Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Rhyno ya koma gidan talabijin na WWE watanni goma sha shida bayan haka a ranar 27 ga Fabrairu, 2003 a cikin shirin "SmackDown!", yana daidaita kansa da Chris Benoit kuma don haka ya zama fuska a karon farko a cikin aikinsa na WWE. Rhyno da Benoit sun ci gaba da kalubalanci Team Angle ba tare da nasara ba don WWE Tag Team Championship a cikin wasan rukuni na barazanar sau uku (wanda ya haɗa da Los Guerreros) a WrestleMania XIX. A Ranar Shari'a, Rhyno ya haɗu da Spanky, da Chris Benoit a cikin ƙoƙari na rasa John Cena da The Full Blooded Italians (Chuck Palumbo da Johnny Stamboli). A Vengeance, Rhyno ya juya kan Benoit yayin wasan Gasar Amurka da Eddie Guerrero, don haka ya sake juyawa. Rhyno ya ci gaba da kokawa a kan "SmackDown!" yana neman gasar zakarun Amurka a lokuta da dama. A cikin
SummerSlam, Rhyno ya yi gasa a cikin Fatal hudu-hanyar wasa don WWE United States Championship amma ya kasa lashe taken. A Royal Rumble, Rhyno ya fafata a wasan Royal Rumble na maza 30 inda ya shiga a # 6 amma Chris Benoit ya fitar da shi. A watan Maris na shekara ta 2004, Rhyno an tsara shi zuwa alamar Raw a cikin 2004 WWE Draft Lottery. Daga baya a wannan daren, ya fuskanci Chris Benoit don Gasar Cin Kofin Duniya a cikin kokarin da aka rasa. A mako mai zuwa a kan Raw, ya sake juyawa ta hanyar fara murkushe Lance Storm a cikin wasa sannan ya kafa ƙungiya tare da Tajiri. Duo ya kalubalanci Gasar Tag Team Championship ta Duniya a lokuta da yawa a cikin 2004. A watan Janairun 2005 a wani labarin na Raw, Rhyno ya rasa wasan neman cancanta na Royal Rumble zuwa Edge.