Pedzisa mutsara unotevera: Nyanzvi yeKremlin yokuPoland Leopold Labedz yakatsoropodza Carr nokuda kwokutora zvirevo zvehurumende yeSoviet zvakakomba zvikuru. Labedz akapfuurira kutaura kuti chisarudzo chaCarr chokugumisa nhevedzano ye"History of Soviet Russia" muna 1929 chakaratidza kusakwanisa uye kusada kutsoropodza Soviet Union yaStalin. Labedz akanga achitsoropodza zvikuru kubata kwaCarr kwemanyuko, achitaura kuti Carr akanga achida kugamuchira zvinyorwa zveSoviet zviri pamutemo uye asingadi kubvuma kugadziriswa kwakarongeka kwezvinyorwa zvenhoroondo pasi paStalin. Pakupedzisira, Labedz akatora basa kuna Carr pamusoro pezvaaiona sekuda kwaCarr kuchenesa mhosva dzeSoviet "kumashure kwechimiro chisingaoneki icho chinowanzobatanidza "kufambira mberi" stereotypes neshoko remashoko eSoviet". Norman Stone akataura kuti Carr akanga ane mhaka yokunyora mumutauro usina kunaka waida kuvanza kunzwira tsitsi kwake kweSoviet. Walter Laqueur akataura kuti "Nhoroondo yeSoviet Russia" mavhoriyamu aive asina chokwadi nhoroondo yenhoroondo iyo kune chikamu chikuru chakaregedza zvinhu zvisingafadzi zvehupenyu hweSoviet, zvichiratidza mafungiro aCarr eSoviet. Manyuko makuru ekutsoropodzwa kwe "Nhoroondo yeSoviet Russia" yaive sarudzo yaCarr yekuregeredza Hondo yeVanhu veRussia pasi pechikonzero chekuti yakanga isina kukosha uye zvakafanana nekupa kwake mitsara mishoma chete ku
Kumukira kweKronstadt kwa1921 sezvo Carr akakuona sechiitiko chiduku bedzi. Laqueur akataura kuti kufuratira kwaCarr Hondo yeVanhu yeRussia achiri kubhadhara huwandu hwakawandisa hwekutarisisa pazvinhu zvakaita sehukama pakati peBolshevik nemaCommunist mapato eSweden uye hukama hweSoviet hwekudyidzana neOuter Mongolia muma1920 hwakasiya "Nhoroondo yeSoviet Russia" isina kuenzana.