Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Mujallar "Time" ta ambaci Ziegler a matsayin ɗaya daga cikin "matasa 30 masu tasiri na 2015" ta sake yin jerin a cikin 2016 da kuma a cikin 2017. Ta kuma kasance a cikin "Harpers Bazaar" 2015 jerin "19 Rising Style Icons Aged 19 da Under". "Billboard" ya zaɓi wasan kwaikwayon Sia da Ziegler na "Elastic Heart" a "Saturday Night Live" 2015 a matsayin ɗayan 10 Mafi kyawun wasan kwaikwayo na SNL tun daga shekarun 1990, "godiya a wani ɓangare ga dan wasan mai shekaru 12 mai suna Maddie Ziegler, wanda... ya nuna iko, rauni, da fiye da ɗan ban mamaki". Ziegler ya lashe gasar 2016
Kyautar Zaɓin Jama'a, Kyautar Zaɓin Matasa ta 2016 da Kyautar Zaɓin Matasa ta 2017. An zabi ta ne don lambar yabo ta Shorty 2016 da lambar yabo ta Shorty 2017 guda hudu, inda ta ci nasara a wani rukuni kuma ta sami girmamawar masu sauraro a wani. A cikin 2018 da 2019, "The Hollywood Reporter" sunaye Ziegler a cikin manyan taurari talatin na Hollywood a ƙarƙashin shekaru goma sha takwas. A cikin 2018, a shekara ta uku a jere, Ziegler ya lashe kyautar Choice Dancer a Kyautar Zaɓin Matasa.