Medical Decision Making for Unrepresented Patients: A Reflection on Colorado’s Approach with Implications for Elsewhere

Unrepresented patients are some of the most vulnerable patients encountered in the healthcare system today. One of the challenges associated with healthcare for unrepresented patients is the lack of a standardized legal approach to decision making for this highly vulnerable population. Current statutory approaches vary widely without best practices or consensus guidelines. In 2016, Colorado passed a medical proxy law that established a process for the appointment of an independent physician to serve as a temporary proxy decision maker for an unrepresented patient. Although this approach helps to identify a decision maker when no proxy is available, the appropriate standards for decision making remain uncertain. A peer-to-peer session at the Clinical Ethics Unconference in 2022 approached this conundrum with a focus on the best interests standard and the appropriate use of patients’ context in decision making.