Kammala wannan magana: Sutcliffe ya lashe wasanni 31 a tsawon shekaru biyu masu zuwa don Cleveland kuma ya jagoranci gasar Amurka a cikin aikin da aka samu a cikin shekara ta. A tsakiyar, Cleveland ya yi musayar Sutcliffe da ke fama da Chicago Cubs don Mel Hall da Joe Carter. Sutcliffe ya sake dawowa kuma ya lashe wasanni 16 don Cubs yayin da ya rasa daya kawai, yana taimaka musu zuwa gasar zakarun Turai. A ranar 2 ga Oktoba, 1984, ya fara wasan farko na gasar
NLCS a kan San Diego Padres, ya ba da hits biyu kuma babu gudu, ba kawai samun nasara ba, har ma da buga wasan gida a cikin na uku. Kwana biyar bayan haka, Sutcliffe ya buga wasan karshe na jerin a filin wasa na Jack Murphy, amma ya buga rashin nasara bayan ya ba da gudummawar gudummawa hudu a karo na bakwai.