Evolutionary effects of individual variation and dimensionality of higher-order interactions on robustness of species coexistence

Although the eco-evolutionary effects of individual variation for species coexistence are still widely debated, theoretical evidence appears to support a negative impact on coexistence. Mechanistic models of eco-evolutionary effects of individual variation focus largely on pairwise interactions, while the dynamics of communities where both pairwise and higher-order interactions (HOIs) are pervasive are not known. In addition, most studies have focused on effects of high dimensional HOIs on species coexistence when in reality such HOIs could be highly structured and low-dimensional, as species interactions could primarily be mediated through phenotypic traits. Here, combining quantitative genetics and Lotka-Volterra equations, we explored the eco-evolutionary effects of individual variation on the patterns of species coexistence in a competitive community dictated by pairwise interactions and HOIs. Specifically, we compare six different models in which HOIs were modelled to be trait-mediated (low-dimensional) or random (high-dimensional) and evaluated its impact on robustness of species coexistence in the presence of different levels of individual variation. Across the six different models, we found that individual variation did not promote species coexistence, irrespective of whether interactions were pairwise or were of higher-order. However, individual trait variation could stabilize communities to external perturbation more so when interactions were of higher order. When compared across models, species coexistence is promoted when HOIs strengthen pairwise intraspecific competition more so than interspecific competition, and when HOIs act in a hierarchical manner. Additionally, across the models, we found that species’ traits tend to cluster together when individual variation in the community was low. We argue that, while individual variation can influence community patterns in many different ways, they more often lead to fewer species coexisting together.