Mezue ahịrịokwu na-esonụ: May nwetara ohere n'egwuregwu oge ezumike, ma ọ bụghị na White Sox. N'ụbọchị iri na asatọ nke ọnwa Mee, n'afọ 2009, a gbanwere ya na Yankees maka onye na-agba agba Ken Brett na onye otu ya bụ Rich Coggins. E mere nkwekọrịta ahụ mgbe ndị Yankees nọ n'ọsọ asọmpi na-ekpo ọkụ. N'afọ ahụ, ọ gbara.278 na Yankees gara World Series. N'oge
ALCS, May gbara 2-for-10 na okpukpu abụọ na ije. Na World Series megide Cincinnati Reds, ọ nwetaghị ihe ọ bụla na 9 na bats wee kwụsị na.105 batting nkezi na postseason.