Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - Ikklisiyar ta bunƙasa har zuwa shekarun 1960, lokacin da raguwar halartar ya haifar da wahalar kuɗi. An kara cocin a cikin National Register of Historic Places a 1977, amma cocin da makabartar da ke kusa da shi sun lalace. A shekara ta 2004, Diocese na Episcopal na Newark ya ba da shi ga Lamb of God Fellowship, ƙungiyar sabuntawa, don abin da aka yi niyyar zama na dogon lokaci, amma Fellowship ya tafi a shekara ta 2009 saboda tsadar tsadar dukiyar. Gicciyen da ke saman ginin ya girgiza a girgizar kasa ta 2011
kuma ya fadi a kasa. Diocese ya sayar da dukiya ga wata ƙungiya ta addini a farkon 2015.