Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Tottle sa'an nan kuma ya taka leda a kakar wasa daya a gasar Hockey League, sannan ya biyo bayan yanayi hudu tare da Charlotte a gasar Hockey League. A farkon zamansa biyu tare da Charlotte Clippers, an sanya shi a matsayin tauraruwa ta farko a 1958/59, da 1959/60. A kakar wasa ta uku a Charlotte, an sake sunan kungiyar zuwa Charlotte Checkers, kuma an nada Tottle a matsayin mai horar da 'yan wasa. Ya jagoranci kungiyar zuwa nasara 25 a wasanni 64, amma ya rasa wasan karshe. A lokacin kakar wasa ta hudu a Charlotte, Tottle ya taka leda a tawagar 'yan wasan hockey na Amurka a gasar cin kofin duniya na bana.
Gasar Kofin Duniya ta Hockey ta 1962. Daga baya ya koma jiharsa ta Michigan, don buga kakar wasa ta karshe tare da Port Huron Flags a gasar Hockey ta Duniya a 1962-63.