Kammala wannan magana: A ranar 26 ga Fabrairun 2008, Maple Leafs sun yi musayar Gill zuwa Pittsburgh Penguins a musayar zagaye na biyu na 2008 da kuma
Zaɓin zagaye na biyar na 2009. Kungiyar ta kai wasan karshe na Stanley Cup, inda ta yi rashin nasara a wasanni shida da Detroit Red Wings. Kungiyar ta kai wasan karshe na Stanley Cup a kakar wasa mai zuwa, a wannan lokacin ta doke Red Wings don lashe Stanley Cup.