Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - A watan Satumbar 2013, Garrett ta sami gwaji a yankin ci gaban WWE na NXT a ranar 13 ga Satumba, 2013 wanda aka watsa a jinkirin tef a ranar 9 ga Oktoba, inda ta fuskanci Charlotte tare da Bayley a cikin ƙoƙari na rashin nasara. A shekara ta 2016, duk da cewa ba a sanya hannu a WWE ba, Garrett ya bayyana sau uku a kan "NXT", ya rasa Asuka, Emma da Billie Kay. A ranar 13 ga Yuli, 2017, Garrett ya dawo a matsayin wani ɓangare na Mae Young Classic
, an fitar da shi daga gasar a zagaye na farko da Piper Niven. Ta yi bayyanar a ranar 26 ga Oktoba, 2017 na "NXT", tana shiga cikin yakin basasa wanda Nikki Cross ya ci nasara don tantance ɗaya daga cikin masu fafatawa don gasar zakarun mata ta NXT a. A ranar 4 ga Yuli, 2018 na "NXT", Dakota Kai ta ci Garrett.