Pari gbolohun ti o tẹle: Toronto ti kopa ninu gbogbo eto NHL, pẹlu yiyan akọkọ ti franchising jẹ Walt McKechnie, ti o gba 6th lapapọ ni 1963 NHL Amateur Draft. Toronto ti yan ẹni àkọ́kọ́ lẹ́ẹ̀mejì, ní 1985 àti
Ọdún 2016. Ni gbogbo itan wọn, awọn Maple Leafs ti kọ ọpọlọpọ awọn irawọ gbogbo ati ọpọlọpọ awọn oṣere ti o ti lọ lati ni awọn iṣẹ aṣeyọri, pẹlu meji ti a fi sinu Hockey Hall of Fame: Darryl Sittler ati Lanny McDonald.