Smile Kid was given the highest possible rating from the Alternative Press, which was first issued in fall of 1993 within the United States.
(3/5) Alternative Press Professional ratings 
Alternative Press reviewer Scott Heisel rated the album 3/5, saying that "Fans of We the Kings' debut will undoubtedly find something to hold on to with Smile Kid, but for those who were less than enamored with the band's pop-punk blend will likely stay that way." 
