Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - A karkashin kocin Antonio Conte, Chiellini ya koma matsayinsa na asali a gefen hagu saboda Barzagli da Bonucci na kyakkyawan tsari. Bayan gwagwarmaya don sake daidaitawa zuwa matsayinsa na baya, ya girma cikin rawar da ya taka kuma ya sami damar kiyaye Paolo De Ceglie, sauran sauran 'yan wasa na baya a cikin tawagar, a benci don yawancin farkon rabin kakar 2011-12. A rabi na biyu na kakar 2011-12, Conte ya koma tsaron mutum uku, inda Chiellini ya haɗu da Bonucci da Barzagli a cikin tsarin tsaro mai nasara ga Juve, wanda ya ƙare kakar wasa a matsayin zakarun Serie A, tare da mafi kyawun rikodin tsaro, tare da rashin nasara a gasar. Saboda wasan kwaikwayon da suka yi tare, mai tsaron ragar mutum uku ya sami laƙabi da "BBC", dangane da farkon 'yan wasan, kuma ba da daɗewa ba ƙungiyar ta kafa kansu a matsayin ɗayan mafi kyawun tsaro a ƙwallon ƙafa ta duniya a cikin yanayi masu zuwa. Juventus ta yi rashin nasara a wasan karshe na Coppa Italia na 2012 da Napoli, amma daga baya za ta doke su a Supercoppa Italiana na 2012
, ko da yake Chiellini zai rasa wasan.