A cikin shekarar 2019, US News & World Report ya sanya Colgate a matsayin mafi kyawun kwalejin zane-zane na 16 a cikin ƙasar (wanda ke da alaƙa da Hamilton College). An sanya harabar jami'ar a matsayin mafi kyau ta The Princeton Review a cikin fitowar su ta 2010. A watan Yulin 2008, an sanya Colgate a matsayin na biyar a cikin jerin Forbes na Top Colleges for Getting Rich, kwalejin da ba Ivy League ba a cikin manyan 5. An sanya Colgate a matsayin ɗaya daga cikin 25 "New Ivies" na Amurka ta mujallar Newsweek.
100 mafi kyawun makarantun don daliban LGBT