Comparison of Drivetrain Topologies for an Ankle Gait Cycle

Powered prosthesis actuation is a field where energy efficiency and mass are important characteristics. The motion requirements of high torque at low speed and low torque at high speed are difficult to effectively combine in a single electric motor. A possibility is to use an oversized direct–drive motor that can deliver the peak torque. However, this results in a heavy actuation system and low overall efficiency. A common practice is combining a smaller electric motor with a gear reduction system. In the literature, novel redundant electric actuation systems have been presented with or without locking mechanisms to mitigate this problem. In this work, we provide a comparison of multiple electrical actuation systems composed of electric motors, gear reduction systems and locking mechanisms. This is done using the gait cycle of a human ankle as a case study. An electric motor with a double stator and a single rotor combined with a gearbox shows the most promising overall results when taking energy loss, total mass and complexity of the system into account.