Ka kammala wannan magana: Stuart ya ba da umarnin a ba da takobinsa da kuma harsashi ga ɗansa. Yayin da mai taimaka masa Manjo McClellan ya bar gefensa, Shugaban Kungiyar Jefferson Davis ya shigo, ya kama hannun Janar Stuart, ya tambaya, "Janar, yaya kake ji?" Stuart ya amsa "A sauƙaƙe, amma a shirye nake in mutu, idan Allah da ƙasata sun yi tunanin na cika burina kuma na yi aikina". Kalmominsa na ƙarshe da ya furta cikin ɓoye-ɓoye su ne: "Na yi murabus; a yi nufin Allah". Ya mutu a karfe 7:38 na yamma a ranar 12 ga Mayu, washegari, kafin Flora Stuart ya isa gefensa. Yana da shekara 31 a lokacin. An binne Stuart a cikin Richmond na Hollywood Cemetery. Bayan da ya sami labarin mutuwar Stuart, Janar Lee ya ba da rahoton cewa ya ce da wuya ya hana yin kuka a ambaton sunan Stuart kuma cewa Stuart bai taɓa ba shi mummunan bayani ba. John Huff, da masu zaman kansu wanda ya fatally ji rauni Stuart, aka kashe a mataki kawai 'yan makonni daga baya a
Yaƙin Shagon Haw.