Sii wad qoraalka sadarkani - Sutcliffe wuxuu ku guuleystay 31 kulan labadii xilli ciyaareed ee xigay ee Cleveland wuxuuna hogaamiyay horyaalka American League celcelis ahaan dhibcaha uu ka helay. badhtamihii sannadkii, Cleveland waxa uu Sutcliffe ku badalay Chicago Cubs oo uu ku badalay Mel Hall iyo Joe Carter. Sutcliffe ayaa dib u soo laabtay wuxuuna ku guuleystay 16 ciyaarood oo Cubs ah halka uu lumiyay kaliya hal, isagoo ka caawinaya horyaalka qaybta. Oktoobar 2, 1984, wuxuu bilaabay ciyaartii ugu horeysay ee NLCS
San Diego Padres, laba hits iyo wax baxsad ahna ma helin, kaliya ma uusan badin, laakiin sidoo kale wuxuu dhaliyay garoonka wareega saddexaad. Shan maalmood ka dib, Sutcliffe wuxuu ciyaaray ciyaartii ugu dambeysay ee taxanaha ee garoonka Jack Murphy, laakiin wuxuu dhajiyay guuldaradii ka dib markii uu ka tagay afar wareeg oo wareega toddobaad ah.