Cajtoft ya fara kakar wasa ta 2014 a matsayin mai tsaron gidan na uku, amma raunin da ya faru ga Niklas Helgesson da Damir Mehić ya sanya shi zaɓi na farko ga manajan Jimmy Thelin. Bugu da ƙari, ya sake tabbatar da kansa ya cancanci farawa kuma ya buga wasanni 27 tsakanin sanduna a wannan shekarar. A kakar wasa ta gaba, shi da Mehic sun raba aikin mai tsaron gida. Cajtoft ya bayyana a wasanni 19 kuma ya rubuta wasanni hudu. J-Södra ya gama a matsayin zakarun gasar kuma an inganta shi zuwa Allsvenskan don
Shekarar 2016. Cajtoft ya fara buga wasan farko a lokacin wasan farko a ranar 2 ga Afrilu a kan Kalmar, inda ya sake yin rikodin wani shutout a cikin nasara 1-0. Wannan shi ne nasarar farko ta J-Södra a cikin shekaru 47.