Ramba uchinyora ndima iyi - Livingstone akabatana naMackay muScotland muna April 1689 panguva yeRising yaJacobite ya1689; seboka revatasvi vemabhiza, vakashandiswa kuchengetedza migwagwa pakati peInverness neStirling uye nokudaro vakakundikana kukunda kwaJacobite kweKilliecrankie
muna July. Pasinei nokudzokera shure uku, Mackay naLivingstone zvishoma nezvishoma vakawana simba; muna 1690, vakatungamirira mauto akasiyana muhondo yakarongwa yakaguma nokukunda kwaLivingstone paCromdale muna May. Sezviri pachena vakanyorerana muchiDutch, zvichida sechinhu chokungwarira kuti vasabatwa nevaJacobite.