Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A cikin 2018, McAfee ya fara bayyana a cikin shirye-shiryen WWE a matsayin mai sharhi na farko don abubuwan da kamfanin NXT TakeOver ya yi, wanda ya fara da 2018, inda ya ci gaba da ƙaramin rikici tare da Adam Cole. Daga baya ya bayyana a, da kuma. A watan Disamba, an ba da rahoton cewa ya sanya hannu kan kwangilar shekaru da yawa tare da WWE, kuma a hukumance ya sanya hannu kan kwangilar a watan Fabrairun 2019. Daga nan sai ya fara watsa shirye-shiryen kallon WWE na biyan kuɗi a kan YouTube, yana farawa da
Fastlane, tare da wasu 'yan damben WWE. A cikin ginin WrestleMania, McAfee, da ma'aikatansa da baƙi na musamman daban-daban sun yi tafiya daga wuri zuwa wuri a cikin RV, cewa abokinsa Zito ya makale a ƙarƙashin wani shinge a filin wasa na MetLife, wanda aka yi fim don "Pat McAfee's Road to WrestleMania". A bayan fage a taron, McAfee ya yi jayayya da Michael Cole, lokacin da Cole ya soki shi saboda saka gajeren wando. McAfee ya yi barazanar yin murabus nan take kuma aka tura shi zuwa wani ɗaki yayin da ake kula da lamarin. Bayan da aka nuna wa Vince McMahon hoton LeBron James a wasan karshe na NBA na 2018, kuma cewa kayan aikin sun yi kama da wanda McAfee ya sa don WrestleMania, McMahon ya amince kuma an ba McAfee damar zama mai watsa shiri na biyu na pre-show, tare da Charly Caruso.