Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - Bayan ya yi ritaya a matsayin dan wasa, Sandusky ya fara aiki mai tsawo. Aikinsa na farko shi ne a matsayin mataimaki a Villanova a shekara ta 1957. Ya zauna a can har zuwa 1959, lokacin da babban kocin Baltimore Colts Weeb Ewbank ya dauke shi aiki, wanda ya kasance mataimakin Browns lokacin da Sandusky ya taka leda a Cleveland. Da farko shi ne mai horar da layin tsaro na Colts, wanda ya gama kakar wasan farko ta Sandusky tare da rikodin nasara 9<unk>3 kuma ya lashe NFL West a bayan laifin da quarterback Johnny Unitas da halfback Lenny Moore suka jagoranta. Colts sun ci gaba da lashe gasar zakarun NFL
a kan New York Giants.