Dhameystir weedha soo socota: Sunagogga wuxuu si dhakhso ah u noqday xarunta bulshada yar laakiin firfircoon ee Yuhuudda, oo mid ka mid ah hoggaamiyayaasheeda, Abraham Reuben, uu noqday xubin ka mid ah golaha magaalada Karachi sanadkii 1936. Qeybinta Hindiya ee Ingiriiska oo ku saleysan diimaha diinta ee u dhexeeya Hindusyada iyo Muslimiinta bishii Ogosto 1947 waxay arkeen magaalada Karachi oo ku dhacday xuduudaha gobolka cusub ee Muslimiinta badan ee Pakistan, ka dib markii la beddelay calaamadda hore ee isku imaatinka sunagogga, iyadoo lagu magacaabay "Bulshada Pakistan Bene Israel". In ka yar sanad kadib, sunagogga waxaa weeraray oo dab qabadsiiyay rabshadaha Muslimiinta ka dib Baaqa Xorriyadda ee 1948 ee Dowladda Israa'iil. Waqtigaan, dhowr Yuhuud oo ku baahsan Pakistan ayaa la weeraray, ugu dambeyntiina waxay ku qasbeen qaybo ka mid ah bulshada inay u cararaan Hindiya deriska ah. Si kastaba ha noqotee, tirada weerarada Yuhuudda ee Pakistan ayaa kordhay kadib mid kasta oo ka mid ah dagaallada Carabta-Israa'iil ee
1948, 1956, 1967 iyo 1973. Horraantii 1970-yadii, bulshada Yuhuudda ee Pakistan waxay u badan tahay inay u baxeen Israa'iil ama Hindiya sababo la xiriira daadgureynta Yuhuudda ee dalalka Muslimka ah, taas oo si wax ku ool ah u dhigaysa sunagogga in ay u badan tahay hurdo. Bishii Luulyo 17, 1988, sunagogga ayaa la dumiyay waxaana ugu dambeyntii lagu beddelay meel laga dukaameysto (Madiha Square) oo ku taal xaafadda Ranchore Line ee koonfurta Karachi.