the market prices with more reasonable risk than slowermethods. A side benefit to the selection is that the usual division required by a movingaverage calculation can be substituted by a simple shift of the decimal place; in an erabefore the pocket calculator, who knows how much impact that convenience had on Kelt-ner’s choice?
 
Triple Exponential Smoothing,
A triple exponential smoothing technique was described by Hutson as another approachto trend following.” Substituting the log of the price for the price itself, he applied an expo-nential smoothing three times using the same smoothing constant. A buy signal was gen-erated when the triple-smoothed series rose for 2 consecutive days; a sell signal followeda 2-day decline.
The smoothing constant selected would normally be faster (less than a 20-day equiva-lent, when 2/(7 + 1) is used to convert the n days to a smoothing constant) for a triplesmoothing than for a single smoothed line. It is interesting to see what actually happenswhen a series is smoothed three times. For example, a triple smoothing of a straight 3-daymoving average gives the following:
P={P1, Px, ***, Pn)‘The single moving average at day 1 is
Me @n-2+ Past Pr)3Smoothing the-new series M givesMg Maat Ma + Mo)3-_ Pn-4+ 2Pp—3 + BPn-2+ 2Pu-1+ Pru)- 9
and the third smoothing gives
2 Jack K. Hutson, “Good TRIX,” Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities uly 1983). 
98
 
TREND SYSTEMSpt ina tM MD)3= Pane + Paws + OPnas + TPs + Pn at 3Pn-1 + Pr)
27
The effect of the weighting puts increased importance on the middle values, reducing thesignificance of both ends. With exponential smoothing as well, the increased emphasis willbe placed on the n — 2 value, the price which is repeated most often.
The Parabolic Time/Price System
One of the primary complaints about trend-following systems is that the built-in lagdestroys the trade. In the Parabolic Time/Price System,? Wilder has reduced the lag byincreasing the speed of the trend (shortening the days) whenever prices achieve new prof-itable levels. The philosophy of the Parabolic System is that time is an enemy. Once a posttion is entered, it must continue to be profitable ér it will be liquidated.
‘The Parabolic Time/Price System is always in the market; whenever a position is closedout, it is also reversed. The point at which this occurs is called the Stop and Reverse (SAR).When plotted, it is similar to a trendline, although it has a decreasing lag (the distancebetween the current price and the trendline, or SAR point), as shown in Figure 5-4
To calculate the SAR value, first assume a long or short position. If the market hasrecently moved lower and is now above the lows ofthat move, assume a fong Cal the lowest point of the previous trade the SAR initial poi i 5point for the SAR calculation (SAR, = SIP). Point (SIP), Because it will be the staring
Calculate each following SAR as ‘
SAR (tomorrow) = SAR(prior) + AF x [High (today) — SAR(prior)]
This is an exponential smoothing using the prior high price. It is unique because thesmoothing constant AF called the acceleration factor, changes. AF is set to .02 at the begin-ning of the trade. Each day that a new extreme occurs (a new high when long, or a new low
® J. Welles Wilder, Jr., New Concepts in Technical Trading Systems (Trend Research, Greénsboro, NC, 1978).RNG i,
FIGURE 5-4 Parabolic Time/Price System.
SIP (prior high)
      
/?
nen7 NN SAR long
(uses highs)
APPLICATIONS OF SINGLE TRENDS 9
 
when short), AF is increased by .02. In moving average days, AF begins at 99 days andincreases in speed to a maximum of a 9-day moving average, but not in a linear fashion.
In the SAR calculation, High(today) is used when a long position is held, andLow(today) is used when a short is held. An additional rule also prevents premature rever-sal by not allowing the SAR to enter the price range of the most recent 2 days:
If Jong, the SAR may never be greater than the low of today or the prior day. If it isgreater than this low, set the SAR to that low value. A reversal will occur on a new intra-day low that penetrates the SAR.
If short, the SAR is calculated in the same way based on the highs.
Wilder's Parabolic Time/Price System was a new and interesting idea—varying theexponential smoothing constant. This could also be accomplished by varying the movingaverage days, but not as effectively. The constant increment of .02 and the limitations of therange, .02 to .20, are likely to be shortcomings. Traders might want to relate the changingspeed to more basic price phenomena such as volatility or momentum. For those readersintefested in the further development of this method, the Parabolic Time/Price System iscombined with Directional Movement (described in Chapter 23) to form the DirectionalParabolic System discussed in Chapter 6.
The Master Trading Formula
‘Another method of variable speed is Mart’s The Master Trading Formula." \t uses an expo-nential smoothing formula in which the smoothing constant and band are calculated daily,based on market volatility. Mart averages the extended daily range (using the maximum ofyesterday's close and today’s high and low) and the net price movement over the sameinterval to define a correlated volatility factor. This value is then used to look up asmoothing constant in a modified log-scale table, in which an 8%-smoothing (24-day equiv-alent) is used for the lowest volatility and a 33% smoothing (2-day equivalent) for the great-est volatility, with the median value at 14% (13-day equivalent).
‘Aband is also placed around the trendline, based on an inverse relationship to the cor-related volatility factor. The band is widest when there is low volatility and the smoothingconstant produces a slow trend; it is narrowest in fast, highly volatile markets.
Rules for trading Mart’s Master Formula are centered around the basic band tradingrules. The system is always in the market, taking long positions when the upper band isbroken and short positions when the lower band is crossed.
Raschke’s First Cross
‘Although we usually trade a trend from the beginning to end based on some smoothingmethod, Linda Bradford Raschke has shown that a selected piece of the trend move can beavery reliable trade. Her First Cross system enters a trend trade on the first pullback afteran initial trend signal based on a faster momentum indicator. She did not offer any exitrules, but there are some that can be suggested. To create this program we need
SlowMA — Slow-moving average, part of oscillator calculation
fastMA  Fast-moving average, part of oscillator calculation
osc Moving average oscillator, fastMA - STOWMA
trend Moving average of osc
The oscillator is the difference between the fast- and slow-moving averages
osc = fastMA - sTowMA -
4 Donald S. Mart, The Master Trading Formula (Winsor Books, Brightwaters, NY, 1981). 
too TREND SYSTEMS
 
To generate a buy or selLentry signal, use the following steps (comments on the right):
BI. osc[1]> trend and ose <= trendB2. low > lowL1]B3. buy
S1. osc{1]} < trend and osc >= trend$2. high < high(1]$3. sell
A likely exit rule for the First Cross system should maintain the short-term nature of theselection. You might simply consider the entry on the first pullback as better entry timingfor a longer-term trend. Or, you might want to trade only the short period isolated by thefirst pullback until this initial impulse is exhausted. If you chose the second method, youmight try the following exit condition:
osc crosses trend moving downlow of bar rises
osc crosses trend moving uphigh of the bar declines
Exit for a long position
X1. close{1] > close[2} close of bar turns up (confirms trend)X2. close < close{1] after going up, the close turns downX3. exit long
Raschke’s idea is an excellent example of selectivity. First, you recognize that the beginningof a trend is different from other times. As traders recognize a change of direction there isan increasingly strong move. Because most systems lag the market, they are often too lateor miss the first part of the turn, which could create large profits. As an alternative, thistechnique waits for the first move to be exhausted, then enters in anticipation of anotherfast surge as the new trend reasserts itself. Once these early moves are over, the generaltrend move may not be as easy to:work with, and you may find yourself trying to enter asthe trend comes to an end.
COMPARISON OF MAJORTREND SYSTEMS
A section on trends cannot be complete without looking at the comparative performance
of the six most popular approaches: -
1. Simple moving average ‘
2. Exponential smoothing3. Linear regression slope4. N-day breakout5. Swing breakout6. Point-and-figure
Trading Rules
To see the characteristics of each system, the trading rules will be as simple as possible. Allsix systems ar@ always in the market. Thats, once they enter a long or short position, theyalways reverse on a flew signal, going from long to short, or short to long. There are nostop-losses or other risk control rules; therefore, each system has its own, natural risk pro-file. A $100 round-turn charge was applied to each trade to cover commissions and slip-page. Table 5-2 summarizes the type of system, calculation method, and trading rules.
Varying the Speed of the Trend
Each system must be tested with a wide range of fast and slow trends. For systems 1through 4, the period, or number of days, 7, determines the trend speed. For the swing
 
 
COMPARISON OF MAJORTREND SYSTEMS.
   
TABLE 5-2 Summary of Six Major Trending Systems
 
System Type FormulasMA = @Sum(ctose,n) / nMA = @Average(close,n)MAchange = MA - MAC1]
            
1, Simple moving averageMA is the average of previousn-day closing prices.
Rules
BUY if MAchange > 0SELL if MAchange < 0(the moving average turnsup or down)
   
 
2. Exponential smoothingEXP is a weighting of the recentclosing price by a percentage, s(called the smoothing constant).
        
EXPchange = EXP - EXP[1]
EXP= EXP[1]+s*(close-EXP[1]) BUY if EXPchange > 0
SELL if EXPchange < 0{the trend turns up or down)
 
 
3. Linear regression slope LRS =LRS is the slope (angle) of astraight line found using a least-squares regression.
n*Sum(x*c) -Sum(x)*Sum(c)n*Sum(x*x) ~Sum(x) *Sum(x)where c is the close, and x are
the integers, 1, 2,3,... 1,representing the time intervals.
            
BUY if LRS > 0SELL if LRS << 0
Buy when the LRS is up (slope ispositive), and sell when the LRSis down (slope is negative).
 
4. N-day breakoutSignals occur when the currentprice reaches a new high or low (abreakout”) for both intraday and now =
end of day, based on the previous @lowest(low[1],n-1)mdays.
nhigh = @high-est(nigh[1],n-1)
BUY if high > nhigh
and close’> close[i]SELL if low < nlow
and close < close{t]
          
Buy when the current high price isgreater than the highest price ofthe past n days,and the close ishigher than the previous close[1}.
 
swhi gh is the highest price thatoccurs before a price deciine ofp*swhigh, where p is a percent
5. Swing breakout
Signals occur when the currenthigh or low price exceeds theprevious swing high or low price.A swing is a price move thatbegins with a reversal of aminimum percentage value.
6. Point-and-figureSignals occur when the current
sw] ow is the lowest price thatoccurs before a rally of p*swlow,where p is a percent.
‘Same rules as Swing Breakout,except that new highs and lowshigh or low price exceeds the are recorded only if they exceed aprevious high or low, which is preset box size. A reversal isformed by filling boxes of a preset recorded if a minimum of 3 boxespoint size. ~ can be filled, not including thecurrent box
 
BUY if high > swhighSELL if low < swlow
                       
Buy when the current highexceeds the previous swing high.Sell when the current low fallsbelow the previous swing low.
BUY if high > PFhigh + 1 boxSELL if low < PFlow - 1 box
Buy when the current highexceeds the previous PF swinghigh by at least one box. Sell‘when the current low falls belowthe previous PF swing low by atleast I box."94 uy open sad ayoud 47x :9 uuInjo> ‘uMopMeICRE}IN = KIpeY sUuMaJ seaA-p] parsnfpr-ys *xIpey:s uUUNJOD sepen ajqrayoud yo aBewuo>ied aya Aayqnyss YoY:y wUUrYOD ‘sepen Jo JequIMU [EOD SPA{1 wunjo sepen aygeayosd jo sequin ygih:z uuunjor "x09 x £ 8) EUAALD fess9Ad4 sqylod uy a8 x09 04 ROAD BuyAs uM 40} 2414 jo @BUadIed g;poyied UoREyTO}E sip UI SAep 0 saquiTU ‘skep:| ULIMIOD
 
'SNHMO9 JO NOLLWNVTaXdcccFI TOE T8l- UKE oth] CLE. Psy£ v9 BI! LIS 7900 yell 69 veel 601 . ‘ | iSse Vsol  99€ T091 iy Fes! 16S 1% OL Ch GLI OLE FOL Vv
 
- = 007 ol t aro LS 'ry BEF a Z €e10 078 etl £9 st Z 00'S ’
LOE EGE 8t i 0010 = F697 Boh 88S al ol 00% 901 £91 9 t 007Lee 9 Ch OF ai £800 (91! SLE Th ee v1 00€ ley LS L r os!tL V2 vu = L900 OL wOh «CSE Is 81 Ost SIZ To I 9 001
 
    
stl ee ve S00 +6 8 vE = 007 flr FES $1 8 SL
tel Ll 6s = €£00 69 Lel is OS Lye ybb ka u 0s
+8 08! o£ = sz0"0 isi 69E LIT 08 (00! 6Sh 6 SY “et a ce
SI Slt 96 =| «9100 9€ OLE 6l2 sol SLO es! LE dL 6 a1
09- B9E bz 8000 ly SE ie tel = 0s0 Ort 90h trl 8S 8
8L- 90h 91 HOO ie USE 18€ vel STO +8 { TBE £87 80l y qa
 
 
4% = PPP SLR eet xOg 4%) POY Spt Sid % soy Pu Spt Hatt = Mog
 
FUNOWONV-INIOd “9 (1=24h) LNOYIYa NIMS °S ANOWYANE AVON“o1ss Bums yaya saseasouy 9s1y “€ “ozs Bums YM SaStALUL ASTY “E -o8ues (ain saseasoul 4ShY “E“yeyrew Buipuedxe ssayun sdjym Jamey "7, ‘yaysew Buypuedxe ssajun siya Jamey 7 “sSums rayzew BuIpuedxa uo Apsow sdiynA, 7' “zaaiy snjd Jaa] jeamaeu uo syeusig *) “syeuBis aAi3 on sjanay jeumeu sesry “| ‘Asowau mnowpyr ara} jeumeu Uo sjeusis “|
    
 
{penunues) rs FTEWLNN EE EE EE aan ae
Coo Cc ee
  
 
Ove E9- ETT £87 Psytbl LOL Lk é or asOs C8 Wl 80h 9S0L BIE FOr OF C09 Orr 9S0L 95% FOE ipl Of 90L Bayost sol 291 9 | 007 s 6 007, 110 s SO bh 6 0079EST et LU OM 8 Ost 8rZI tr a OSI 6% 8 18E 1% 8 os!Or Ir €€€ SI s ool 40'S Lst 1 ool &s9 18% GE fh st 001BES Sl She 6% €1 SL SB sel 61 Sh v L% TH G9 Al SLyS'S HZ Ole 6E ow 0s 16 St os = =6IT 80% 97E 6 1€ os
 
fey Bet TBE OSS 1% we we S9E 43 te Ors 99S CE IL. LE ros
ITO Ae EME LU iy a 1770 be BET vit Is 9 ¥L0 ye] O87 78) MIS yw
to0- - Vs€ 687 16 8 $0°0- Lim $80 ote 06 8 610 Is VTE vt 88 8910-06 = LOE LSS 121 v 4V0- 8B HT SIS EL y 810- 6L- €0E EEF lel + aa
4% peu Pu sput dat og ue lpoy ypu gt Shog u%—elpoy yp git shog
 
 
 
3dO1S NOISSTYDIY YVINIT € SNIHLOOWS TWLLNINOdX3 ‘7 OVEIAY ONIAOW “T“AX 40 Yin Ue? 12Bse] aq ue sassoy “¢ ‘sesso euis Apso “E “sassoy jews Apso “¢“sdlym asned 10u saop uopenauad aug -% —“(v93}y paeu) sepesn jo Jaquinu winwujujus aH SdIYAA “Z —“(uaaIy padu) sope.n jo Jequnu WnUIUR aw SdIYAA, “7“(s21ouoda) ueaws se uoR>eIp s1>a!0I4 *| “saad ased jo Atowauu aui0g *} “pouad ased jo Aowau on *|‘wan) anoyeaug Aep-y “9’ spuog 7 ere (puourg ‘| :psepuers'g = 3d AL. °S (ed) @un3y-pue-ruiog °sPareoipuy ssajun p6/1 E/E 09 -B/|/| WOY ERP 35a) “> (OMS) anoyeBIG Bug “>apenn sed 091 $ 28 eBeddys pue suosssiu0 “¢ (su) adoys uorssouBau seaury “fuonezijenut 40} pasn step 00z 3814 °Z (axa) 2unpoows jenuauodg -z‘Ayo sapenn ano-paso}> uoneasapeay, “| (vid) @82s0Ke Burpy “|. s3ymy swiaishs
 
(h661-S861) suia3sks xIS 40) synsoy 4eoposngy f-§ JTEVL-_—_ ee
103
102 
toa ‘TREND SYSTEMS
 
breakout, a percentage swing makes it more or less sensitive to price movements. Point-and-figure uses a constant box size, which is then multiplied by 3 to get the reversal size.
Tests shown in Table 5-3 for the Eurodollar confirm a broad range of trading from veryshort-term to very long-term. The number of trades varies from over 500 in 10 years (about2,500 days) to 6 trades in 10 years. Some showed a fairly high minimum number of tradesfor the longest periods.
Different Trend Philosophies
‘The moving average, exponential, and linear regression are time-series processes; that is,each day is a small part of the total calculation. This can make it very difficult for a singlelarge price jump to cause a change of signal. For very fast trends, each price will have moreimportance than for slower trends.
The N-day breakout, swing breakout, and point-and-figure systems all depend on aprice breakout. A signal occurs when the market makes a new high or low. Therefore, a sin-gle big move often causes a new signal. Breakout systems can be considered event driven,while a moving average system requires a trend to evolve.
Different Risk Profiles
Each of the six systems fall into particular categories of risk profiles.
Moving Averages and Exponential Smoothing
Both the moving average and exponential smoothing return a weighted average. The sim-ple moving average uses equal weighting, and the exponential gives more importance tothe most recent value, according to the smoothing constant, s.
Both systems are considered conservation-of-capital methods because they keeplosses small. When current price levels are trading near the n-day average, it takes very lit-tle to change the trend from up to down and back to up. Although this is annoying totraders, it is part of the conservation-of-capital benefit. Table 5-3 shows that the minimumnumber of trades were 42 to 44 for these systems, far greater than the other four strategies.The whipsaws seem to increase as the trends become very slow, which is the reason forusing a filter,-or band, in most trend systems. In Table 5-3 the number of trades doubledwhen the trend slowed from 150 to 200 days. ‘
Breakout Systems
The swing breakout, point-and-figure, and N-day breakout systems can all be grouped ashigh-risk strategies. Once a buy signal has occurred because of new high prices, the tradeis reversed only when new low prices occur. The initial risk is —
breakout risk = highest high — lowest low
for the N-day period. The rate at which risk declines is different for each of the systems. The _
swing breakout and point and figure systems reduce risk each time a new swing low occursonly if that low is higher than the previous swing low (see Figure 5-5). The N-day breakoutreduces risk if the oldest days, which are dropped off, were also the lowest prices. Other-wise, its risk is the same as the other breakout systems.
Linear Regression Risk
The linear regression method, which creates a straight-line forecast, is very different fromother trending systems. It does not change direction when prices move up or down.through the trendline (as in the smoothing systems). It is possible that a very large, but fastprice drop, which recovers quickly, will not cause a long position signal to reverse.
 
 
COMPARISON OF MAJOR TREND SYSTEMS 105
—_—FIGURE 5-5 Swing breakout risk pattern. As prices move lower, the swing highs become thepoint at which signals reverse. This pattern is the same for point-and-figure.
reversal 1
 
—reversal 2
sell—reversal 3
ne,
Least squares puts the greatest importance on those prices closest to the straight-lineestimate. It is very sluggish to change direction when a larger number of days is used.Because of this pattern, it can have a mixture of large and small losses.
Frequency of Trades
‘You might notice that thé number of trades varies considerably across systems. This reflectstheir risk. The longer you hold a trade, the greater the risk exposure. The two smoothingsystems (moving average and exponential smoothing) cut losses short; therefore, theyshow the largest number of trades for a slow trend. ; /
Breakout systems can trade very little if they enter on.a new high after a volatile mar-ket period. A long position can be held for months waiting for the swing low to move up.‘An expanding range, one that makes a new high, followed by a new low and another newhigh, can be devastating.
ExpectationsWe form expectations so that we can recognize when test results are wrong. It is the sameas an engineer estimating the length of a bridge before a computer program produces thefinal numbers. An accidental shift of a decimal point may give you plans for a 10-foot bridgeover a 100-foot river. -
Similar Systems Give Similar Results Ch 1imi les are‘We expect the first two and last two systems to be very similar. In each case the rules a1nearly the same. We expect the N-day breakout to have the highest risk because volatilityincreases over time. The n-day high and low should create a much larger range than themost recent swing high and low. Of course, we expect slower systems to be more profitablethan faster ones, because longer periods often reflect fundamental price movements.
Robust Testing -
‘To get the most value from these tests (an approach covered in detail in Chapter 21), thereneeds to be as much consistency as possible between tests. The following, standards are set:
= iod, ending1. Test periods. Al markets and all tests covered the same 10-year period,March ot, 1994 (except the OEX, which began in 1986 and totaled 9 years).2. Range of trend speeds. Those systems that used days were tested from 4 to 200. Sys-tems 5 and 6, swing breakout and point-and-figure, used values that produced a
similar number of trades. 
Bad TREND SYSTEMS
3. Adjusted rate of return. Returns were specified as the 10-year return divided by themaximum intraday drawdown.
4. Test averages. Below each test group are the averages of all tests, the standard devi-ation of the total returns, and the average minus one standard deviation. The best
result is the system with the highest average return and the smallest standard devi-ation.
Which System Is Best?
Table 5-4 gives only the average returns by system and market. It then averages thoseresults down and to the right, giving the average of averages. Results show that Eurodollarswere profitable for all systems and that the N-day breakout had the best returns for all mar-kets. In trying to understand the results, it is useful to remove those tests that resulted invery few trades or too many trades to be practical. Table 5-5 presents the same results forall results with the number of trades from