Id give it a five but when i logged in all my red stars are just gone... Yes im still in a club ... I thought red stars were always there and you had to get them ... Idk can anyone explain this AT ALL!!!! Other than that i love this game.... Free coins everyday... A chance to win gems ect... You dont have to spend to play...but spending a little still helps...BUT I LIVE ITS NOT A PAY TO PLAY GAME!!!!