Dhameystir weedha soo socota: Febraayo 25, 1997, New Jersey Devils waxay McCauley, oo ay weheliyaan Jason Smith iyo Steve Sullivan, ku wareejiyeen dib u dhiska Toronto Maple Leafs si ay ugu beddelaan Doug Gilmour, Dave Ellett, iyo New Jersey doorashada wareega 3aad ee
Sanadkii 1999kii McCauley waxaa loo adeegsaday inuu yahay difaac horudhac ah xilli ciyaareedkiisii ugu horreeyay ee Toronto, waxaana ku koobnaa kaliya lix gool iyo 16 dhibcood. Dhibaatooyinka garaaca wadnaha ayaa sii waday inay ku dhibaan isaga xirfad ahaan, dhaawacyadani waxay si qoto dheer u saameeyeen waxqabadkiisa barafka. Sannadkii 2000/01, wuxuu isku arkay ciyaartoy yar yar oo ka tirsan Horyaalka Hockeyga Mareykanka (AHL) ee St. John's Maple Leafs, in kasta oo loogu yeeray Toronto ciyaarta playoff-ka.