" 
 :Chill out. You made a request for feedback and you are getting it. I could go either way, you and the IP are for, and the evil stubborn no good admin (not really, I'm sure he is fine) is against it. Disambiguation pages are not a search index. ""monkey boobies"" gets google hits but doesn't have a disambiguation page or redirect. If you think English speaking (this is the English wikipedia) users are typing ""dog sex"" in the address bar to get to an article titled ""dog sex"" then go for it. I assume they are typing in ""animal sex"" ""dogging"" ""doggy style"" ""puppies"" ect. I don't think we need a rediret or disambiguation page at all since I don't think people are searching for an article entitled dog sex. If we are going to have one or the other: disambiguation page is the way to go navigation wise.  "