Arthur William Hodge was recommended for mercy by a majority of the jurors but Chief Justice Robertson had him hung anyway, for the murder of one of his slaves.
A majority of the jurors recommended mercy for Hodge. Such recommendations were not binding, and the presiding judge, Chief Justice Robertson, pronounced that Hodge should be "hanged by the neck on Wednesday the 8 May following, until he was dead, on a spot near unto the common prison." Arthur William Hodge (17631811) was a plantation farmer, member of the Executive Council and Legislative Assembly, and slave owner in the British Virgin Islands, who was hanged on 8 May 1811, for the murder of one of his slaves. 
