Nyorai kupfuurira kweiyi ndima - Macdonogh akanga asina kuvimbwa naHaig uye chipangamazano wezvenhau waHaig John Charteris, uyo aiva nekunyorerana kwakashata naye. Akapa nhamba kuWar Cabinet muna October 1917, achidurura mvura inotonhora pakufanotaura kwaHaig kwokuti simba revanhu vokuGermany raizopera pakupera kwegore. Chinyorwa chakashata mubhuku raHaig (15 October 1917) chinotaura kuti MacDonogh "ndiye muRoma Katurike uye (zvichida asingazivi) anokurudzirwa nemashoko anosvika kwaari achibva kunzvimbo dzakasvibiswa (ndiko kuti, dzeKaturike)". Akafanotaurawo musi, nguva nenzvimbo yeGermany March 1918 "Michael
" Anogumbura, sezvakaita Charteris.