Cika wannan jumla: A 1994, Unser ya sake lashe
a Indy, wannan lokacin tare da Penske Racing. Abokan wasansa sun kasance Emerson Fittipaldi, mutumin da ya yi yaƙi da shi shekaru biyar da suka gabata, da Paul Tracy. Unser ya juya a cikin wasan kwaikwayo na tsawon lokaci, ya lashe tsere takwas daga cikin tsere 16 a kan hanyar zuwa gasar zakarun CART ta biyu, tare da kasancewa mai suna ABC's Wide World of Sports Athlete of the Year a wannan shekara. A cikin 1995 Unser, tare da abokin aikinsa Emerson Fittipaldi, sun kasa cancanta a Indianapolis, kuma daga baya zai nuna wannan a matsayin abin da ya haifar da saukowa cikin shan giya da rushewar aurensa. Zai gama na biyu ga Jacques Villeneuve a cikin gasar zakarun CART a shekarar 1995. Ya gama na huɗu a 1996, duk da cewa yana da damar lashe gasar har zuwa ƙarshen kakar.