They seemed to be OK at first but the little tab in the back broke after a couple uses because they are very difficult to get on. I'm tempted to give them a 2 star review because I had to return them and get something else but maybe it's just my feet so I'll give them the benefit of the doubt and let others tell their stories. I would have to say that the quality is questionable due to the pull tab in the back breaking. I didn't really get enough time wearing them to tell you much about the long term comfort. As new boots, they were comfortable enough to walk 20 minutes in the rain to get to work which is the reason I bought them (and biking to work in the rain).