Rubuta ci gaba ga wannan sakin layi - A lokacinsa na farko na 1897 tare da Boston Beaneaters, ya buga.354, kuma a farkon lokutansa shida, ya wuce.300. A shekara ta 1899, ya ci kwallaye shida a wasa, kuma a gasar cin kofin duniya ta 1903
, ya buga uku sau uku. A shekara ta 1904, gami da lokacinsa tare da Beaneaters da Boston Americans, Stahl ya kasance babban ɓangare na ƙungiyoyi huɗu masu cin nasara a cikin yanayi bakwai.