Pedzisa mutsara unotevera: Mumwaka wake wokutanga muna 1897 neBoston Beaneaters, akarova.354, uye mumwaka wake wokutanga mitanhatu, akaenzana kupfuura.300. Muna 1899, akanga ane zvibodzwa zvitanhatu mumutambo, uye mu
1903 World Series, akarova katatu katatu. Pakazosvika 1904, kusanganisira nguva yake neBeaneaters neBoston Americans, Stahl akanga ari chikamu chinokosha chezvikwata zvina zvekukunda mumwaka minomwe.