Philosophical anarchism
# Philosophical anarchism

Part of a series on :

Anarchism :

History

Outline :

Schools of thought

Feminist

Green

Primitivist

Social ecology

Total liberation

Individualist

Egoist

Existentialist

Free-market

Naturist

Philosophical

Mutualism

Postcolonial

African

Black

Queer

Religious

Christian

Jewish

Social

Collectivist

Parecon

Communist

Magonism

Without adjectives

Methodology

Agorism

Illegalism

Insurrectionary

Communization

Expropriative

Pacifist

Platformism

Especifismo

Relationship

Syndicalist

Synthesis :

Theory

Practice

Anarchy

Anarchist Black Cross

Anarchist criminology

Anationalism

Anti-authoritarianism

Anti-capitalism

Anti-militarism

Affinity group

Autonomous social center

Black bloc

Classless society

Class struggle

Consensus decision-making

Conscientious objector

Critique of work

Decentralization

Deep ecology

Direct action

Free association

Free love

Freethought

Horizontalidad

Individualism

Isocracy

Law

Mutual aid

Participatory politics

Permanent autonomous zone

Prefigurative politics

Proletarian internationalism

Propaganda of the deed

Refusal of work

Revolution

Revolutionary spontaneity

Rewilding

Security culture

Self-ownership

Social ecology

Sociocracy

Somatherapy

Spontaneous order

Squatting

Temporary autonomous zone

Union of egoists

Voluntary association

Workers' council :

People

Armand

Ba

Bakunin

Berkman

Bonanno

Bookchin

Chomsky

Cleyre

Day

Durruti

Ellul

Ervin

Faure

Ferrer

Feyerabend

Godwin

Goldman

González Prada

Graeber

Guillaume

He-Yin

Kanno

Kōtoku

Kropotkin

Landauer

Liu

Magón

Makhno

Malatesta

Michel

Most

Parsons

Pi

Proudhon

Rocker

Santillán

Spooner

Stirner

Thoreau

Tolstoy

Tucker

Volin

Ward

Warren

Zerzan :

Issues

Animal rights

Capitalism

Education

Love and sex

Nationalism

Religion

Violence :

History

Paris Commune

Spanish Regional Federation of the IWA

Cantonal rebellion

Hague Congress

International Conference of Rome

Trial of the Thirty

Haymarket affair

May Day

Congress of Amsterdam

Tragic Week

High Treason Incident

Manifesto of the Sixteen

Individualist anarchism in the United States

1919 United States bombings

Biennio Rosso

German Revolution of 1918–1919

Bavarian Soviet Republic

Kronstadt rebellion

Makhnovshchina

Amakasu Incident

Escuela Moderna

Individualist anarchism in Europe

Spanish Revolution of 1936

Barcelona May Days

Red inverted triangle

Labadie Collection

May 1968

Provo

LIP

Kate Sharpley Library

Australian Anarchist Centenary

Carnival Against Capital

1999 Seattle WTO protests

Really Really Free Market

Occupy movement :

Culture

A las Barricadas

Anarchist bookfair

Anarcho-punk

Arts

Culture jamming

DIY ethic

Films

Freeganism

Glossary

Infoshop

Independent Media Center

The Internationale

Jewish anarchism

Lifestylism

"No gods, no masters"

Popular education

"Property is theft!"

Radical cheerleading

Radical environmentalism

Squatting

Symbolism :

Economics

Communization

Cooperative

Cost the limit of price

General strike

Gift economy

Give-away shop

Free association

Labour voucher

Market abolitionism

Mutual aid

Mutual credit

Participatory economics

Social ownership

Wage slavery

Workers' self-management :

By region

Africa

Albania

Algeria

Andorra

Argentina

Armenia

Australia

Austria

Azerbaijan

Bangladesh

Belarus

Belgium

Bolivia

Bosnia and Herzegovina

Brazil

Bulgaria

Canada

Chile

China

Colombia

Costa Rica

Croatia

Cuba

Czech Republic

Denmark

Dominican Republic

East Timor

Ecuador

Egypt

El Salvador

Estonia

Finland

France

French Guiana

Georgia

Germany

Greece

Guatemala

Hong Kong

Hungary

Iceland

India

Indonesia

Iran

Ireland

Israel

Italy

Japan

Korea

Latvia

Malaysia

Mexico

Monaco

Mongolia

Morocco

Netherlands

New Zealand

Nicaragua

Nigeria

Norway

Panama

Paraguay

Peru

Philippines

Poland

Portugal

Puerto Rico

Romania

Russia

Serbia

Singapore

South Africa

Spain

Sweden

Switzerland

Syria

Taiwan

Tunisia

Turkey

Ukraine

United Kingdom

United States

Uruguay

Venezuela

Vietnam :

Lists

Anarcho-punk bands

Books

Communities

Fictional characters

Films

Jewish anarchists

Musicians

Periodicals :

Related topics

Anti-corporatism

Anti-consumerism

Anti-fascism

Anti-globalization

Anti-statism

Anti-war movement

Autarchism

Autonomism

Communism

Counter-economics

Definition of anarchism and libertarianism

Labour movement

Left communism

Left-libertarianism

Libertarianism

Libertarian Marxism

Libertarian socialism

Marxism

Situationist International

Socialism

Spontaneous order

Voluntaryism :

Anarchism portal

Politics portal :

vte :

Philosophical anarchism is an anarchist school of thought which focuses on intellectual criticism of authority, especially political power, and the legitimacy of governments. The American anarchist and socialist Benjamin Tucker coined the term philosophical anarchism to distinguish peaceful evolutionary anarchism from revolutionary variants. Although philosophical anarchism does not necessarily imply any action or desire for the elimination of authority, philosophical anarchists do not believe that they have an obligation or duty to obey any authority or conversely that the state or any individual has a right to command. Philosophical anarchism is a component especially of individualist anarchism.

The scholar Michael Freeden identifies four broad types of individualist anarchism. He says the first is the type associated with William Godwin that advocates self-government with a "progressive rationalism that included benevolence to others". The second type is egoism, which is most associated with Max Stirner. The third type is "found in Herbert Spencer's early predictions" and in that of some of his disciples such as Wordsworth Donisthorpe, who foresee in this sense "the redundancy of the state in the source of social evolution". The fourth type retains a moderated form of egoism and accounts for social cooperation through the advocacy of the market, having such followers as the American individualist anarchist Benjamin Tucker and the green anarchist Henry David Thoreau.

## Overview

### Types and variations

As conceived by William Godwin, philosophical anarchism requires individuals to act in accordance with their own judgments and to allow every other individual the same liberty. Conceived as egoistically by Max Stirner, it implies that the unique one who truly owns himself recognizes no duties to others. Within the limit of his might, he does what is right for him.

Rather than taking up arms to bring down the state, philosophical anarchists "have worked for a gradual change to free the individual from what they thought were the oppressive laws and social constraints of the modern state and allow all individuals to become self-determining and value-creating." Those anarchists may oppose the immediate elimination of the state by violent means out of concern that what remains might be vulnerable to the establishment of a yet more harmful and oppressive state. That is especially true among those anarchists who consider violence and the state as synonymous or that it is counterproductive if public reaction to violence results in increased "law enforcement" efforts.

### Political and philosophical anarchism

Magda Egoumenides writes, "The anarchist criticisms and ideal of legitimacy explain the link between philosophical and political anarchism: they remind us that the enduring deficiency of the state is a position that is initially shared by both forms of anarchism, and the moral criteria of philosophical anarchism are intended to be inherent in the society that political anarchism seeks to create." According to Egoumenides, "A demonstration of the compatibility of political anarchist social visions with the perspective and ideals of legitimacy of critical philosophical anarchism establishes a continuity within the anarchist ideology."

Michael Huemer writes, "In the terminology of contemporary political philosophy, I have so far defended philosophical anarchism (the view that there are no political obligations), but I have yet to defend political anarchism (the view that government should be abolished)." He argues that "the terminology is misleading" since "both kinds of 'anarchism' are philosophical and political claims."

## Criticism

Philosophical anarchism has met the criticism of members of academia following the release of pro-anarchist books such as A. John Simmons' Moral Principles and Political Obligations (1979). In The Problem of Political Authority: An Examination of the Right to Coerce and the Duty to Obey (2013), Michael Huemer defends his interpretation of philosophical anarchism and claims that "political authority is a moral illusion".

The law professor William A. Edmundson authored an essay arguing against three major philosophical anarchist principles that he finds fallacious. Edmundson claims that the individual does not owe a normal state a duty of obedience, but he considers that not to imply that anarchism is the inevitable conclusion and the state is still morally legitimate.

Another criticism of philosophical anarchism is that it remains purely theoretical. In failing to act out anarchism in the real world, philosophical anarchism is seen as a bourgeois convenience that actually serves the status quo, rather than destroying it.

