Kammala wannan jumla: Schindler ta sadu da mijinta na farko, Buckey O'Neill, yayin da yake aiki a matsayin malamin makaranta. A lokacin shi ne editan jaridar "Hoof da Horn". Ma'aurata sun yi aure a ranar 27 ga Afrilu, 1886. An haifi ɗansu na farko, "Buckey" Jr., a ranar 1 ga Janairu, 1887 kuma ya mutu makonni biyu bayan haka. Sun dauki ɗa na biyu, Maurice, a ranar 15 ga Oktoba a wannan shekarar. O'Neill ya zama gwauruwa a ranar 1 ga Yuli, 1898 lokacin da Buckey ya mutu a lokacin
Yaƙin San Juan Hill. Asusun inshora na US $ 200,000 tare da dukiya a Phoenix da kuma kudaden da mijinta ya samu daga ma'adinan onyx ya bar ta da kudi a cikin shekaru masu yawa. Ta sake yin aure a ranar 16 ga Mayu, 1901, ta auri ɗan'uwan mijinta marigayi, Eugene Brady O'Neill. Eugene ya kasance lauya ne na Phoenix wanda ya yi aiki sau biyu a Majalisar (babban gidan) na Majalisar Dokokin Yankin Arizona kafin ya kashe kansa a shekarar 1918.