Nyorai kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Pana March 5, 2003, Toronto yakatengesa McCauley, Brad Boyes, uye chisarudzo chokutanga cheToronto muna 2003
kuenda kuSan Jose Sharks, nesimba mberi Owen Nolan achienda kuToronto mukutsinhana. Kuchinja kwacho kwakaratidzika kuva kwakabetsera McCauley. Mumwaka wake wekutanga wakazara neSharks muna 2003-04, akaisa mabasa epamusoro muzvinangwa (20) uye mapoinzi (47). McCauley aizivikanwa nekutamba kwake kwemaviri uye kugona kwake kuuraya chirango, izvo zvakamupa iye Selke Trophy kusarudzwa muna 2003-04 semutambi akanakisa anodzivirira muligi.