The use of torture techniques by the US government, as a tool to obtain intelligence from individuals linked to terrorist organizations after the September 11 catastrophe, has given rise to significant philosophical reflection and examination. What is your philosophical assessment of this issue?
The philosophy of virtue ethics highlights the glaring inconsistency between the practice of torture and the virtues of compassion, empathy, and benevolenceIt is imperative that these core values shape the decisions and actions of not only private citizens but also those occupying positions of authority and influence.
With a philosophical analysis from a consequentialist perspective, the avoidance of torture is paramount since it often fails to elicit truthful confessions and may generate fraudulent information, leading to misguided investigationsAdditionally, it may subject innocent individuals to cruel treatment.
With a philosophical analysis from a consequentialist perspective, the avoidance of torture is paramount since it often fails to elicit truthful confessions and may generate fraudulent information, leading to misguided investigationsAdditionally, it may subject innocent individuals to cruel treatment. Philosophically and analytically speaking, the application of torture is never justifiable as it violates the fundamental principle of showing respect and value towards all human beings. The philosophy of virtue ethics highlights the glaring inconsistency between the practice of torture and the virtues of compassion, empathy, and benevolenceIt is imperative that these core values shape the decisions and actions of not only private citizens but also those occupying positions of authority and influence.