Tha Colgate air a liostadh mar aon de na 30 oilthighean as fheàrr airson a bhith a 'faighinn beairteach ann an Forbes, an aon cholaiste neo-Ivy League anns a' chiad 5. Tha Colgate air a liostadh mar aon de na 25 "New Ivies" Ameireagaidh le iris Newsweek. Tha Colgate cuideachd air a liostadh mar aon de na "100 oilthighean as fheàrr airson oileanaich LGBT".
Colgate