Kammala jumla mai zuwa: A ranar 14 ga Janairu, 2019 na "Raw", Lashley ya lashe Gasar Cin Kofin Duniya a karo na farko a cikin aikinsa, daga Dean Ambrose a wasan barazanar sau uku wanda kuma ya hada da Seth Rollins, wanda ya fara mulkinsa na farko a WWE tun Yuni 2007. A Royal Rumble, Lashley ya shiga wasan Royal Rumble a matsayin mai shiga 26th, amma an cire shi a cikin dakika goma sha uku daga mai nasara Seth Rollins. A cikin
Wurin kawarwa, Lashley ya rasa kambinsa ga Finn Bálor a wasan rashin ƙarfi wanda ya haɗa da Lio Rush bayan an kama Rush, yana kawo ƙarshen mulkinsa a kwanaki 34. A Fastlane a ranar 10 ga Maris, Lashley ya haɗu da Baron Corbin da Drew McIntyre a kan Garkuwar a cikin ƙoƙari na rashin nasara. A daren da ya biyo baya a kan "Raw", Lashley ya ci Finn Bálor bayan tsangwama daga Lio Rush, don kama gasar zakarun Turai, don haka ya fara mulkinsa na biyu. A ranar 25 ga Maris a cikin "Raw", Lashley ya haɗu da Jinder Mahal a kan Finn Bálor a cikin ƙoƙari na rashin nasara bayan da aka ɗora Mahal, kuma bisa ga sharuddan wasan, Bálor ya sami nasarar sake buga gasar zakarun Turai da Lashley. A WrestleMania 35, Lashley ya rasa lakabi ga Bálor, ya ƙare mulkinsa a kwanaki 27.