Kammala wannan jumla: LaFayette ya rubuta ta St. Louis Blues a zagaye na 3 (65th overall) na
Tsarin shiga NHL na 1991. Ya zira kwallaye na farko na NHL, taimako, a ranar 14 ga Janairu, 1994 a kan Edmonton Oilers wanda ya kafa biyu-da-daya don Craig Janney da Brendan Shanahan, kuma Shanahan ya zira kwallaye. Blues sun yi niyyar LaFayette ya yi wasa a ƙungiyar 'yan wasan ƙwallon ƙafa, Peoria Rivermen, don tsawon kakar wasa, amma saboda raunin da ya samu, ya buga wasanni 38 na NHL tare da Blues kafin a yi ciniki.