Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - Duk da haka, lambun da ba shi da rufi yana da zafi a lokacin rani kuma yana daskarewa a lokacin hunturu. Vanderbilt a ƙarshe ya sayar da abin da "Harper's Weekly" ya kira "tsohuwar harsashi, mai ƙazanta, mai ƙazanta, mai ƙonewa" ga ƙungiyar da ta haɗa da J. P. Morgan, Andrew Carnegie, James Stillman da W. W. Astor, waɗanda suka rufe shi don gina sabon filin wasa wanda sanannen masanin Stanford White ya tsara. Rushewa ya fara ne a watan Yulin 1889, kuma Madison Square Garden na biyu
, wanda ya kashe fiye da rabin dala miliyan don ginawa, an bude shi a ranar 6 ga Yuni, 1890. An rushe shi a 1926, kuma New York Life Building, wanda Cass Gilbert ya tsara kuma ya kammala a 1928, ya maye gurbinsa a shafin.