Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Bayan gasar zakarun farko ta Colts ta NFL, ƙungiyar ta buga rikodin 9<unk>3 a lokacin kakar wasan 1959 kuma ta sake kayar da Giants a cikin
Wasan Gasar Gasar NFL don da'awar taken su na biyu a baya baya baya. Bayan gasar zakarun biyu a 1958 da 1959, Colts ba su koma gasar cin kofin NFL ba har tsawon shekaru hudu kuma sun maye gurbin babban kocin Ewbank da matashi Don Shula a 1963. A kakar wasa ta biyu na Shula Colts sun tattara rikodin 12<unk>2, amma sun yi rashin nasara ga Cleveland Browns a gasar zakarun NFL. Koyaya, a cikin 1968 Colts sun dawo tare da ci gaba da jagorancin Unitas da Shula kuma sun ci gaba da lashe Gasar NFL ta uku ta Colts kuma sun bayyana a Super Bowl III.