Pedzisa mutsara unotevera: Pashure pokunge ashanda muCleveland, Ohio, dhipatimendi rezvokutandara gore rakatevera racho, akapiwa basa rokuva mubatsiri paKent State University muna 1948. Akapedza mwaka gumi nerimwe neGolden Flashes kusvika agamuchira chinzvimbo chemubatsiri wekurairidza neBaltimore Colts muna 1959 pasi pemurairidzi mukuru Weeb Ewbank. Mukati menguva iyoyo yokutanga pamwero wenyanzvi, McCafferty akanga ari rutivi rweColts yechipiri yakatevedzana
chikwata chokukunda.