My Own Mess was reviewed by three critics.
Laviea Thomas from Clash gave the album a positive review describing the album as "Swirling in surfer-boy aesthetic, heartfelt lyrics and joyous guitar patterns." John Lesson from The Newcastle Herald said "Skegss might appear like typical surfer or skate rats, but this three-piece possess an uncanny knack for melody [and] ... while it's typically lo-fi and uncomplicated the hooks are constant." Daniel Hansson from The AU Review said "on the whole My Own Mess floats between the faster chordal patterns of tracks like 'Couch Party' while other tracks, particularly 'Midnight Eyes' and 'Need to Do' are more laid back, giving the album a little bit of breathing room." 
Professional ratings The AU Review Clash The Newcastle Herald 
