Ci gaba da wannan sakin layi - Kasancewa tare da Braves a cikin, Neagle yana da mafi kyawun lokacinsa, yana zuwa 20<unk>5 tare da 2.97 ERA. Neagle ya fara farawa ga Braves a wasan farko na kakar wasa a Turner Field, wanda ya faru a ranar 4 ga Afrilu, 1997. Ya sami wani zaɓi na All-Star kuma ya gama na uku a zaben Cy Young Award. A Wasan 4 na Gasar Zakarun Kasa ta 1997
, Neagle ya jefa cikakkiyar wasa.