Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A ranar 30 ga Maris a cikin "Raw", Sheamus ya dawo daga rauni, bayan ya canza kamanninsa sosai, gami da mohawk da gemu mai gemu, yana bayyana don ceton Daniel Bryan da Dolph Ziggler daga harin Bad News Barrett, amma sai ya kai wa Bryan da Ziggler hari a maimakon haka, yana juya diddige a cikin tsari a karon farko tun 2011. Daga nan Sheamus ya bayyana sauyin sa da sabon halin ta hanyar iƙirarin cewa "zamanin marasa ƙarfi ya ƙare", wanda ya haifar da rikici da Ziggler. A ranar 16 ga Afrilu na "SmackDown", Sheamus ya ba da sanarwar cewa zai fuskanci Ziggler a cikin Kiss Me Ass wasan a Extreme Rules, wanda ya yi asara. Koyaya, Sheamus ya ƙi bin ƙa'idar, kuma a maimakon haka ya sa Ziggler ya sumbace shi, duk da rashin nasara. A cikin
Ramuwa, Sheamus ya ci Ziggler a wasan ramuwa. A Gidan Cirewa, Sheamus ya halarci wasan Gidan Cirewa don gasar cin kofin Intercontinental, amma bai yi nasara ba yayin da Ryback ya ci wasan. A Kudi a Bankin, Sheamus ya lashe kudin da ke cikin bankin don samun kwangilar WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Daga nan sai Sheamus ya fara rikici da Randy Orton, wanda shi ma ya kasance cikin wasan tsere, tare da maza biyu suna kai wa juna hari da kuma fuskantar juna a wasannin tag-team. Sheamus ya yi rashin nasara a kan Orton a Battleground, amma ya ci Orton a SummerSlam.