Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A ranar 8 ga Yuli, 2010, O'Malley ya sami lambar yabo ta Primetime Emmy Award don fitaccen Baƙon Baƙo <unk> Jerin wasan kwaikwayo don wasa Burt. A ranar 8 ga watan Agusta, 2010, an nada shi a matsayin wanda ya lashe lambar yabo ta 2010 Teen Choice Awards, Choice TV: Nau'in Iyaye. A cikin
17th Screen Actors Guild Awards, O'Malley an haɗa shi a cikin ƙungiyar "Glee" ta ƙungiyar da aka zaɓa don Babban Ayyukan da Ƙungiyar ta yi a cikin jerin wasan kwaikwayo.