text: Sides settle in historic house demolition lawsuit, Bloomington doesn’t levy $83.5K fine – The B Square
  Skip to content
  Home
  Subscribe
  About
  Error Log
  Pages
  Calendar
  Support B Square
  Sides settle in historic house demolition lawsuit, Bloomington doesn’t levy $83.5K fine
  Dave Askins Bloomington September 14, 2021 September 14, 2021 3 Minutes
  This April 18, 2020 image is from the Pictometry module of Monroe County’s online property lookup system.
  This March 29, 2017 image is from the Pictometry module of Monroe County’s online property lookup system.
  A settlement agreement approved by the court last week means that the owner of a house at 523 West 7th St. across from Fairview Elementary School will not be fined $83,500 for demolishing it about two years ago without the proper permit.
  It was Monroe County circuit court judge Kara Krothe who signed off on the settlement, by ordering the case dismissed, based an a joint motion from the two sides—the owners and the city of Bloomington.
  In fall 2019, the house was under consideration by Bloomington’s historic preservation commission (HPC) for designation as historic.
  It was on Aug. 8, 2019 when the HPC recommended that the city council consider designating the house as historic. But the commission’s resolution was missing a crucial element: It did not explicitly say that the house was being put under interim protection.
  Before it was put on the city council’s agenda for action, towards the end of September 2019, owners David Holdman and Judie Baker had the house demolished. They did not have the required certificate of zoning compliance.
  After the demolition, the city assessed a fine of $83,500, based on a penalty levied for the demolition and for each day after the demolition, contending the property was in violation of the city code for each of those days. The city arrived at $83,500 by capping the fine at the most recent value of the house and garage as assessed by Monroe County.
  In their subsequent legal papers, the owners argued that if there were a violation of the city code for undertaking a demolition without having the certificate, then the violation happened just once, and was not recurring, which was the way the city was attempting to levy the fine.
  The court action was a request for a writ of mandamus requiring the city after-the-fact to issue a certificate of zoning compliance for demolition of the house. That’s why former director of Bloomington’s planning and transportation department, Terri Porter, is the named defendant in the case. It would have been up to Porter to issue the certificate.
  The city contended that the issuance of such a certificate was moot, especially since the city was, by the end of May 2020, already saying that it would no longer pursue the fine.
  The owners contended that without the certificate, they would still be vulnerable to potential future city action. On that point, judge Krothe agreed with the owners, in her order from five months ago. On April 21, Krothe denied the city’s motion for summary judgement.
  In her order, Krothe wrote: “The court disagrees that this matter is moot. If Baker and Holdman do not receive the CZC they are still subject to fines for not obtaining the CZC.”
  In her April 21 order, Krothe also denied the owners’ motion for summary judgment, writing that it was not clear if the request for a certificate of zoning compliance had been properly made: “Whether or not the Plaintiffs application was proper is a determination of fact. There seems to be a dispute about whether or not the Plaintiffs properly applied for a demolition permit. Therefore, Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment is denied.”
  Instead of continuing to battle things out in the circuit court, the two sides reached a settlement.
  Under the terms of the settlement, the owners of the house are being issued a certificate of zoning compliance by the city.
  The part of the settlement that ensures the $83,500 fine is not levied against the owners states that the city of Bloomington will “release and forever discharge the Plaintiffs from all claims, actions, causes of action, demands, debts, liabilities and other obligations, including all potential penalties and fines resulting from violations of the Bloomington Municipal Code…”
  Under the terms of the settlement, Bloomington did not have to pay legal fees for the owners. The case for the owners was handled by David Ferguson and Christine Bartlett with Ferguson Law.
  Share this:
  Twitter
  Facebook
  Like this:
  Like Loading...
  Tagged
  historic house
  historic preservation commission
  Holdman Baker v. Porter
  Published September 14, 2021 September 14, 2021
  Post navigation
  Previous Post Old Colonial Crest redux: Bloomington OKs mostly same site plan for 671-bedroom student-oriented housing project, but under different zoning
  Next Post $135K in Sophia Travis community service grants OK’d by Monroe County
  2 thoughts on “Sides settle in historic house demolition lawsuit, Bloomington doesn’t levy $83.5K fine”
  Valerie Merriam says:
  September 14, 2021 at 2:25 pm
  It’s Fairview School.
  Loading...
  Reply
  Dave Askins says:
  September 14, 2021 at 2:40 pm
  Thank you, fixed!
  Loading...
  Reply
  Leave a Reply Cancel reply
  Search The B Square
  Search for:
  Recent Items
  Deadlines for campaign finance reports in 2023 could get stricter enforcement in Monroe County December 1, 2022
  Election 2023: Sims won’t run again for city council, still plans continued service to Bloomington November 30, 2022
  Company email: Catalent’s Bloomington operation to cut 400 jobs November 30, 2022
  Standard procedure: Ballots impounded by Indiana State Police for House District 62 recount November 29, 2022
  Recount for 40-vote margin: Monroe County Dems to ask for hand re-tally in Hall-Githens District 62 race November 28, 2022
  Public bus notebook: BT to work with Go Bloomington on guaranteed rides home November 27, 2022
  Conservation district math: Dec. 4 to mark conversion of Near West Side to historic district November 26, 2022
  Canopy of Lights 2022: Thank you, Mae! November 25, 2022
  Thanksgiving week Bloomington turkeys—in disguise November 24, 2022
  Dems ask for recount of 4-vote margin in Benton Township board race November 24, 2022
  2022: Happy Thanksgiving, Bloomington! November 24, 2022
  Johnson’s Creamery: No new alley means no swap, but council’s vacation stands, project can proceed November 23, 2022
  Federal judge to Bloomington: Create criteria for public art requests in right-of-way, allow application for “All Lives Matter” street mural November 22, 2022
  Bloomington to pay $500,000 less for western part of city hall building November 21, 2022
  Analysis: 2024 edition of Bloomington city council will be different, by a little or a lot November 20, 2022
  Hall nets +3: Provisional ballot review for District 62 House gives Hall 15 more, Githens 12 more November 19, 2022
  Kerry Thomson kicks off campaign for Bloomington mayor: “A public that labels itself ‘progressive’ deserves to see some progress.” November 18, 2022
  Hamilton on a third term as Bloomington mayor: “It’s tempting to run, but I just have decided not to.” November 18, 2022
  Bloomington sewer, stormwater rate increases get city council OK November 17, 2022
  Johnson’s Creamery alley vacated by city council on 8–1 vote, BPW to see request for new alley next week November 17, 2022
  Meeting set for review of provisional ballots in 2022 general elections: District 62 House race margin could get bigger, smaller, stay the same November 16, 2022
  Parks board, city engineer: Collaboration, consultation, or supervision on trail closures? November 15, 2022
  Negative stamp on rezone for jail by Bloomington plan commission, could still win city council’s OK November 14, 2022
  Sandberg sets tone for 2023 mayoral campaign with kickoff: “We should restore before we do more.” November 13, 2022
  Photos: Red-tailed hawk at Switchyard Park November 12, 2022
  Veterans Day 2022 at Indiana University: “Let us strive for peaceful resolution in all conflict.” November 11, 2022
  Column: For convention center governance, it’s a clear choice—the one subject to the Open Door Law November 10, 2022
  6.6K ballots missed in first vote totals from Monroe County: Added numbers make for tiny margin in District 62 House race November 9, 2022
  Monroe County 2022 results highlights: Hall for House; Pirani, Wyatt for school board; MCCSC referendum passes; turnout light November 9, 2022
  Alea iacta est: Nov. 8, 2022 election results, served when ready November 8, 2022
  Monroe County 2022 Election Day: Polls are OPEN November 8, 2022
  2023 Bloomington city council elections: Guenther won’t pursue at-large seat November 7, 2022
  Early voting wraps up in Monroe County, polls open on Election Day at 6 a.m. November 7, 2022
  Column: Let’s put a stop sign on the road to divisive debate club points, greenlight more ped infra money November 6, 2022
  Bloomington looks finally to put commercial tenants in ground floors of city parking garages November 5, 2022
  New alley as part of swap at old Johnson’s Creamery likely won’t get city engineer’s support November 4, 2022
  Early voting in Monroe County continues to trail 2018 turnout, election day workers still needed November 3, 2022
  Stop signs OK’d by Bloomington city council over dissent from two members November 2, 2022
  Fuel from Marathon station leaks into Bloomington’s sewers, officials work to get plant back online November 1, 2022
  Bloomington consultant: Build arts incubator with small venue; keep Waldron; look close at BCT; showcase art in expanded convention center October 31, 2022
  Bloomington city council preview: Johnson’s Creamery alley vacation; higher sewer, storm rates October 30, 2022
  Election 2022 notebook: Early voting pace in Monroe County looks slower than for 2018 October 29, 2022
  “Piss-poor” B-Line detour design prompts scrutiny of right-of-way definition by city traffic commission October 28, 2022
  Rezone for “truckstop–small” denied by Monroe County, ends 30 years of overnight truck parking October 27, 2022
  Scooter contract renewal pulled from Bloomington BPW agenda, pending more review October 26, 2022
  Election notebook: Monroe County early voting picks up pace, still way slower than presidential year October 25, 2022
  Column: Bloomington city council quarrel about committees could be helped by a look back to 1954 October 24, 2022
  Photos | 2022 Little 500 Fall Racing Series: Cyclocross October 23, 2022
  2022 Little 500 Street Sprints: A perfect fall day in Bloomington October 23, 2022
  Denial of variance for 15 condos could lead to change in ground floor regs for downtown Bloomington October 21, 2022
  Meeting set on Nov. 9 for city, county officials to talk more about convention center expansion October 20, 2022
  Bloomington OKs $100K for emergency reproductive services, meant to counter effect of SB1 October 20, 2022
  Transit board wants attorney’s advice on legal requirements for service outside Bloomington October 19, 2022
  11 Callery pear trees to get axed, Bloomington’s park board OKs $17K contract October 18, 2022
  Winslow Road resurfacing gets some discussion by Bloomington RDC, but no vote on contract October 18, 2022
  Column: Hey, buddy, let’s talk trash bin math October 17, 2022
  Walnut-College study contract OK’d by Bloomington board of works, could tackle two-way question October 16, 2022
  Early election notebook: Three days of in-person early voting October 14, 2022
  Bloomington budget adopted, AFSCME workers get same pay (for now) as last year October 13, 2022
  Bloomington plan commission news: State’s highest court declines case on party affiliations for partisan-balanced boards October 12, 2022
  Hear ye, hear ye: Early voting starts in Monroe County, Indiana October 12, 2022
  2023 Bloomington budget notebook: Parking cashouts, cop cars October 11, 2022
  First rezone hearing for potential new jail highlights employment center versus institutional use October 11, 2022
  Traffic notebook: Added stops at Maxwell-Sheridan to be weighed by Bloomington city council October 10, 2022
  Convention center notebook: What’s the deal with the food and beverage tax advisory commission? October 9, 2022
  Rezone request for potential county jail property to be heard by Bloomington plan commission October 8, 2022
  Bloomington effectively declares dead any deal to work with Monroe County on convention center October 7, 2022
  Now settled: New district boundaries for Bloomington city council 2023 elections October 6, 2022
  Bloomington west side encampment: County commissioners approve $24,500 for displacement October 5, 2022
  What candidates said in 3 minutes to make their best pitch to Monroe County voters October 5, 2022
  Bloomington’s annual Life Chain demonstration precedes city budget decisions October 3, 2022
  With some grumbles, $30K approved by Monroe County commissioners for Bloomington Economic Development Corporation October 2, 2022
  2023 Bloomington budget notebook: Built-in padding of 50 percent or more? October 1, 2022
  2023 Bloomington budget notebook: Trash talk, cart fees, general fund September 30, 2022
  Initial talk: Bloomington city council balks on 2023 budget, likely looking for better employee pay before late October vote September 28, 2022
  Cataloging scooter parking violations: Bloomington to use temp agency for initial staffing of 2 positions September 27, 2022
  Fiber network with 1-Gigabit internet service likely to start construction work in Bloomington next week September 26, 2022
  Column | Lake Monroe: A neighborhood where Bloomington gets its drinking water September 24, 2022
  Denied by Bloomington: Request to vacate two strips of right-of-way where parts of buildings stand September 23, 2022
  New Bloomington city council districts: Vote put off at least until Oct. 6 September 22, 2022
  Bloomington Transit mulls impact of city council resolution on extension of service outside city September 21, 2022
  Believed armed suspect extracted from Bloomington stormwater system after day-long saga September 20, 2022
  Griffy dam trail crossing gets OK from Bloomington RDC: “It’s not within the TIF—it’s serving the TIF.” September 20, 2022
  Election equipment for Monroe County passes logic, accuracy test September 19, 2022
  Bloomington police report: Early Sunday morning death when drunk driver hits scooter rider September 18, 2022
  Monroe County 2023 budget notebook: Councilors mull $2K one-time retention bonus September 17, 2022
  Lots more electric scooters in Bloomington, but not as many more rides September 16, 2022
  Photos: Protesters mourn effective date of Indiana’s law prohibiting most abortions September 15, 2022
  Bloomington board of public works notebook: Boxed-in bamboo wins appeal September 14, 2022
  Likely no deliberations this week on new map for Bloomington city council districts September 13, 2022
  Column: Bloomington botches accessibility of document about accessibility September 13, 2022
  Bloomington OKs 135-bedroom apartment building across from IU football stadium September 12, 2022
  Photos | Black y Brown Arts Festival 2022: “There are so many shades under the sun. We see black y brown when we gaze in the mirror, bruh. “ September 11, 2022
  Delayed: Bloomington plan commission hearing on rezone for possible future site of Monroe County jail September 10, 2022
  Dropped cell phone snagged from storm drain by Bloomington utilities workers September 9, 2022
  Public buses outside Bloomington: City council goes on record in support, if county govt pays extra cost September 8, 2022
  Bloomington city council sets schedule to consider new district boundaries, could lead to Sept. 21 vote September 7, 2022
  Winslow Road repaving gets initial $500K nod from Bloomington RDC September 6, 2022
  Column: New Bloomington city council districts should get a vote on Sept. 21, but probably won’t September 5, 2022