Kammala wannan jumla: Monteith ya lashe kyautar 2011 Teen Choice Award a cikin Zaɓin TV: Actor Comedy category don nuna Finn, kuma ya kasance memba na "Glee" cast ensemble da aka ba da Kyauta ta Musamman ta Ensemble a cikin Kyautar Comedy Series a
Kyautar Gida ta Gida ta 16. Ya karɓi wasu gabatarwa da yawa don rawar, gami da Kyautar Zaɓin Matasa a cikin 2009 don Zaɓin TV: Breakout Star Male da kuma a cikin 2010 don Zaɓin TV: Comedy Actor, da kuma lambar yabo ta 17th Screen Actors Guild Awards don Babban Ayyuka ta Ensemble a cikin jerin wasan kwaikwayo.