Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A lokacin kakar 1995, Nagy ya jagoranci ma'aikatan tare da 16<unk>6 da 4.55 ERA, kamar yadda Indians suka koma gasar cin kofin duniya a karo na farko tun. Ya jefa da kyau a cikin division da kuma
gasar zakarun Turai, ta ba da gudummawar gudummawar gudummawar gudummawa guda biyu a cikin 15 innings, amma ta ba da gudummawar gudummawar gudummawar gudummawa guda biyar a cikin wasanni bakwai a wasan 3 na 1995 World Series. Shekarar da ta biyo baya, 1996, ita ce mafi kyawun lokacinsa; ya rubuta rikodin 17<unk>5 da 3.41 ERA, kuma ya gama na huɗu a zaben AL Cy Young Award.