A 69-year-old man passes away after a 3-week hospitalization for liver failure, complicated by a myocardial infarction. A medical student rotating in the intensive care unit asked if she can practice performing intubations during her rotation. The resident suggests performing one on the deceased patient, as the student cannot harm him. Which of the following is the most appropriate course of action for the medical student?
Ask the resident if the patient’s family or the patient has been consented for this procedure
Contact the patient's family to ask for permission to perform the procedure
Intubate the patient with the resident's supervision
Report the resident to hospital administration
Ask the resident if the patient’s family or the patient has been consented for this procedure
This medical student wants to perform a procedure on a deceased patient for educational purposes. Before proceeding, the student should ensure that permission has been obtained from the patient's family or the patient when he was alive.

Performing procedures on deceased patients is ethically permissible with appropriate consent and consideration of risks and benefits for patients, families, learners, staff, and the field of medicine. Supervising physicians must obtain informed consent from the patient while alive and with capacity or from a newly deceased patient’s healthcare proxy or family. During the consent process, the supervisor should outline the patient's and family's rights, wider educational and societal benefits, potential risks, and ensure that performing the procedure would be consistent with the patient's values and wishes. Additionally, the supervising physician has a responsibility to ensure that a medical examiner has cleared the patient and that the patient is not an organ donor before proceeding. Finally, the procedure should be documented in the patient's chart.

Berger and Cassell review the ethics of practicing procedures on deceased patients. They note that some ethical norms may suggest this practice is not appropriate. They recommend performing procedures when consent is obtained and it is ethically acceptable to do so.

Incorrect Answers:
Answer B: Consulting the hospital ethics committee is not necessary, for with proper permission, trainees may perform procedures on deceased patients for educational purposes. The ethics committee should only be consulted when there is no clear course of action (an example may be no advanced directive with family members disagreeing on what the patient's wishes would have been for a critically ill patient).

Answer C: Contacting the patient's family to ask for permission to perform the procedure is incorrect, as the supervising physician needs to verify and document consent. Medical students cannot consent patients and family members. Moreover, the family should not be contacted if the patient has already approved or refused this when he had capacity.

Answer D: Intubating the patient with the resident's supervision is incorrect because proper permission must be ensured prior to performing educational procedures on deceased patients.

Answer E: Reporting the resident to hospital administration is incorrect because it is ethically permissible to perform an intubation on a deceased patient provided there is proper permission. The resident is not asking the medical student to do anything illegal or against hospital policy. Reporting the resident may be indicated if the resident was performing procedures against the patient's will.

Bullet Summary:
Trainees may perform procedures for educational purposes on deceased patients if permission is obtained from the patient prior to death, the patient's family, or a healthcare proxy.