Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Livingstone ya haɗu da Mackay a Scotland a watan Afrilu 1689 a lokacin 1689 Jacobite Rising; a matsayin doki, an yi amfani da su don tabbatar da hanyoyi tsakanin Inverness da Stirling kuma don haka sun rasa nasarar Jacobite na
Killiecrankie a watan Yuli. Duk da wannan koma baya, Mackay da Livingstone sun sami iko a hankali; a cikin 1690, sun jagoranci dakarun da suka bambanta a cikin yakin da aka tsara wanda ya ƙare a nasarar Livingstone a Cromdale a watan Mayu. Da alama sun rubuta wa juna a cikin Yaren mutanen Holland, wataƙila don kiyayewa daga saɓo daga Jacobites.