COMMON POSITION (EC) No 10/1999 adopted by the Council on 21 December 1998 with a view to adopting Council Regulation (EC) No .../1999 of ... on a Community-fleet capacity policy to promote inland waterway transport
25. 2. 1999 EN Official Journal of the European Communities C 55/25 COMMON POSITION (EC) No 10/1999 adopted by the Council on 21 December 1998 with a view to adopting Council Regulation (EC) No. /1999 of. on a Community-fleet capacity policy to promote inland waterway transport (1999/C 55/03) THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION, Having regard to the Treaty establishing the European Community, and in particular Article 75 thereof, Having regard to the proposal from the Commission (1), Having regard to the opinion of the Economic and Social Committee (2), Acting in accordance with the procedure laid down in Article 189c of the Treaty (3), into service as soon as in the event of a serious disturbance on the same market, as defined in Article 1 of Directive 96/75/EC (5); whereas steps should be taken to prevent the benefits from the scrapping schemes conducted since 1990 being wiped out by new capacity coming the abovementioned rule ends; whereas it is therefore necessary to retain the ‘old-for-new’ rule for a limited period of not more than four years while gradually reducing the ratios to zero to safeguard the transition the Community-market intervention stage; whereas it is also important to maintain the ‘old-for-new’ instrument for regulating the capacity of the Community fleets beyond these four years, but as a standby mechanism set at zero which could be reactivated only in the event of serious market disturbance of the kind referred to in Article 7 of Directive 96/75/EC; and end (1) Whereas Regulation of arrangements (EEC) No for 1101/89 (4) introduced structural improvements in the inland waterway sector for the fleets operating on the linked inland waterway networks France, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Austria; whereas the objective of that Regulation was to reduce overcapacity in the inland waterway fleets by means of at Community level; whereas that Regulation expires on 28 April 1999; Belgium, Germany, vessel-scrapping coordinated schemes (2) Whereas of the measures to support these structural improvement arrangements with the aim of avoiding aggravation of the emergence of further overcapacity, the ‘old-for-new’ rule has proved indispensable to balanced operation of the inland waterway market; whereas this rule also remains an essential instrument for intervention existing overcapacity or (1) OJ C 320, 17. 10. 1998, p. 4. (2) Opinion delivered on 2 December 1998 (not yet published in the Official Journal). (3) Opinion of the European Parliament of 3 December 1998 (OJ C 398, 21. 12. 1998), common position of the Council of 21 December 1998 and Decision of the European Parliament of. (not yet published in the Official Journal). (4) OJ L 116, 28. 4. 1989, p. 25. Regulation last amended by Commission Regulation (EC) No 742/98 of 2 April 1998 (OJ L 103, 3. 4. 1998, p. 3). (3) Whereas the emergence of new overcapacity must be kept in check effectively in every branch of the inland waterway transport market; whereas it is therefore important that the measures to be adopted should be generally applicable and cover all cargo vessels and pusher craft; whereas there should be exemption from such measures for vessels which, because they operate solely on closed national or international markets, in no way contribute to the overcapacity on the network of inland waterways and provision should be made for the possibility of exempting vessels which, because their deadweight tonnage is less than 450 tonnes, also do not contribute to such overcapacity; whereas, by fleets performing own-account contrast, private operations cannot be excluded because of their impact on transport markets; linked (4) Whereas a common approach allowing Member States to take joint measures to attain the same objective is a sine qua non for regulating capacity; whereas to this end the scrapping funds introduced by Regulation (EEC) No 1101/89 in the Member States with inland waterways should be maintained, (5) Council Directive 96/75/EC of 19 November 1996 on the system of chartering and pricing in national and international inland waterway transport in the Community (OJ L 304, 27. 11. 1996, p. 12). C 55/26 EN Official Journal of the European Communities 25. 2. 1999 the but under a new designation, and should administer this ‘old-for-new’ rule; whereas the surplus funds from to structural improvement schemes conducted up until 28 April 1999 should be placed in a reserve fund attached to the abovementioned funds; industry’s contributions should be conferred on safeguard the conditions of competition laid down in this Regulation the Commission; whereas important that the it Commission take such decisions after consulting the Member States and the organisations representing inland waterway transport at Community level; is (5) Whereas, in view of the fundamental differences between the dry cargo, liquid cargo and pusher craft markets, it is advisable to keep separate accounts in each fund for dry cargo carriers, tanker vessels and pusher craft; therefore be borne by the Treaty, responsibility (6) Whereas, in the context of an economic policy compatible with for capacity regulation lies primarily with operators in the sector; whereas the cost of the measures introduced should the undertakings in the inland waterway sector; whereas this capacity regulation consists of laying down the conditions to apply for bringing into service certain new capacity without going so far as totally blocking access to the market; whereas it is possible to limit the duration and impact of these conditions and to adjust them flexibly to market trends but the ratios must gradually be reduced to zero within four years starting on 29 April 1999; whereas this regulatory mechanism designated the ‘old-for-new’ rule should be maintained as a standby mechanism once the ratio reaches zero; whereas the special contributions paid under the ‘old-for-new’ rule should be placed in the reserve fund and may be used for granting scrapping premiums, if intervention in the market proves necessary; (7) Whereas it is desirable to ensure that the measures provided for in this Regulation and implementation thereof do not distort, or threaten to distort, competition, in particular by favouring certain undertakings to an extent which is contrary to the common interest; whereas, in order to place the in similar conditions of enterprises concerned competition, the special contributions to be paid to the funds covering the building of new craft and the scrapping premiums, if such premiums prove necessary in the event of a serious disturbance of the market and in accordance with the procedure provided for in Article 8 of Directive 96/75/EC, should be set at uniform rates and on uniform terms; (9) Whereas, in connection with the modernisation and restructuring of the Community fleets to create a context favourable to the environment and safety, social measures should be envisaged to help workers who wish to leave the inland waterway industry or to retrain for jobs in another sector, together with establishment of measures groupings of undertakings, to improve operators’ skills and to promote adaptation of the vessels to technical progress, encourage the to HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION: Article 1 Inland waterway vessels used to carry goods between two or more points by inland waterway in the Member States shall be subject to the Community-fleet capacity policy laid down in this Regulation. For a period of not more than four years with effect from 29 April 1999 this capacity policy shall include the conditions for bringing into service new capacities, in accordance with this Regulation. Article 2 1. This Regulation shall apply to cargo-carrying vessels and pusher craft providing transport services on own account or for hire or reward and registered in a Member State or, if not registered, operated by an undertaking established in a Member State. (8) Whereas, since the inland waterway fleets are Community fleets, decisions on operation of this capacity-regulation mechanism should be taken at Community level; whereas the power to adopt such decisions, to see to implementation thereof and to For the purposes of this Regulation, ‘undertaking’ shall mean any natural or legal person exercising an economic activity on a non-industrial or industrial scale. 25. 2. 1999 EN Official Journal of the European Communities C 55/27 The 2. Regulation: following shall be exempt from this (a) vessels operating exclusively on national waterways not linked to other waterways in the Community; (b) vessels which, owing to their dimensions, cannot leave the national waterways on which they operate and cannot enter the other waterways of the Community (captive vessels), provided that such vessels are not likely to compete with vessels covered by this Regulation; (c) vessels operating exclusively on the Danube (and its tributaries) up to Kelheim without leaving it; (d) pusher craft with a motive power not exceeding 300 kilowatts; (e) sea-going inland waterways vessels and ship-borne barges used exclusively for international or national transport operations during voyages which include a sea crossing; (f) vessels used exclusively for storage of goods, i. e. vessels used for loading and subsequently unloading goods at the same place; (g) dredging equipment, such as hopper vessels and pontoons and floating construction plant, provided that such equipment is not used for the carriage of goods within the meaning of Article 1; (h) ferries; (i) vessels providing a non-profit-making public service. 3. Each Member State concerned within the meaning of Article 3(1) may exclude its vessels with a deadweight tonnage of less than 450 tonnes from the scope of this Regulation. Where a Member State avails itself of this option, it shall notify the Commission accordingly within six months; the Commission shall inform the other Member States. Article 3 1. Each Member State whose inland waterways are linked to those of another Member State and the tonnage of whose fleet is above 100 000 tonnes, hereinafter referred to as ‘the Member State concerned’, shall set up, under its own administrative resources, an inland waterways fund, hereinafter referred to as ‘the Fund’. legislation and with its national The competent authorities in the Member State 2. concerned shall administer the Fund. Each Member State shall its national organisations representing inland waterway carriers in this administration. involve 3. Each Fund shall have a reserve fund consisting of three separate accounts: one for dry cargo carriers, one for tanker vessels and one for pusher craft. This reserve fund shall be financed by: — the surplus funding from the structural improvement schemes conducted up until 28 April 1999, consisting solely of financial contributions from the industry, — the special contributions referred to in Article 4, — the financial resources which could be made available in the event of serious disturbance of the market, as referred to in Article 7 of Directive 96/75/EC. 4. The reserve fund may be used in connection with the suitable measures referred to in Article 7 of Directive 96/75/EC and, in the course of the improvement measures organised at Community level in accordance with the procedure defined in paragraph 6 and Article 6 of this Regulation. in particular, The reserve fund may be used in the course of 5. if unanimously in Article 8 measures referred to requested by inland the organisations representing waterway transport. In this case, the measures must be the subject of an action at Community level. 6. There shall be mutual financial support between the Funds with regard to the separate accounts mentioned in the first subparagraph of paragraph 3. This shall come into play for all the expenditure and all the funding mentioned in the second subparagraph of paragraph 3, so as to guarantee equal treatment for all carriers subject to this Regulation, independently of the Fund to which the vessel belongs. The Member States concerned shall continue to 7. administer the Fund referred to in Article 3 of Regulation (EEC) No 1101/89 until the new Fund referred to in paragraph 1 is set up. C 55/28 EN Official Journal of the European Communities 25. 2. 1999 Article 4 1. Vessels covered by this Regulation, whether newly constructed, imported from a third country or due to leave the waterways mentioned in Article 2(2)(a), (b) or (c), may be brought into service subject to the condition (the old-for-new rule) that the owner of the vessel to be brought into service: Any Member State concerned may permit vessels definitively withdrawn from the market for use for purposes other than the carriage of goods, such as vessels for humanitarian purposes, museum ships, vessels for developing countries outside Europe or vessels placed at the disposal of non-profit-making bodies, to be counted as compensatory tonnage, i. e. treated as if they had been scrapped. It shall communicate such permission to the Commission, which shall inform the other Member States concerned. — either scraps, without receiving a scrapping premium, tonnage in line with the ratio between old and new tonnage set by the Commission, In the case of pusher craft, the concept of ‘tonnage’ 4. shall be replaced by that of ‘motive power’. — or pays into the Fund covering the new vessel, or into the Fund chosen by the vessel-owner in accordance with Article 5(2), a special contribution based on the abovementioned ratio or, if the owner scraps a tonnage smaller than required by the abovementioned ratio, pays the difference between the tonnage of the new vessel and the tonnage scrapped. 2. The ratio may be set at different levels for different sectors of the market, i. e. dry cargo carriers, tanker vessels and pusher craft. The ratio shall be constantly reduced to bring it as quickly as possible and in regular stages to zero no later than 29 April 2003. Once the ratio has been set at zero, the arrangements shall become a standby mechanism and may be reactivated only in the event of a serious disturbance of the market, as provided for by Article 6. The owner of the vessel must have the choice 3. between paying the special contribution or scrapping old tonnage: — either at the time that the firm order for construction of the new vessel is placed or at the time that the application for import is lodged, provided the vessel is brought into service within twelve months thereafter, — or at the time that the new or imported vessel is brought into service. The choice of time must be stated when ordering or applying to import the vessel. The conditions laid down in paragraph 1 shall also 5. apply to in capacity resulting from the lengthening of a vessel or the replacement of pusher-craft engines. increases After consulting 6. the organisations representing inland waterway transport at Community exempt specialised vessels from the scope of paragraph 1. the Member States and the Commission may level, The specialised vessels must be specially and technically designed to carry a single type of goods and technically unsuitable for carrying other goods, it must be impossible to carry this single type of goods in vessels without special technical installations and the owners of the vessels must give a written undertaking that no other goods will be carried in their vessels as long as the ‘old-for-new’ rule applies. Article 5 1. For vessels registered in one of the Member States concerned, the special contribution shall be paid into the Fund of the Member State where the vessel is registered. For non-registered vessels operated by an undertaking established in one of the Member States concerned, the special contribution shall be paid into the Fund of the Member State in which the undertaking is established. 2. The special contribution for vessels registered in a Member State other than a Member State concerned or for non-registered vessels operated by an undertaking established in a Member State other than a Member State concerned shall be paid into one of the Funds set up in the Member States concerned, at the choice of the vessel-owner. The vessel offered for scrapping as compensatory tonnage must have been scrapped before the new vessel is brought into service. Article 6 Owners of vessels to be brought into service who have a higher tonnage than necessary scrapped shall receive no financial compensation for this surplus. In the event of serious disturbance on the market, as defined in Article 7 of Directive 96/75/EC and, at the request of a Member State, after the committee referred to in Article 8 of the said Directive has given its opinion 25. 2. 1999 EN Official Journal of the European Communities C 55/29 and following the procedure laid down in the same Article, the Commission may reactivate the ‘old-for-new’ rule for a limited period, in accordance with Article 7 of the said Directive, accompanied or not by structural improvement measures. Under such structural improvement measures owners of vessels referred to in Article 2(1) who scrap a vessel, i. e. who have the hull of the vessel broken up totally or, in the case of pusher craft, destroy the hull and the engine, may receive a scrapping premium at the rate set by the Commission under the conditions laid down in Article 7 from the Fund covering the vessel insofar as the financial resources are available. However, this premium may be granted only in respect of vessels which the owner proves form part of his active fleet, i. e. : — vessels which are in good working order and — vessels for which the owner can produce valid certificates of water worthiness and tonnage or an authorisation to engage in national transport issued by the competent authority of one of the Member States concerned and — vessels which have made at least 10 voyages during the 24 months preceding application for the scrapping premium. ‘Voyage’ shall mean a commercial transport operation over a distance normal for the carriage of goods of the same type (over 50 km) and carrying a volume of cargo in reasonable proportion to the cargo capacity of the vessel (at least 70 %). No premium shall be granted in respect of vessels which, as a result of a wreck or other damage suffered, are no longer repairable or for which the repair costs are higher than the amount of the scrapping premium. Where the competent authorities have well-founded reasons to doubt that the vessel covered by the application for the scrapping premium in good working order, they may request a surveyor to certify that the vessel concerned is in a technical condition to carry goods. The scrapping premium shall be refused if the vessel fails to meet this requirement. is Article 7 After consulting the Member States and the 1. organisations representing inland waterway transport at Community lay down level, the Commission shall separately for dry cargo carriers, for tankers and for pusher craft: — the rate of the special contributions, — the period during which scrapping premiums referred to in Article 6 will be paid, the conditions for granting them and the rates, — the adjustment coefficients (equivalent tonnage) for each type and category of inland waterway vessel. 2. The special contributions and scrapping premiums shall be expressed in euros. The rates applying shall be the same for each Fund. 3. The special contributions and scrapping premiums shall be calculated for cargo-carrying vessels on the basis of the deadweight tonnage and for pusher craft on the basis of the motive power of the vessel. After consulting the Member States and 4. the organisations representing inland waterway transport at Community lay down level, the Commission shall detailed rules for the mutual financial support referred to in Article 3(6). 5. The decisions reached by the Commission shall also take account of the results of observation of the transport markets in the Community and of any foreseeable changes therein, as well as of the need to avoid any distortion of competition to an extent which is contrary to the common interest. In order to contribute to observation of the market, owners of vessels built or imported must inform the Funds six months before these vessels are brought into service. Article 8 Without prejudice to Article 3(5), any Member State may take measures in particular to: — make it easier for inland waterway carriers leaving the industry to obtain an early retirement pension or to transfer to another economic activity, — organise vocational training or re-training schemes for workers leaving the industry, — encourage private owner-operators to join trade associations, — the ratios for the ‘old-for-new’ rule for the vessels referred to in Article 2, — encourage adaptation of vessels to technical progress in order to improve working conditions and promote technical safety requirements, C 55/30 EN Official Journal of the European Communities 25. 2. 1999 — improve operators’ skills in order to safeguard the development and future of the trade. Article 9 1. Member States shall adopt the measures necessary to implement this Regulation and shall notify the Commission thereof. These measures shall provide, inter alia, for permanent and effective verification of compliance with the obligations imposed on undertakings by this Regulation and the national provisions adopted in implementation thereof, and for appropriate penalties in the event of infringement. shall States the 2. Member Commission annually all information on progress with the ‘old-for-new’ scheme and on the financial position of the Funds and of their reserve fund. communicate relevant to The Commission shall adopt the decisions which it 3. is required to take under Article 7. 4. The Commission shall ensure that the Funds apply this Regulation uniformly and shall ensure coordination thereof. Article 10 This Regulation shall enter into force on 29 April 1999. This Regulation shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in all Member States. Done at. For the Council The President 25. 2. 1999 EN Official Journal of the European Communities C 55/31 STATEMENT OF THE COUNCIL’S REASONS I. INTRODUCTION On 28 September 1998 the Commission submitted to the Council a proposal for a Council Regulation on a Community-fleet capacity policy inland waterway transport (1). to promote The proposal is based on Article 75 of the EC Treaty. The European Parliament delivered its opinion on the Commission proposal on 3 December 1998 (2) and the Economic and Social Committee delivered its opinion on 2 December 1998 (3). On 11 December 1998 the Commission submitted an amended proposal to the Council in the light of the European Parliament’s opinion. The Council adopted a common position on 21 December 1998 pursuant to Article 189c of the EC Treaty. II. OBJECTIVES OF THE PROPOSAL The amended Commission proposal is intended to replace Council Regulation (EEC) No 1101/89 of 27 April 1989 on structural improvements in inland waterway transport (4), which expires on 28 April 1999. The Regulation provides for the reduction of fleet overcapacity in inland waterway transport through vessel scrapping measures coordinated at Community level. The Commission proposal seeks to maintain the market-regulation mechanism currently in force (old-for-new rule) for a maximum period of five years, in order to prevent the effects of the scrapping measures carried out since 1990 being nullified by the bringing into service of new capacity just after the expiry of Regulation (EEC) No 1101/89. During this period, the owner of a vessel to be brought into service must: — either scrap, without receiving a scrapping premium, tonnage in line with the ratio between old and new tonnage set by the Commission, — pay a special contribution into the inland waterways fund. The Commission proposes that the ratio be gradually reduced to zero over the aforementioned five-year period. As soon as the ratio has been fixed at zero or at the end of the above period at the latest, the market-regulation mechanism would be turned into a standby mechanism which, solely in the event of a serious market crisis and for a limited period of time, would allow the ‘old-for-new’ rule to be reactivated, whether or not accompanied by structural improvement measures. (1) OJ C 320, 17. 10. 1998, p. 4. (2) OJ C 398, 23. 12. 1998. (3) CES 1449/98. (4) OJ L 116, 28. 4. 1989, p. 25. Regulation last amended by Commission Regulation (EC) No 742/98 of 2 April 1998 (OJ L 103, 3. 4. 1998, p. 3). C 55/32 EN Official Journal of the European Communities 25. 2. 1999 III. ANALYSIS OF THE COUNCIL’S COMMON POSITION The Council’s common position basically corresponds to the amended Commission proposal. There are however a number of changes, the main ones being as follows: — the maximum period of application of the ‘old-for-new’ rule is reduced from five to four years starting from 29 April 1999 (recitals (2) and (6), Article 1 and Article 4(2)), — the ratio must be continually reduced to bring it as quickly as possible and in regular stages to zero, within four years at the latest from 29 April 1999 (recital (6) and Article 4(2)), — Member States have the option of excluding vessels under 450 tonnes from the scope of the Regulation (as stipulated in Regulation No 1101/89 currently in force) (recital (3) and Article 2(3)), — the surplus funds from structural improvement schemes intended for the reserve fund will be derived solely from financial contributions from the industry (recital (4) and Article 3(3)), — the decisions to be taken by the Commission on the operation of the ‘old-for-new’ rule will be subject to prior consultation of the Member States and the organisations representing inland waterway transport at Community level (recital (8) and Articles 7(1) and (4)), — deletion of Article 9 and the corresponding recital, as proposed by the Commission, dealing with the negotiations which the Community should initiate with Switzerland and other third countries for the implementation of the Regulation. The Council thought that such a measure did not constitute a mandate given by the Council to the Commission but was rather an indication of a political nature. The Council and the Commission, however, consider it desirable that Switzerland adopt measures similar to those in this Regulation for its fleet sailing on interconnected inland waterways of the Member States concerned in order to prevent distortion of competition on the inland waterway market and to increase the efficiency of Community measures dealing with that market. IV. EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AMENDMENTS 1. European Parliament amendments adopted by the Council (a) T a k e n u p b y t h e C o m m i s s i o n The Council followed the Commission’s amended proposal and adopted the following European Parliament amendments: — Article 4(2) of the common position takes over amendment 4 which provides that the ‘old-for-new’ rule can be reactivated only in the event of a serious disturbance of the market, which is to be understood not within the meaning of Article 7 of Directive 96/75/EC but within the meaning of Article 6 of the common position. The common position does not, however, take up amendment 6 providing for a change to Article 6(1) (Article 6 of the common position, see IV. 2 below), — Article 4(3) of the common position takes over amendment 5 which reduces to 12 months the 18-month period proposed by the Commission for bringing a vessel into service. 25. 2. 1999 EN Official Journal of the European Communities C 55/33 (b) N o t t a k e n u p b y t h e C o m m i s s i o n Article 1 of the common position incorporates the substance of the first part of amendment 2 which includes the idea of bringing into service not new vessels, but new capacity. 2. European Parliament amendments not adopted by the Council and not taken up by the Commission The Council, following the amended Commission proposal, did not adopt: — amendments 1, 2 and 7 on the reintroduction of the scrapping scheme: — amendment 1, designed to incorporate into the Regulation a new recital to the effect that it was necessary to ensure that the scrapping scheme did not lead to the disappearance of all low-tonnage vessels, — the second part of amendment 2, designed to modify Article 1 to restore the scrapping scheme, which would be phased out over the transitional period, in conjunction with the gradual elimination of the ‘old-for-new’ rule, — amendment 7, intended to incorporate into the Regulation a new Article 6a taking over Article 1 from Regulation no 1101/89 to clarify the structural improvement measures to which inland waterway vessels would be subject. The Council considers that the aim of the common position is to maintain what has been achieved by the scrapping measures since 1989, rather than instituting new structural improvement measures, with new capacity brought into service being offset by old capacity scrapped. In the Council’s view, Community intervention must be phased out to achieve a policy of free capacity on a market which will be fully liberalised as from 1 January 2000. The Council considers that vessels must not be subject to scrapping measures after 29 April 1999 and that only the capacity-regulating mechanism constituted by the ‘old-for-new’ rule should be kept for a four-year transitional period, on the understanding that it could be brought into play only in the event of serious disruption of the market. The Council stresses moreover that vessels of under 450 tonnes may be excluded from the scope of the future Regulation, — amendment 3, designed to amend Article 3(6) (Article 3(5) of the common position), providing that, where the reserve fund is used, at the unanimous request of the sector, for the measures referred to in Article 8 (e. g. encouragement from the Member States concerned for workers wishing to leave the sector, etc. ), the Member States concerned are also consulted. The Council notes that the Article 3(5) of the common position provides that the requisite measures must be taken at Community level. The decisions would thus be taken by the Commission, after consulting not just the industry but also the Member States concerned, C 55/34 EN Official Journal of the European Communities 25. 2. 1999 — amendment 6, designed to amend Article 6(1) (Article 6 of the common position), which provides that the Commission may reactivate the ‘old-for-new’ rule, with or without structural improvement measures as well, in the event of serious disruption of the market, in order to add to it that the Commission may take the measures in question only after expiry of the transitional period and thus once the ‘old-for-new’ rule and the scrapping scheme have been abolished. The Council considers that, even though the aim of the common position is to bring the ratios applied under the ‘old-for-new’ scheme to zero as quickly as possible in the four years after 29 April 1999, the Commission needs nonetheless to be given the latitude to act on the ratios, pursuant to Article 6, during the transitional period as well if a serious disruption of the market were to occur during that period which justified keeping, or even hardening, the ratios then in force