Qoraal sii socota faqradan - Bishii Luulyo 27, 2012, Scutaro waxaa lagu kala iibsaday, iyada oo la tixgelinayo lacag caddaan ah, San Francisco Giants oo loogu talagalay ciyaaryahanka Charlie Culberson. Ciyaartii ay ka soo horjeedeen St. Louis Cardinals ee ka dhacday Busch Stadium bishii Agoosto 8, 2012, Scutaro wuxuu waday toddobo orod oo xirfadeed oo ay ku jiraan grand slam. Wuxuu dhaliyay.306 xilli ciyaareedkii caadiga ahaa, oo ay ku jiraan.362 oo ah Giant, isagoo ka caawiyay Giants inay ku guuleystaan horyaalka qaranka ee horyaalka Galbeedka. Waxaa la siiyay NLCS MVP ka dib markii uu isku daray rikoodhka NLCS oo leh 14 hits iyo sidoo kale.500 (14 for 28) oo leh lix orod oo la dhaliyay iyo afar orod oo la dhaliyay intii lagu jiray taxanaha toddobada kulan ee ka dhanka ah Cardinals
Waxaad Bishii Oktoobar 28, wareegii tobnaad ee Ciyaarta 4aad ee Taxanaha Adduunka ee 2012, Scutaro wuxuu ku kaxeeyay Ryan Theriot orodka guusha, maadaama ay Giants ay ka adkaadeen Detroit Tigers.