Ia tusi se faaauauga o lenei palakalafa - Na fanau Tuttle i Horseheads, i Niu Ioka iā Tesema 10, 1870. Na faauu o ia mai le Horseheads High School ma le Elmira Free Academy i le 1887 ma auai i le Iunivesite o Cornell mo le lua tausaga. Sa ia galue i le pisinisi laupapa i Westfield, i New Jersey. O Tuttle o se sui o le Democratic National Convention i le 1908 ma le 1916
.