Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Bayan lashe taken rukuni sau shida a cikin yanayi bakwai daga 1995 zuwa 2001, Indians sun bayyana ne kawai a cikin postseason sau biyu a cikin shekaru 14 a ƙarƙashin mallakar dangin Dolan mai yawan gaske (Larry Dolan ya sayi ƙungiyar a 2000). A cikin
2007 American League Championship Series, Indians sun kasance 3<unk>1 kuma nasara daya daga ci gaba zuwa World Series, amma sun rasa wasanni uku na karshe zuwa Boston Red Sox ta hanyar haɗin gwiwa na 30<unk>5, suna hana tawagar wasan kwaikwayo na duniya. A cikin 2013, Indians sun ci wasanninsu goma na ƙarshe na kakar wasa don sake buga wasan, amma sun rasa wasan wasa na Wild Card zuwa Tampa Bay Rays da ci 4<unk>0.