New York Mutuals all-time roster
# New York Mutuals all-time roster

The New York Mutuals baseball club, established 1859, played five seasons in the National Association, 1871–1875, and one in the National League, 1876. Here is a list of all their players in regular season games beginning 1871.

† Bold names identify members of the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

* Top
* 0–9
* A
* B
* C
* D
* E
* F
* G
* H
* I
* J
* K
* L
* M
* N
* O
* P
* Q
* R
* S
* T
* U
* V
* W
* X
* Y
* Z

## A

* Doug Allison

## B

* Billy Barnie
* George Bechtel
* Steve Bellán
* Eddie Booth
* Bill Boyd
* Jack Burdock

## C

* Tom Carey
* Bill Craver
* Candy $Cummings^†$

## E

* Dave Eggler

## F

* George Fair
* Bob Ferguson
* Frank Fleet
* Davy Force
* Chick Fulmer

## G

* Count Gedney
* Billy Geer
* Joe Gerhardt

## H

* Jimmy Hallinan
* John Hatfield
* John Hayes
* George Heubel
* Nat Hicks
* Dick Higham
* Jim Holdsworth

## L

* Terry Larkin

## M

* John Maloney
* Phonney Martin
* Bobby Mathews
* Pat McGee
* John McGuinness
* John McMullin
* Al Metcalf
* Charlie Mills

## N

* Candy Nelson
* Al Nichols

## P

* Tom Patterson
* Dickey Pearce
* Nealy Phelps

## R

* Jack Remsen

## S

* George Seward
* Jim Shanley
* Orator Shaffer
* Charlie Smith
* Joe Start

## T

* Fred Treacey
* Pete Treacey

## V

* Bob Valentine

## W

* Billy West
* Rynie Wolters
