Ka kammala wannan jumla: Waƙar tana girmama shahararren jami'in Sojan Tarayya Laftanar Janar Thomas J. "Stonewall" Jackson, kuma John Williamson Palmer (1825<unk>1906) ne ya rubuta shi, wanda ya bayyana cewa ya rubuta waƙar a ranar 16 ga Satumba, 1862; duk da haka, Miller &amp; Beacham, wanda ya wallafa waƙar a 1862, ya bayyana cewa an sami waƙar a jikin wani jami'in soja na Confederate bayan da aka kashe shi.
Yaƙin farko na Winchester, Mayu 25, 1862. Zai yiwu wannan labarin asalin asalin ya samo asali ne don hana Palmer, dan Arewa, daga kama shi a matsayin mai goyon bayan Confederate.