Wax yar ka dib markii Barnes uu u soo xulay kooxda Baltimore Colts, Barnes waxaa lagu casuumay inuu daawado ciyaarta horyaalka NFL ee Colts
New York Giants oo ka ciyaaray garoonka Memorial Stadium ee Maryland December 27, 1959. Colts waxay ku guuleysteen 31/16 Barnes waxaa ka buuxay dareen dareen ah kadib markii uu daawaday ciyaarta isagoo kursiga keydka Colts. Markii uu ahaa 21 jir, wuxuu saxiixay qandaraaskiisa kubbadda cagta wuxuuna la kulmay asxaabtiisa cusub ee Johnny Unitas, Jim Parker, Lenny Moore, Art Donovan, Gino Marchetti, Alan Ameche iyo "Big Daddy" Lipscomb.