Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Bayan hutun watanni huɗu, The Undertaker ya dawo a SummerSlam a watan Agusta ta hanyar kai hari ga CM Punk, wanda ya lashe gasar cin kofin duniya daga Jeff Hardy a cikin Tables, Ladders, da Chairs. A Breaking Point, The Undertaker ya fuskanci Punk a cikin wasan biyayya. The Undertaker ya fara lashe wasan ne tare da "Hell's Gate" wanda ya gabatar, amma an sake farawa wasan ta SmackDown General Manager Theodore Long, wanda ya yanke hukuncin cewa haramcin da Vickie Guerrero ya sanya a kan motsi har yanzu yana aiki. Punk ya ci gaba da lashe wasan tare da anaconda vise lokacin da alkalin wasa Scott Armstrong ya kira ga kararrawa, duk da cewa Undertaker bai taba yin biyayya ba a cikin wani wasan kwaikwayo na Montreal Screwjob, wanda ya faru a cikin wannan wuri a
A shekara ta 1997. A ranar 25 ga watan Satumba na "SmackDown", Theodore Long a hukumance ya ɗage haramcin, bayan an sake shi daga akwatin gawa da Undertaker ya sanya shi a ciki. Rikici tsakanin su biyun ya ci gaba kuma a Hell in a Cell, The Undertaker ya lashe gasar cin kofin duniya mai nauyi daga Punk a Hell in a Cell. The Undertaker ya sami nasarar kare taken daga CM Punk a ranar 23 ga Oktoba a cikin shirin "SmackDown", a cikin mummunan wasa hudu a Bragging Rights da Punk, Batista da Rey Mysterio da kuma cikin wasan barazanar sau uku da Chris Jericho da Big Show a Survivor Series. Ya fuskanci Batista a cikin wasan kujerun don gasar zakarun Turai kuma ya ci nasara lokacin da Long ya sake fara wasan, bayan Batista ya ci nasara bayan ya yi amfani da rauni. A dare na gaba a kan "Raw", Undertaker ya yi gasa a cikin gasar don lashe kyautar Superstar na shekara ta 2009, ya rasa Randy Orton ta hanyar ƙidaya a zagaye na farko bayan ɓatar da hankalin da Orton ya samu daga Cody Rhodes da Ted DiBiase.