Received wrong color

I have fair to medium skin tone so I ordered 'Cafe A Lait' because it appeared to be slightly lighter than 'Natural'. Instead, I received 'Cafe AU Lait', a different color entirely. I'm not sure if 'cafe A lait' exists and there was just a typo when entering AU lait, but it still doesn't make sense because AU lait was an option as we'll, and it appeared much darker. Either way, I'm disappointed because I don't want to deal with paying to return these because someone shipped me the wrong order and risk receiving another wrong color.