Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - Bayan gasar zakarun farko ta NFL ta Colts, ƙungiyar ta sake yin rikodin 9<unk>3 a lokacin kakar wasan 1959 kuma ta sake kayar da Giants a Wasannin Gasar NFL
don da'awar taken su na biyu a baya-da-baya fashion. Bayan gasar zakarun biyu a 1958 da 1959, Colts ba su koma gasar zakarun NFL ba har tsawon shekaru hudu kuma sun ga sauyawa daga babban kocin Ewbank zuwa wani matashi Don Shula a 1963. A kakar wasa ta biyu na Shula Colts sun tattara rikodin 12<unk>2, amma sun rasa 27<unk>0 ga Cleveland Browns a Gasar NFL. A cikin 1965 Colts sun buga Green Bay Packers a cikin wasan wasa don sanin wanda zai je wasan Gasar NFL. Colts suna jagorantar 10 zuwa 7 a kan Green Bay Packers tare da minti biyu da suka rage don wasa lokacin da mai buga kwallo na Packers, Don Chandler ya yi kama da kusan ba shi da wata manufa. Alkalin wasa ya kira shi mai kyau duk da haka, kuma Packers ya ci gaba da lashe wasan a cikin karin lokaci. Kuskuren ya haifar da canje-canje ga dokoki: NFL ta yanke shawarar alƙalai biyu za su yanke hukunci game da burin filin gaba, kuma ya kamata a ɗaga tsayin da ƙafa uku. A cikin 1968 Colts sun dawo tare da ci gaba da jagorancin Unitas da Shula kuma sun ci gaba da lashe gasar cin kofin NFL na uku na Colts kuma sun bayyana a Super Bowl III. A cikin 1968, Unitas ya ji rauni kuma Earl Morrall ya maye gurbinsa wanda ya zama MVP na gasar.