The Toronto Indians performance at the ORFU seasons showed that they missed the playoffs from seasons 1941 to 1944 while they almost made it to the ORFU finals in 1946 and 1947; nonetheless, they made it to the ORFU finals in 1945 and 1948 despite losing.
1941 1944 1942 1943 Missed Playoffs Missed Playoffs Missed Playoffs Missed Playoffs 1946 1947 Lost ORFU Semi-Finals Lost ORFU Semi-Finals 1945 1948 Lost ORFU Finals Lost ORFU Finals 
