Pedzisa mutsara unotevera: Musi waFebruary 28, 2011, Mitchell akatengeswa kubva kuToronto Maple Leafs kuenda kuNew York Rangers mukutsinhana nekusarudzwa kwedrafiti yechinomwe mu
Gore ra2012. Mushure mekutanga mwaka wa2011-12 neRangers AHL yakabatana neConnecticut Whale, Mitchell akadaidzwa kuRangers kumutambo musi waNovember 25, 2011, umo akanyoresa poindi yake yekutanga yeRangers nekubatsira pachinangwa naBrian Boyle.