Tituba ya kasance bawa ga Samuel Parris da iyalinsa; ita da Sarah Good duka mata ne matalauta, yayin da Osborne ba. Osborne bai halarci coci ba a cikin kusan shekaru uku saboda rashin lafiya mai tsawo, kuma har yanzu yana magance matsalolin shari'a tare da iyalin Putnam. Zargin da ake yi wa Osborne na iya zama samfurin shawarwari mai karfi daga iyalin Putnam. An rubuta umarnin kama Sarah Osborne a ranar 1 ga Maris, 1692.
1 ga Maris, 1692