Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - Lokacin da taron jihar ya taru a watan Afrilu na 1880, Randall ya amince da nasara, amma nan da nan ya gano cewa ƙungiyar Wallace ta fi ta yawa. Yawancin Wallace sun yi rikici da ƙungiyar jam'iyyar a Philadelphia kuma, kodayake wasu magoya bayan Randall sun sami kujeru, yawancin sun kasance masu biyayya ga sanata. Duk da rashin nasarar, Randall ya ci gaba da Tilden, a Pennsylvania da kuma sauran wurare. Kamar yadda jita-jita ke zagayawa cewa lafiyar Tilden za ta hana shi sake gudu, Randall ya kasance mai aminci Tilden mutum har zuwa taron kasa
wannan Yuni. Bayan zaben farko, tawagar New York ta fitar da wasika daga Tilden wanda ya janye daga la'akari. Randall ya yi fatan tsoffin wakilan Tilden za su hada kai da shi. Mutane da yawa sun yi haka, kuma Randall ya tashi zuwa na biyu a kuri'a ta biyu, amma saurin ya canza zuwa wani dan takara, Manjo Janar Winfield Scott Hancock. Kusan dukkanin wakilai sun koma Hancock, kuma an zabi shi.