Kammala wannan jumla: Pettitte shi ne dan wasan da ya lashe gasar yayin da Yankees suka doke Los Angeles Angels na Anaheim a wasan 6 na gasar
ALCS a ranar 25 ga Oktoba, 2009, don cin nasarar jerin kuma ci gaba zuwa World Series da Philadelphia Phillies. Wannan ya kawo jimlar aikinsa na cin nasara zuwa biyar, ya karya rikodin da ya raba tare da Roger Clemens, Catfish Hunter da Dave Stewart.