Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Unitas ya kafa bayanan NFL da yawa kuma an kira shi Mafi Kyawun Player sau uku a 1959, 1964, da 1967, ban da karɓar 10 Pro Bowl da biyar na farko-team All-Pro girmamawa. Ya taimaka ya jagoranci Colts zuwa hudu gasar zakarun Turai lakabi; uku pre-haɗuwa zamanin a 1958,
1959, 1968, da kuma Super Bowl guda daya a Super Bowl V. An dauki nasararsa ta farko a matsayin daya daga cikin manyan wasannin gasar kuma an yaba shi da taimakawa wajen yada NFL. Tsakanin 1956 da 1960, ya kafa tarihi don mafi yawan wasanni a jere tare da wucewa na touchdown a 47, wanda ya yi shekaru 52.