Monteith menangaké Teen Choice Award 2011 ing kategori Choice TV: Actor Comedy kanggo perannya dadi Finn, lan dadi anggota saka ensemble "Glee" sing diwenehi penghargaan Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series ing 16th Screen Actors Guild Awards. Dheweke nampa sawetara nominasi liyane kanggo peran kasebut, kalebu Teen Choice Awards ing taun 2009 kanggo Choice TV: Breakout Star Male lan ing taun 2010 kanggo Choice TV: Comedy Actor, lan 17th Screen Actors Guild Awards
nominasi ensemble kanggo Outstanding Performance dening Ensemble ing Seri Komedi.