Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A ranar 22 ga Fabrairun 2017, Bálor ya koma NXT don taimaka wa Shinsuke Nakamura, wanda Andrade "Cien" Almas da Bobby Roode suka fi shi yawa. A ranar 10 ga Maris, Bálor ya sake dawowa a cikin wasan kwaikwayo a wani taron kai tsaye a wasan rukuni na mutum shida, tare da Chris Jericho da Sami Zayn don kayar da Kevin Owens, Samoa Joe da Triple H. Bálor ya sake komawa talabijin bayan WrestleMania 33 a ranar 3 ga Afrilu a cikin "Raw", inda ya haɗu da tsohon abokin hamayyarsa Seth Rollins yayin da su biyun suka ci Owens da Joe a wasan rukuni. A cikin makonni masu zuwa, Bálor zai ci nasara a kan Jinder Mahal da Curt Hawkins yayin da yake karɓar gargadi daga Bray Wyatt da kuma fuskantar Luke Gallows da Karl Anderson. A ranar 4 ga watan Yuni a
Extreme Rules, Bálor ya yi gasa a cikin mummunan wasan ƙa'idodi na ƙa'idodi guda biyar don tantance mai neman lamba ɗaya don Brock Lesnar's Universal Championship, wanda Bálor ya rasa bayan ya fita daga Samoa Joe's "Coquina Clutch".