Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Ricketts ya yi farin ciki a kakar wasa ta farko a gasar Major League Soccer a karkashin Bruce Arena, wanda ya jagoranci Galaxy zuwa gasar cin kofin yamma. Tawagarsa ta samu nasarar kaiwa wasan karshe na MLS Cup na 2009. A wasan karshe na gasar, ya sami rauni a tsakiyar wasan kuma an maye gurbin mai tsaron gida Josh Saunders. Saunders ya cika da kyau, la'akari da Ricketts ya fara yawancin wasannin a kakar '09, amma bai isa ya kare Real Salt Lake ba, wanda ya ci nasara ta hanyar bugun fansa. A shekara ta 2010, an zabi Ricketts a matsayin "MLS Goalkeeper of the Year". Ricketts bai buga mafi yawan kakar 2011 ba saboda rauni, kuma Saunders ya sake maye gurbinsa yayin da tawagarsa ta lashe gasar
Kofin MLS na shekara ta 2011.