Columbus Crew SC lost 7 times against the Toronto FC in the Trillium Cup since it started in 2008.
CLB 31 TOR
Major League Soccer
(March 29, 2008) CLB 75 TOR 
2008 Columbus Crew 2009 Columbus Crew 2010 Columbus Crew 2012 Columbus Crew 2013 Columbus Crew 2015 Columbus Crew SC 2018 Columbus Crew SC 2011 Toronto FC 2014 Toronto FC 2016 Toronto FC 2017 Toronto FC 2019 Toronto FC 2020 Toronto FC 
