Ku qor sii wadida cutubkan - Maareeyaha Antonio Conte, Chiellini wuxuu ku soo laabtay booskiisii asalka ahaa ee bidix ee bidix sababtoo ah Barzagli iyo Bonucci qaab ciyaareed wanaagsan. Ka dib markii uu ku dhibtooday inuu dib ugu soo laabto booskiisii hore, wuxuu ku koray doorkiisa wuxuuna ku guuleystey inuu sii wado Paolo De Ceglie, oo ah kan kaliya ee dabiiciga ah ee ka tagay kooxda, kursiga keydka inta badan qeybtii hore ee xilli ciyaareedkii 2011-12. Qeybtii labaad ee xilli ciyaareedkii 2011-12, Conte wuxuu u wareegay difaaca seddexda nin, halkaas oo Chiellini uu la shaqeeyay Bonucci iyo Barzagli nidaam difaac oo aad u guuleystay oo loogu talagalay Juve, oo xilli ciyaareedkii ku soo gabagabeeyay horyaalnimada Serie A, oo leh rikoodhka difaaca ugu fiican, iyo sidoo kale in aan laga adkaan horyaalka. Sababtoo ah waxqabadkooda wadajirka ah, saddexda nin ee difaaca ayaa kasbaday naanaysta "BBC", oo tixraac u ah bilowga ciyaartoyda, isla markaana si dhakhso leh ayay saddexda koox isu aasaaseen mid ka mid ah difaaca ugu fiican adduunka kubada cagta xilliyada soo socda. Juventus ayaa ku guuldareysatay finalka 2012 Coppa Italia oo ay la ciyaareen Napoli, laakiin markii dambe waxay ka adkaadeen iyaga 2012 Supercoppa Italiana
, inkastoo Chiellini uu seegi doono ciyaarta.