Ka cika wannan jumla: Shuttleworth ya auri Matilda White a shekara ta 1862. A wannan lokacin, an nada shi shugaban kungiyar Maple Leaf, wanda ya buga wasanni uku da kungiyar Woodstock tsakanin 1862 da 1864, ya rasa kowane lokaci. An kafa Kungiyar Kwallon Kwallon Kwallon Kanada a 1864, tare da Shuttleworth a matsayin mataimakin shugabanta na farko; A shekara ta 1865, Shuttleworth ya haɗu da ɗan'uwansa James a kan Maple Leaf, kuma ya sami kuri'a don kasancewa shugaban kungiyar. A wani wasa na Yuni 1865 da West Flamboro, ya zira kwallaye shida kuma an bayyana shi a matsayin "musamman mai saurin aiki a wannan lokacin" kamar yadda Maple Leaf ya ci 34<unk>11. 'Yan uwan Shuttleworth kowannensu ya taka leda a nasarar da kulob din ya yi a kan Maple Leaf na Guelph, Niagara, da Newcastle Beaver, da Ingorsoll kafin a soke wasa da kungiyar Woodstock saboda takaddama kan wasan da za a yi amfani da shi. A shekara ta 1866, an jinkirta fara kakar wasan Maple Leaf, kamar yadda Shuttleworth da akalla wasu 'yan wasa biyu suka shiga Battalion na goma sha uku kuma suna kare Hamilton a lokacin yakin basasa.
'Yan Fenian sun kai hari. A ranar 9 ga watan Agusta, ya ji rauni a lokacin wasa da Beaver kuma dole ne ya bar asara ta 75<unk>44 a cikin wasan na uku. Ya koma kungiyar a tsakiyar watan Agusta, inda ya zira kwallaye uku a wasan da Ingersoll ta yi nasara.