However, ‘Ali later had a captive slave girl, the daughter of Rab’iah, who bore him a daughter name Umm Ruqayyah. al-Tabari vol.11 p.66.
Hata hivyo, ‘Ali baadaye alikuwa na mjakazi, binti wa Rab’iah, ambaye alimzalia binti aliyeitwa Umm Ruqayyah. al-Tabari juzuu ya 11 uk.66.