Rubuta ci gaba ga wannan sakin layi - Waƙar ta girmama shahararren jami'in Sojan Tarayya Janar Janar Thomas J. "Stonewall" Jackson, kuma John Williamson Palmer ne ya rubuta shi (1825<unk>1906), wanda ya bayyana cewa ya rubuta waƙar a ranar 16 ga Satumba, 1862; duk da haka, Miller &amp; Beacham, wanda ya wallafa waƙar a 1862, ya bayyana cewa an sami waƙar a jikin wani jami'in soja na Confederate bayan yakin farko na Winchester
, 25 ga Mayu, 1862. Zai yiwu wannan labarin asalin asalin ya samo asali ne don hana Palmer, dan Arewa, daga kama shi a matsayin mai goyon bayan Confederate.