Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Don kakar wasa mai zuwa, maimakon dawo da 'yan wasan Blueshirts zuwa Livingstone kamar yadda aka alkawarta a asali, a ranar 19 ga Oktoba, 1918, Kamfanin Arena ya kafa Toronto Arena Hockey Club, wanda aka ba shi cikakken memba a cikin NHL. Kamfanin Arena ya kuma yanke shawara a wannan shekarar cewa ƙungiyoyin NHL ne kawai aka ba su izinin yin wasa a Arena Gardens - matakin da ya kashe NHA. Livingstone ya kai kara domin ya dawo da 'yan wasansa. Ƙididdigar lissafin doka daga rikici ya tilasta Arenas ya sayar da wasu daga cikin taurari, wanda ya haifar da mummunar nasara biyar a kakar wasa ta 1918-1919. Tare da kamfanin da ke fuskantar matsalolin kudi, kuma Arenas an cire shi daga wasan, NHL ta amince da barin kungiyar ta rasa wasanninsu biyu na karshe. An dakatar da ayyukan a ranar 20 ga Fabrairu, 1919, tare da NHL ta ƙare lokacinta kuma ta fara wasan kwaikwayo. Arenas'.278 nasara kashi cewa kakar ya kasance mafi muni a franchise tarihi. Duk da haka, da
1919 Stanley Cup Finals ya ƙare ba tare da mai nasara ba saboda annobar mura a duniya.