Mezue ahịrịokwu na-esonụ: Mgbe ọ nọchara na Congress, Caruth maliteghachiri ọrụ iwu na Louisville. Ọ rụrụ ọrụ dị ka onye ọka ikpe nke ngalaba mpụ nke Jefferson County Circuit Court na 1902. O jere ozi dịka kọmishọna nke
Ihe ngosi St. Louis na 1904. Ọ nwụrụ na Louisville na November 25, 1907, ma lie ya na Cave Hill Cemetery.