Orlin Chalmers was  traded to Toronto Croatia (founded in 1956) and made his debut in 2003 where he failed to helped them finish second .
On August 27, 2003 he was traded to Toronto Croatia for Peter Curic and Josip Bucic. He made his debut for Croatia on September 5, 2003 in a match against the Mississauga Olympians in a 3-0 victory. He helped Toronto finish third in the Western Conference allowing the club to clinch a postseason berth. The club was founded in 1956 by the Croatian diaspora in Toronto. 
