Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A Royal Rumble a ranar 27 ga Janairu, 2019, Styles ya sake kasa lashe taken, bayan da Rowan ya dawo ya kai wa Styles hari lokacin da alkalin wasa ya kasa aiki kuma ya ba Bryan damar riƙe taken. Bayan Royal Rumble, Styles ya sami wata dama don dawo da zakara bayan ya cancanci shiga wasan Elimination Chamber. A cikin Wurin Cirewa a ranar 17 ga Fabrairu, Styles bai yi nasara ba bayan Randy Orton ya kawar da shi. Bayan Elimination Chamber, duka Styles da Randy Orton sun fara yin maganganu marasa kyau game da juna, suna fara rikici tsakanin su biyun. A cikin
Fastlane, bayan da Orton ya katse Elias, Styles ya bugi Orton da wani babban harbi daga babu inda. Wannan ya haifar da rikici tsakanin su biyu a ranar 12 ga Maris a cikin "SmackDown Live", wanda Styles ya kalubalanci Orton zuwa wasa a WrestleMania 35. A WrestleMania, Styles ya ci Orton. Kashegari, an bayar da rahoton cewa Styles ya ji rauni a lokacin wasan da ya yi da Orton kuma an tura shi gida don murmurewa. Styles bai bayyana a kan "SmackDown Live" ba bayan WrestleMania, kuma an bayar da rahoton cewa rauni ne na hip.