":Kirk shanahan wrote:

Does it strike the rest of you as strongly as it does me as to how disconnected from reality Jed is?  I sit here practically screaming at him (because he doesn't listen to normal tomes) that the CCS is a systematic error (read 'procedural error') . . .

That's what I said: ""I think it would be fair to say that Shanahan believes the data to be an instrument artifact and not caused by actual heat . . .""

Further, you have the Clarke work that shows 'procedural errors' must be present (in order to get 'hydrogen' samples contaminated with air) in SRI's attempts to measure He production!

I was talking about calorimetry only. I realize there are discussions of errors in other measurements, and some of these other measurements are not as widely replicated or certain.

- Jed Rothwell, Librarian, LENR-CANR.org

"