Mezue ahịrịokwu na-esonụ: McCoy rụrụ ọrụ na World Series na 1977 na 1988. Ọ bụkwa onye ọka ikpe na American League Championship Series ugboro isii (1973,
1976, 1980, 1986, 1990 na 1997) na atọ All-Star egwuregwu (1978, 1985 na 1996), na-akpọ bọọlụ na strikes maka 1985 egwuregwu. McCoy rụrụ ọrụ na American League Division Series na 1981, 1995 na 1998. Ọ bụ onye ikpe ikpe nke atọ na Eprel 20, 1986, mgbe Roger Clemens ghọrọ onye mbụ na-atụ egwu iji kpochapụ ndị batrị 20 na egwuregwu itoolu. McCoy bụkwa onye isi oche nke mbụ maka egwuregwu zuru oke nke David Cone na July 18, 1999. Ọ bụ onye ọka ikpe maka abalị Ten Cent Beer Night nke ndị Cleveland Indians mere na June 4, 1974, nke kwụsịrị na mmeri maka Texas Rangers. Ọ bụkwa onye ọka ikpe ụlọ na Phil Niekro 300th ọrụ mmeri na Toronto na Ọktọba 6, 1985.