:This discussion probably belongs on the workshop page, but while I agree that it shouldn't seem that one is attacking the other side, I think your proposal is unworkable.  If a lot of people genuinely feel that there is a problem with X's behavior or disagree with Y's policy interpretation, they need to speak up (calmly and neutrally), otherwise it seems like it's just A vs X, and X can ignore A because A is obviously in the minority.