Nyorai kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Pana December 5, 1990, Alomar naJoe Carter vakatengeswa kuToronto Blue Jays mukutsinhana naFred McGriff naTony Fernández. Yakanga iri muToronto kuti akavandudza kuva mutambi mukuru wechipiri anotambudza, achibatanidza.300-plus batting average nesimba uye kukurumidza kwakakwirira pamasasa. Muna 1991, akashandisa kukurumidza kwake ne11 katatu uye 53 yakabiwa mabhesi, achitungamirira timu kune yekutanga yevatatu vanotevedzana vanoita playoff. Gore rakatevera racho, akahwina mamakisi 105, akafamba 87, uye akanga ane.405 pa-base muzana. Muna 1993, Alomar akaita mwaka wake wakanakisa neBlue Jays, achigadzira 17 home runs (HR), 93 runs batted in (RBI), uye 55 zvakabiwa mabhesi, achirova.326, wechitatu muAmerican League kuseri kwevamwe vake John Olerud naPaul Molitor. Akanga ari munhu wepakati mumakwikwi eWorld Series eToronto muna 1992 na1993; mumutambo 6 we1992 World Series, akahwina run run paDave Winfield's mbiri-run mbiri mu11th inning. Alomar's game-tying, yepfumbamwe-inning home run kurwisa Oakland relief ace Dennis Eckersley, muMutambo 4 we1992 American League Championship Series
(ALCS), inoonekwa nevakawanda seyakakosha kurova munhoroondo yekirabhu, sezvo nzendo nhatu dzakapfuura dzechikwata kuALCS dzakapera mukushungurudzika; akatumidzwa zita rekuti Most Valuable Player (MVP) yeiyo nhevedzano. Muna 1995, akatamba mitambo 104 akatevedzana pasina kuita chikanganiso, achiisa AL rekodhi yechipiri basemen. Mumwaka wega wega wechishanu neBlue Jays, Alomar akatumidzwa kuchikwata cheAll-Star uye akahwina mubairo weGold Glove.