Ka taƙaita labarin:  Lord Justice Beatson ya soki RSPCA a lokacin shari'ar kotu kan binciken wasu masu kiwon kare da dabbobi suka bincika ba bisa ka'ida ba daga jami'an sadaka. RSPCA ta sami babban alƙali na Kotun Koli a kan binciken da aka yi game da masu shayar da karnuka da ake zargi da haifar da wahala ga dabbobi. Shari'ar Deborah Fuller, mai shekara 55, da Phil Sheldrake, mai shekara 59, ta rushe bayan da ya bayyana cewa hukumar kare dabbobi ta yi amfani da takardar da ba ta dace ba don shiga gidan ma'auratan a Lawford, Essex. Babban alkalin kotun Lord Justice Beatson a yau ya yi watsi da bukatar da RSPCA ta yi na sake duba hukuncin yanke hukuncin rufe shari'ar - yana mai cewa yana da muhimmanci'ma'aikatan jihar' su mutunta takunkumin da aka sanya wa ikon su. RSPCA na kalubalantar hukuncin da alkalin gundumar Kenneth Sheraton ya yanke a kotun majistare ta Colchester a watan Yunin bara da ke hana shigar da kara. Alkalin Sheraton ya yi watsi da shaidar da aka samu a lokacin binciken da aka yi a gidajen Deborah Fuller, mai shekara 55, da Phil Sheldrake, mai shekara 59, wadanda suka ce ba su da laifi a kan tuhume-tuhume 16 na haddasa wa karnuka wahala da rashin daukar matakan da suka dace don biyan bukatunsu. Shari'ar ta shafi 42 Ridgebacks da Hamiltonstovers guda biyu da aka kama daga gidan Fuller da Sheldrake a Lawford, Essex, a watan Agusta 2013, lokacin da masu binciken RSPCA suka raka jami'an daga Tendring Council da 'yan sanda zuwa ga dukiyarsu. Binciken ya haifar da zargin RSPCA cewa wasu 17 daga cikin karnukan sun lalace, shida daga cikinsu suna da tsanani, kuma daya yana fama da ciwon daji na fuska. Dukkanin karnukan a halin yanzu ana kula da su ta hanyar RSPCA. An dakatar da shari'ar ne lokacin da ya bayyana cewa jami'an majalisar sun sami takardar bincike ne kawai don bincika korafe-korafen cewa ma'auratan sun haifar da 'damuwa ta doka' saboda hayaniyar karnukan da ke hawaye da kuma wari da ke fitowa daga najasa wanda ba a share shi ba. Alkali Sheraton ya gano cewa babu wani umarnin da aka bayar wanda ya ba da izinin duba yanayin karnukan. Alkalin ya ce 'rashin gogewa da rashin fahimta maimakon...
Shari'ar masu kiwon karnuka biyu da ake zargi da sakaci ta rushe a kan jerin umarnin. RSPCA ba ta da ikon da ya dace don duba dabbobin. Hukumar ta je Kotun Koli domin a sake duba hukuncin da alkali ya yanke. Amma babban alkali ya yi watsi da da'awar, yana goyon bayan takunkumin da aka sanya wa jami'ai.