Kammala wannan jumla: A watan Maris, O'Keefe ta yi gasa a Gidan Gymnix na Duniya a Kanada inda ta kasance ta farko a cikin dukkanin abubuwan da suka faru kuma ta gama na uku a kowane taron. A watan Afrilu, ta halarci Gasar Cin Kofin Birnin Jesolo ta 2017. A Jesolo ta gama na biyu a cikin dukkan-a kusa da Gabby Perea. O'Keefe kuma ya lashe lambar tagulla a cikin sanduna marasa daidaito da daidaitaccen ƙwallon ƙafa, da kuma lambar azurfa a wasan karshe na wasan motsa jiki. A watan Yuni O'Keefe ta sanar da cewa ta yi alkawarin halartar Jami'ar Utah a kan karatun motsa jiki. A watan Agusta, ta lashe duka-kusa a
Gasar Gasar Gymnastics ta Amurka ta 2017. An zabi ta tare da Emma Malabuyo wanda ya lashe lambar azurfa don wakiltar Amurka a Gasar Gymnastics ta Junior ta Duniya ta 2017 a watan da ya gabata a Japan. A can O'Keefe ya sami zinare a cikin duka-ko'ina kuma a kan katako da azurfa a ƙasa, vault, da kuma sanduna marasa daidaito.