Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Redus yana da mafi kyawun lokacinsa a shekarar 1989, kuma ya taimaka wa Pirates zuwa sau uku a jere National League East division titles daga 1990 zuwa 1992, amma raunin da ya samu ya hana shi samarwa; bayan 1988, bai taba fitowa a wasanni sama da 98 a kowane kakar wasa ba. Redus ya jagoranci dukkan batters tare da.438 matsakaici (7-for-16) ta hanyar wasanni shida na farko na kakar wasa
1992 National League Championship Series, bayan da ya fara wasanni hudu a farkon tushe, kuma ya bayyana a matsayin pinch hitter sau ɗaya. Manajan Pirates Jim Leyland ya zaɓi kada ya buga Redus a wasa na bakwai mai yanke hukunci, yana fifita 'yan wasa na hagu da hannun dama John Smoltz na Atlanta Braves. A wasa na bakwai, Braves sun zira kwallaye uku a ƙarshen na tara don share jagorancin Pirates na 2 da 0 da kuma kama taken National League. Redus ya zaɓi 'yanci kyauta a ƙarshen 1992, yana wasa shekaru biyu da suka ji rauni tare da Texas Rangers kafin ya yi ritaya a ƙarshen yakin 1994.