Brunton, if your interpretation of the WP rules as per WP:MEDRS is right, the rules are wrong. But I think you inadvertently (happens easily, this area of stats is a bit tricky) misinterpreted the rules. The discussion of these points should now move to the MD:MEDRS site, where I will go, following not only my instinct by the advice of my mental health advisor. She says: 
 ::::::::::I know you like an argument, Reinhard. But remember how often that got you into trouble? Here at Homeopathy:Talk your contributions have already been sectioned (WP-slang: WP:NOTFORUM), if you carry on you will WP:DICKED.  And the advice on the WP:DICK site is very wise. In your case:  Move On, gracefully!  
 :::::::::: She is right, I will move on. I don’t know about gracefully though – I never knew. Cheers!  (Good grief: I nearly said WP:Pricked and WP:Prick!)