Reuse of a wing venation gene-regulatory network in patterning the eyespot rings of butterflies

Novel organismal traits might reuse ancestral gene-regulatory networks (GRNs) in their development, but data supporting this mechanism are still sparse. Here we propose that a conserved venation gene network, used in patterning insect wings, has been recruited to pattern the sharp and distinct rings of color in butterfly eyespot development. This network involves Decapentaplegic (Dpp), acting as a central morphogen, activating optix and spalt at different concentration thresholds. It also involves Spalt cross-regulating optix resulting in the formation of a sharp boundary between the two genes. First, using in situ hybridizations, we show that dpp is expressed in the eyespot centers during the early pupal stage and that CRISPR-Cas9 embryonic knockouts of dpp, optix, and spalt result in the loss of eyespots, loss of the orange ring, and loss of the black scales, respectively. Furthermore, using RNAi during the pupal stage, we show that dpp down-regulation results in the complete or partial loss of eyespots. Using CRISPR disruptions of optix or spalt, followed by immunostainings, we show that Spalt represses optix in the central region of the eyespot, limiting optix expression to a more peripheral ring. We further illustrate that optix disruptions alter scale pigmentation and scale ultrastructure as they transform orange to brown scales. Altogether, the regulatory interactions between dpp, spalt and optix mimic those found in earlier larval developmental stages, in the anterior compartment of an insect’s wing, where these genes play a role in venation patterning. The network similarities suggest that the venation GRN was co-opted to aid in the differentiation of the eyespot rings.