Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A ranar 25 ga Oktoba na "SmackDown", Natalya ya yi rashin nasara a kan Nikki Bella a wasan da za a tantance kyaftin din kungiyar mata ta SmackDown a gasar Survivor Series pay-per-view. Koyaya, bayan an kai wa Nikki hari a bayan fage kafin wasan, Natalya ta maye gurbin Nikki amma ta jagoranci tawagarta zuwa ga nasara. A lokacin biya-da-gani, Carmella ya zargi Natalya da zama mai kaiwa Nikki hari a Survivor Series; Natalya ta musanta wannan har tsawon makonni kafin ta kai wa Carmella hari a ranar 20 ga Disamba a cikin shirin "SmackDown" kuma ta yarda da kai wa Nikki hari, tana bayyana kishiyar kishiyar nasarar Bella a tsawon shekaru. An shirya Natalya da Nikki don yin gasa a cikin wasa a ranar 10 ga Janairu, 2017, a cikin shirin "SmackDown", amma ba a fara wasan a hukumance ba saboda rikici tsakanin su biyun, inda alƙalai suka shigo don raba su. A Royal Rumble pay-per-view a ranar 29 ga Janairu, Natalya ta yi gasa a wasan mata shida tare da Alexa Bliss da Mickie James a kan Nikki, Naomi, da Becky Lynch, inda aka kayar da tawagarta bayan da Naomi ta kama Bliss. A ranar 12 ga watan Fabrairu a
Elimination Chamber pay-per-view, Natalya ta fuskanci Nikki a gasar singles, wanda ya ƙare a cikin sau biyu. Rikicin ya ƙare a cikin Falls Count Anywhere wasan a ranar 21 ga Fabrairu a cikin "SmackDown", wanda Natalya ya yi nasara bayan tsangwama daga Maryse. A ranar 18 ga Yuni a Kudi a Bankin, Natalya ya yi gasa a wasan farko na mata na Kudi a Bankin Bankin, wanda Carmella ya lashe bayan tsoma baki da James Ellsworth ya yi.