Between Screens was praised by both Echoes and Dust and Ride the Tempo, Weird Canada published a feature on it.
Echoes and Dust praised Between Screens, saying "everything about this album makes the hair on my arms rise and creates goosebumps all over." Ride the Tempo declared that "'Between Screens' is an even stronger set of music, and also more purposeful" compared to The Wax Girl's "excellent" 2014 release, Anosmic EP. Weird Canada published a feature on April 2, 2015, proclaiming that Between Screens is "perfect for laying back and letting the current take you where it will." 
