Beyond mean fitness: demographic stochasticity and resilience matter at tree species climatic edges

Aim Linking local population dynamics and species distributions is critical to predicting the impacts of climate change. While many studies focus on the mean fitness of populations, theory shows that species distributions can be shaped by demographic stochasticity or population resilience. Here we examine how mean fitness (measured by invasion rate), demographic stochasticity, and resilience (measured by the ability to recover from disturbance) constrain populations at the edges compared to the climatic center. Location Europe: Spain, France, Germany, Finland, and Sweden. Period Forest inventory data used for fitting the models cover the period from 1985 to 2013. Major taxa Dominant European tree species; Angiosperms and Gymnosperms. Methods We developed dynamic population models covering the entire life cycle of 25 European tree species with climatically dependent recruitment models fitted to forest inventory data. We then ran simulations using integral projection and individual-based models to test how invasion rates, risk of stochastic extinction, and ability to recover from stochastic disturbances differ between the center and edges of species’ climatic niches. Results Results varied among species, but in general, demographic constraints were stronger at warm edges and for species in harsher climates. Conversely, recovery was more limiting at cold edges. In addition, we found that for several species, constraints at the edges were due to demographic stochasticity and recovery capacity rather than mean fitness. Main conclusion Our results highlight that mean fitness is not the only mechanism at play at the edges; demographic stochasticity and population capacity to recover also matter for European tree species. To understand how climate change will drive species range shifts, future studies will need to analyse the interplay between population mean growth rate and stochastic demographic processes as well as disturbances.