Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Monteith ya lashe lambar yabo ta 2011 Teen Choice Award a cikin Choice TV: Actor Comedy category don nuna Finn, kuma ya kasance memba na "Glee" wanda aka ba shi lambar yabo ta Musamman ta Ensemble a cikin jerin wasan kwaikwayo a 16th Screen Actors Guild Awards. Ya sami wasu gabatarwa da yawa don rawar, gami da Kyautar Zaɓin Matasa a cikin 2009 don Zaɓin TV: Breakout Star Male da kuma a cikin 2010 don Zaɓin TV: Mai wasan kwaikwayo na wasan kwaikwayo, da kuma
17th Screen Actors Guild Awards ƙungiyar da aka zaɓa don Babban Ayyukan da Ƙungiya ta yi a cikin jerin wasan kwaikwayo.