Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - A ranar 22 ga Fabrairun 2017, Bálor ya koma NXT don taimaka wa Shinsuke Nakamura, wanda Andrade "Cien" Almas da Bobby Roode suka fi shi yawa. A ranar 10 ga Maris, Bálor ya sake dawowa a cikin wasan kwaikwayo a wani taron kai tsaye a wasan rukuni na mutum shida, tare da Chris Jericho da Sami Zayn don kayar da Kevin Owens, Samoa Joe da Triple H. Bálor ya sake komawa talabijin bayan WrestleMania 33 a ranar 3 ga Afrilu a cikin "Raw", inda ya haɗu da tsohon abokin hamayyarsa Seth Rollins yayin da su biyun suka ci Owens da Joe a wasan rukuni. A cikin makonni masu zuwa, Bálor zai ci nasara a kan Jinder Mahal da Curt Hawkins yayin da yake karɓar gargadi daga Bray Wyatt da kuma fuskantar Luke Gallows da Karl Anderson. A ranar 4 ga watan Yuni a Extreme Rules
, Bálor ya yi gasa a cikin mummunan wasan ƙa'idodi biyar don ƙayyade mai neman lamba ɗaya don Brock Lesnar's Universal Championship, wanda Bálor ya rasa bayan ya fita daga Samoa Joe's "Coquina Clutch".