===Season-by-season records=== 

 |- 
 | 1991 || 73 || 69 || 5th || Did Not Qualify 
 |- 
 | 1992 || 77 || 62 || 2nd 1 || Lost in 1st round to Myrtle Beach Hurricanes 2-0. 
 |- 
 | 1993 || 86 || 56 || 2nd || Did Not Qualify 
 |- 
 | 1994 || 87 || 51 || 1st 1 || Lost in 1st round to Savannah Cardinals 2-0. 
 |- 
 | 1995 || 80 || 62 || 3rd 2 || Lost in 1st round to Augusta GreenJackets 2-0. 
 |- 
 | 1996 || 79 || 63 || 4th 2 || 1st round: beat Augusta GreenJackets 2-1. 2nd round: Lost to Savannah Sand Gnats 2-0. 
 |- 
 | 1997 || 62 || 76 || 12th || Did Not Qualify 
 |- 
 | 1998 || 59 || 81 || 7th || Did Not Qualify 
 |- 
 | 1999 || 70 || 71 || 7th 1 || Lost in 1st round. 
 |- 
 | 2000 || 67 || 70 || 7th 1 || 1st round: beat Augusta GreenJackets. Finals: Lost to Delmarva Shorebirds 3-0. 
 |- 
 | 2001 || 77 || 59 || 3rd || Did Not Qualify 
 |- 
 | 2002 || 79 || 60 || 3rd 2 || 1st round: beat Capital City Bombers. Finals: Lost to Hickory Crawdads 3-2. 
 |- 

 1- 1st half division champion 
 2- 2nd half division champion 
 1991: Columbus Indians  
 1992-2002: Columbus RedStixx