Wall-Modeled and Hybrid Large-Eddy Simulations of the Flow over Roughness Strips

The flow over alternating roughness strips oriented normally to the mean stream is studied using wall-modeled large-eddy simulations (WMLES) and improved delayed detached-eddy simulations (IDDES) (a hybrid method solving the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) equations near the wall and switching to large-eddy simulations (LES) in the core of the flow). The calculations are performed in an open-channel configuration. Various approaches are used to account for roughness by either modifying the wall boundary condition for WMLES or the model itself for IDDES or by adding a drag forcing term to the momentum equations. By comparing the numerical results with the experimental data, both methods with both roughness modifications are shown to reproduce the non-equilibrium effects, but noticeable differences are observed. The WMLES, although affected by the underlying equilibrium assumption, predicts the return to equilibrium of the skin friction in good agreement with the experiments. The velocity predicted by the IDDES does not have memory of the upstream conditions and recovers to the equilibrium conditions faster. Memory of the upstream conditions appears to be a critical factor for the accurate computational modeling of this flow.