Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Daga nan sai Rawley ya fafata a gasar zakarun Amurka, inda ya doke Zack Ryder a zagaye na farko, amma ya yi rashin nasara ga Bobby Roode a wasan kusa da na karshe. A Royal Rumble a ranar 28 ga Janairu, 2018, Rawley ya amsa ƙalubalen da Bobby Roode ya buɗe don Gasar Amurka, amma bai yi nasara ba wajen lashe taken. A matsayin wani ɓangare na Superstar Shake-up, an tsara Rawley zuwa Raw alama. A ranar 27 ga Afrilu, Rawley ya shiga cikin
Mafi Girma Royal Rumble, shiga a lamba 29, amma an kawar da Randy Orton. A ranar 18 ga watan Yuni na "Raw", bayan ya ci No Way Jose, Rawley ya yi iƙirarin cewa ba a ƙara ɗaukaka shi ba kuma kawai ya mai da hankali. A cikin makonni masu zuwa a kan "Raw", Rawley ya ci No Way Jose, da Tyler Breeze sau da yawa. Bayan ɗan gajeren rikici tare da Bobby Roode, Rawley ya sami kansa daga Raw na dogon lokaci. Daga watan Janairu 28, 2019 na Raw, Rawley ya fara bayyana a cikin sassan da aka riga aka yi rikodin suna magana da wani mutum a bayan allo, yana ɗora musu laifin rashin nasararsa, kafin a bayyana cewa yana magana da madubi. A ranar 13 ga watan Mayu na "Raw", ya fara fitowa da sabon salo, inda ya kayar da Apollo Crews. Duk da haka, an yi watsi da gimmick.