Rubuta ci gaba ga wannan sakin layi - A watan Yulin 1993, Athletics sun yi musayar Henderson zuwa Toronto Blue Jays da ke da alaka da Steve Karsay da José Herrera. Ya yi takaici ga Jays, yana buga.215 ne kawai a cikin wasanni 44, wanda wataƙila ya faru ne saboda gaskiyar cewa ya karye ƙashi a hannunsa da wuri tare da ƙungiyar, bayan da aka buga shi, kodayake har yanzu ya ba da gudummawar 22 da aka sace da 37 ya zira kwallaye. Duk da haka, ya buga wahalhalu ci gaba a cikin post-kakar, batting.120 a cikin American League Championship Series
kuma.227 a gasar cin kofin duniya. Duk da haka, Henderson ya shiga cikin wasan karshe na gasar cin kofin duniya a wannan shekara a cikin salon da aka fi sani da shi, kamar yadda shi da Paul Molitor suka zira kwallaye a wasan da Joe Carter ya yi na karshe. Bayan ya lashe lambar yabo ta biyu ta Duniya tare da Toronto, ya sake sanya hannu a matsayin dan wasa mai kyauta tare da Oakland a watan Disamba na 1993.