Impossibilism
# Impossibilism

Part of a series on :

Marxism :

Theoretical works

Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844

The German Ideology

Wage Labour and Capital

The Communist Manifesto

The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte

Grundrisse der Kritik der Politischen Ökonomie

A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy

Das Kapital

Critique of the Gotha Programme

Dialectics of Nature

Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism

The State and Revolution

History and Class Consciousness

On Contradiction

Prison Notebooks

Dialectic of Enlightenment

The Wretched of the Earth

Guerrilla Warfare

Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses

Women, Race and Class

Empire (Hardt and Negri book) :

Philosophy

Dialectical materialism

Philosophy of nature :

Critique of political economy

Capital (accumulation)

Crisis theory

Commodity

Concrete and abstract labor

Factors of production

Falling profit-rate tendency

Means of production

Mode of production

Asiatic

Capitalist

Socialist

Productive forces

Scientific socialism

Surplus product

Socially necessary labour time

Value-form

Wage labour :

Sociology

Alienation

Base and superstructure

Bourgeoisie

Class

Class consciousness

Class struggle

Classless society

Commodity fetishism

Communist society

Critique of political economy

Cultural hegemony

Democracy

Dictatorship of the proletariat

Exploitation

Human nature

Ideology

Immiseration

Imperialism

Lumpenproletariat

Metabolic rift

Proletariat

Private property

Relations of production

Reification

State theory

Working class :

History

Philosophy in the Soviet Union

Primitive accumulation

Proletarian revolution

World revolution

Theory of historical trajectory :

Aspects

Aesthetics

Archaeology

Criminology

Cultural analysis

Cultural Studies

Ethics

Film theory

Geography

Historiography

Literary criticism

Marxism and religion

Sociology

Philosophy :

Orthodox variants

Analytical

Black

Classical

Feminist

Hegelian

Humanist

Instrumental

Leninism

Trotskyism

Maoism

Neo

Open

Post

Structural

Western

Marxism–Leninism

Anti-revisionism

Marxism–Leninism–Maoism

Gonzalo Thought

Socialism with Chinese characteristics

Titoism :

Left communist variants

Bordigism

Communization

Council communism :

Libertarian variants

Autonomism

Situationism :

Other variants

Austromarxism

Eurocommunism

Neo-Gramscianism

Neue Marx-Lektüre

Revisionist :

People

Marx

Engels

Morris

Lafargue

Kautsky

Plekhanov

Du Bois

Connolly

Lenin

Luxemburg

Kollontai

Hilferding

Trotsky

Grossman

Zinoviev

Bloch

Lukács

Korsch

Bukharin

Bordiga

Ho

Serge

Gramsci

Pashukanis

Nosaka

Benjamin

Mao

Mariátegui

Toledano

Horkheimer

Volpe

Dutt

Brecht

Marcuse

Bordiga

Fromm

Neumann

Lefebvre

James

Adorno

Padmore

Sartre

Deutscher

Beauvoir

Nkrumah

Sweezy

Emmanuel

Hill

Bettelheim

Draper

Jones

Hobsbawm

Althusser

Hinton

Williams

Freire

Mandel

Sivanandan

Miliband

Lefort

Cabral

Thompson

Bauman

Fanon

Kosik

Berger

Castro

Guevara

Heller

Guattari

Mészáros

O'Connor

Wallerstein

Mies

Tronti

Debord

Amin

Hall

Nairn

Parenti

Negri

Jameson

Dussel

Harvey

Laclau

Bahro

Poulantzas

Vattimo

Badiou

Altvater

Anderson

Löwy

Resnick

Vogel

Sison

Easthope

Rancière

Berman

Przeworski

Blackburn

Cohen

Therborn

Ahmad

Losurdo

Ture

Postone

Rodney

Spivak

Newton

Sakai

Wood

Federici

Wolff

Balibar

Eagleton

Hartsock

Rowbotham

Mouffe

Geras

Brenner

Davis

Cleaver

Bishop

Haraway

Panitch

Clarke

Jessop

Davis

Wright

Fraser

Holloway

Screpanti

McLaren

Tamás

Hampton

Cano

Žižek

Sankara

Hennessy

McDonnell

Douzinas

Cockshott

Roediger

Foster

West

Ghandy

Marcos

Tarasov

Prashad

Merrifield

Varoufakis

Kelley

Linera

Fisher

Li

Barker

Coulthard

Malm

Seymour

Toscano

Bhattacharya

Moufawad-Paul

Srnicek

Horvat

Hamza

Saito :

Journals

Capital & Class

Capitalism Nature Socialism

Catalyst

Constellations

Critique: Journal of Socialist Theory

Historical Materialism

Mediations

Monthly Review

New Left Review

Race & Class

Rethinking Marxism

Science & Society

Socialism and Democracy

Socialist Register :

Related topics

21st-century communist theorists

Anarchism

Anarcho-communism

Creative destruction

Critical theory

Criticism of Marxism

Communism

Communalism

Economic determinism

Historical determinism

History of communism

Left-wing politics

Marxian economics

New Left

Old Left

Municipalism

Political ecology

Radical democracy

Social democracy

Socialism

Authoritarian

Democratic

Libertarian

Market

Reformist

Revolutionary

Utopian

Soviet democracy

Left-wing populism

Universal class

Vulgar Marxism

Economism

Worker cooperative

Workers' council :

Related categories Karl Marx

Philosophy of history :

Outline

 Communism portal

 Philosophy portal

 Socialism portal :

vte :

Impossibilism is a Marxist theory that stresses the limited value of political, economic, and social reforms under capitalism. As a doctrine, impossibilism views the pursuit of such reforms as counterproductive to the goal of achieving socialism as they stabilize, and therefore strengthen, support for capitalism. Impossibilism holds that reforms to capitalism are irrelevant or outright counter-productive to the goal of achieving socialism and should not be a major focus of socialist politics.

Impossibilists insist that socialists should primarily or solely focus on structural changes (sometimes termed "revolutionary changes") to society as opposed to advancing social reforms. Impossibilists argue that spontaneous revolutionary action is the only viable method of instituting the structural changes necessary for the construction of socialism; impossibilism is thus held in contrast to reformist socialist parties that aim to rally support for socialism through the implementation of popular social reforms (such as a welfare state). It is also held in contrast to those who believe that socialism can emerge through gradual economic reforms implemented by an elected social democratic political party.

Impossibilism is the opposite of "possibilism" and "immediatism". Possibilism and immediatism are based on a gradualist path to socialism and a desire on the part of socialists to help ameliorate the social ills immediately through practical programs implemented by existing institutions including labor unions and electoral politics, thereby de-emphasizing the ultimate objective of building a socialist economy. This position is justified by the fact that socialists who embraced possibilism sounded and acted little different from non-socialist reformers in practice.

Impossibilist movements are also associated with anti-Leninism in their opposition to both vanguardism and democratic centralism.

## Origins of the concept

The concept of impossibilism—though not the specific term—was introduced and heavily influenced by American Marxist theoretician Daniel De Leon on the basis of theory that De Leon generated before his interest in syndicalism began. It came to be focused especially on the question of whether socialists should take part in government and pursue policy reforms that benefited the working-class under capitalism.

At the Paris Congress of the Second International in 1900, those who favored entry into government with all the implied compromises called themselves "Possibilists" while those who opposed them (those around Jules Guesde) characterized them as political "Opportunists". Conversely, the revolutionary socialists who opposed ameliorative reforms and participation in existing governments were called "Impossibilists" by their detractors because they allegedly sought the impossible by refusing to partake in the governing of capitalism.

While not usually described as an impossibilist, Rosa Luxemburg opposed both reformism and vanguardism, taking the more classical Marxist perspective that revolution would be a spontaneous reaction to underlying material changes in the productive forces of society. According to Luxemburg, "[political and juridical relations of capitalism] is not overthrown, but is on the contrary strengthened and consolidated by the development of social reforms and the course of democracy.".

## Basis in Karl Marx's work

Karl Marx famously critiqued reformism and immediatist/possibilist goals advocated by modern social democrats in his Address of the Central Committee to the Communist League (1850). Specifically, he argued that measures designed to increase wages, improve working conditions and provide welfare payments would be used to dissuade the working class away from socialism and the revolutionary consciousness he believed was necessary to achieve a socialist economy and would thus be a threat to genuine structural changes to society by making the conditions of workers in capitalism more tolerable through reform and welfare schemes.

## Political groups

* French Workers' Party
* Proletarian Party of America
* Social Democratic Federation
* Socialist Party of Great Britain
* Socialist Party of Canada
* Socialist Party of Canada (WSM)
* Socialist Labor Party of America
* World Socialist Party (Ireland)
* World Socialist Party of India
