text: Free-Fall – A series of postings offering perspective and commentary on art and global environmental issues from Joe Carlisi
  Cleaning House at OHA
  Getting Permitting Out of Home Maintenance
  Business & Tech
  AllConsumer TechEcologyEconomyPersonal FinanceThinkTech
  Is it time for Hawaii to replace zoning with a new city planning paradigm?
  Will Aloha Stadium redevelopment be our next white elephant?
  Budget surplus is good reason to cut taxes
  Demystifying Hawaii’s doctor shortage
  Life
  AllArts & CultureEntertainmentEventsFoodHealthSpiritual PracticeTravelWork/Career
  No, Boosting the Affordable Housing Fund Isn’t the Answer
  Free-Fall – A series of postings offering perspective and commentary on art and global environmental issues from Joe Carlisi
  Filmmaker Connie Florez Riffs on HIFF and Film in Hawai’i
  HAMILTON MAKES HAWAII DEBUT AT BLAISDELL CONCERT HALL
  More
  Home Special Features Guest Commentary Would Schwarzenegger Support School Choice?
  Special Features
  Guest Commentary
  Would Schwarzenegger Support School Choice?
  By
  Hawaii Reporter
  -
  September 16, 2003
  0
  1076
  Facebook
  Twitter
  Pinterest
  WhatsApp
  article top
  Last week Actor and candidate for California governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger, told NBC’s Matt Lauer, “I think children should have the first call on the budget.”
  It turns out in California they do — with the 2003-2004 California budget including $45.7 billion for K-14 education spending alone — representing a $1.7 billion or 4 percent increase from 2002-2003. However, as both parents and government officials know, children can often break the bank, and money can’t necessarily buy love or student achievement.
  inline
  In fact, on the 2002 National Assessment of Educational Progress reading exam, just 21 percent of California fourth-graders scored at or above the “proficient” level. The national rate was 30 percent. More specifically, in Los Angeles, 67 percent of students scored below basic turning in the second worst performance in the nation behind Washington D.C. at 69 percent. The release of California’s 2003 test scores found 925 California schools not meeting adequate yearly progress (AYP).
  California AYP only requires that 13.6 percent of elementary children and 11.2 percent of high school students be proficient in reading and math. Thousands of children are now eligible for the public-school choice provision under the No Child Left Behind Act. Yet, California has a shortage of better public schools for these kids to transfer into. In the public school sector, these children have nowhere to go.
  With vast amounts of taxpayer spending equaling poor performance for California’s children, the crucial question for Arnold becomes: What will he do with the children stuck in record numbers of low-performing schools despite high levels of taxpayer investment in education? Will he spend more or let them out?
  We can extrapolate some of Schwarzenegger’s potential education policy from the company he keeps. Pete Wilson opposed proposition 174, the first statewide California school voucher initiative, but later proposed a more moderate voucher plan similar to Governor Jeb Bush’s Florida Opportunity Scholarship Plan, that allows students in failing schools to use vouchers to attend the private or public school of their choice. Similarly, Mayor Riordan opposed Tim Draper’s proposition 38, California’s second failing statewide voucher initiative, but supported private school vouchers for low-income children through the Los Angeles Children’s Scholarship Fund. Arnold has Internet photos with Tim Draper at various children’s charitable functions and recently co-hosted an Education Summit with Education Secretary Rod Paige, who just last week came out in favor of vouchers in the Wall Street Journal. And of course Schwarzenegger has been a prominent supporter of President Bush, who at least pays lip service to the benefits of school choice.
  These associations, however, are no guarantee of Arnold becoming a school choice advocate. Yet, it is likely that Arnold would support more school competition and parental choice than the current administration (not much of a stretch). And with more Democrats like Dianne Feinstein, Joe Lieberman, and DC Mayor Anthony Williams breaking ranks with the union and coming out in favor of vouchers in D.C. and other low-performing urban cities, it makes a Schwarzenegger pro-choice position seem almost moderate.
  So while Schwarzenegger will not likely support a full-scale voucher or tax credit scheme to privatize education there are several moderate proposals he could imitate:
  *He could drastically increase the number of charter schools in California by letting local government, Universities, and nonprofits authorize and monitor the schools.
  *He could let organizations bid to run failing schools similar to the Philadelphia approach, that has universities, nonprofits, and for-profit companies managing the city’s worst-performing schools.
  *He could initiate a state-wide voucher program a la’ Colorado Governor Bill Owens and Florida Governor Jeb Bush that allows students in failing schools to use vouchers in private or public schools.
  *He could institute a tax credit program like Arizona, Florida, or Pennsylvania that allows individuals and corporations to take a tax-credit for donations to charitable organizations that provide private scholarships to low-income and minority students.
  *He could take advantage of President Bush’s proposed $75 million school choice pilot project by offering up a city such as Compton, Oakland, or even Los Angeles as a test city for federally funded school vouchers.
  *The bottom line is that Arnold will likely follow the George W. school-choice model. The President has been the supporter of more choices in education, including the Washington D.C voucher plan, public school choice, and the private tutoring vouchers for children in failing schools, while simultaneously pumping billions more federal dollars into public education. We know from experience with Proposition 49 that when it comes to children Arnold is not averse to spending taxpayer dollars. Arnold will likely continue record levels of education spending while opening up moderate choice options for children in failing public schools. Hence, one key question for Arnold will be how he intends to utilize choice and competition to stretch the public dollar while increasing accountability and performance. I will be listening very closely for that answer.
  ”’Lisa Snell is the Director of Education Program for the Reason Foundation. Originally published by Reason Foundation, which is a public policy think tank promoting choice, competition and a dynamic market economy as the foundation for human dignity and progress. For more information, contact Geoffrey Segal, Director of Privatization and Government Reform Policy at:”’ mailto:geoffrey.segal@reason.org ”’Visit the Reason Web site at:”’ http://www.rppi.org ”’or go to the Reason Public Policy Institute’s Privatization Center at:”’ http://www.privatization.org ”’for information on government reform, privatization, contracting out and public/private partnerships.”’
  ”’Check out Lisa Snell’s education commentary at”’ http://www.educationweak.blogspot.com
  Related
  Comments
  comments
  bottom
  Facebook
  Twitter
  Pinterest
  WhatsApp
  Previous articleGrassroot Perspective – Aug. 20, 2003-Brief Analysis 451: Corporate Taxes; Shock! Politicians Lie
  Next articleCan’t Have it Both Ways: Which Bush was Right in Handling Iraq
  Hawaii Reporter
  http://boss.hawaiireporter.com/members/admin/
  Hawaii Reporter is an award-winning, independent Hawaii-based news and opinion journal founded in 2001 and launched in February 2002. The journal's staff have won a number of top awards from the Society of Professional Journalists, including the top investigative news reporting awards, business reporting awards, government reporting awards, and online news reporting awards.
  Top Posts
  No, Boosting the Affordable Housing Fund Isn’t the Answer
  Filmmaker Connie Florez Riffs on HIFF and Film in Hawai'i
  Free-Fall – A series of postings offering perspective and commentary on art and global environmental issues from Joe Carlisi
  Is it time for Hawaii to replace zoning with a new city planning paradigm?
  It pays not to work: Hawaii residents receive highest welfare benefits in US
  Recent Comments
  Robert Kay on Driving with scissors –a bracing start to motoring in Malaysia
  Rob Kinslow on Mission: Joy – Documentary celebrates friendship between Desmond Tutu and the Dalai Lama screened at HIFF
  NRA Promotes Charles Cotton and Willes Lee, Two Execs Who Spread Bonkers Conspiracies - Lord Web on Interview with Willes Lee, first local candidate for NRA Board Member
  NRA Promotes Charles Cotton and Willes Lee, Two Execs Who Unfold Bonkers Conspiracies - 𝟙𝟙𝕥𝕙 ℍ𝕠𝕦𝕣 ℕ𝕖𝕨𝕤 on Interview with Willes Lee, first local candidate for NRA Board Member
  The NRA Promotes Charles Cotton And Wells Lee, Two Execs Who Spread Bonkers Conspiracies. - GreeleyTribune.Net on Interview with Willes Lee, first local candidate for NRA Board Member