Rubuta ci gaba ga wannan sakin layi - Bayan lokacinsa a Majalisa, Caruth ya sake komawa aikin doka a Louisville. Ya yi aiki a matsayin alƙali na ɓangaren aikata laifuka na Kotun Da'irar Jefferson County a 1902. Ya yi aiki a matsayin kwamishinan St. Louis Exposition a 1904
Ka yi haƙuri. Ya mutu a Louisville a ranar 25 ga Nuwamba, 1907, kuma an binne shi a Cave Hill Cemetery.