Kammala jumla mai zuwa: McCoy ya yi aiki a cikin World Series a 1977 da 1988. Ya kuma yi hukunci a cikin Wasannin Gasar Wasannin Amurka guda shida (1973,
1976, 1980, 1986, 1990 da 1997) da kuma wasanni uku na All-Star (1978, 1985 da 1996), suna kiran kwallaye da hare-hare don wasan 1985. McCoy ya yi aiki a cikin Wasannin Wasannin Wasannin Amurka a 1981, 1995 da 1998. Shi ne alkalin wasa na uku a ranar 20 ga Afrilu, 1986, lokacin da Roger Clemens ya zama dan wasa na farko da ya buga batir 20 a wasan wasa tara. McCoy shi ne kuma alkalin wasa na farko na wasan David Cone na cikakkiyar wasa a ranar 18 ga Yuli, 1999. Shi ne mai kula da farantin don Ten Cent Beer Night wanda Cleveland Indians ya gudanar a ranar 4 ga Yuni, 1974, wanda ya ƙare a cikin nasara ga Texas Rangers. Shi ne kuma alkalin wasa na gida a nasarar Phil Niekro ta 300 a Toronto a ranar 6 ga Oktoba, 1985.