Rubuta ci gaba don wannan sakin layi - Nagy ya fara sana'arsa a AHL playoffs daga baya a wannan shekarar tare da Worcester Ice Cats. Nagy ya taka leda tare da Blues daga 1999 zuwa 2001, kuma an siyar da shi zuwa Coyotes tare da Michal Handzus, Jeff Taffe da kuma zagaye na farko a zagaye na 2002
a musayar Keith Tkachuk. A lokacin da yake tare da Coyotes, Nagy ya buga wasanni 3 a jere 20+ kakar wasa daga 2001 zuwa 2004, kuma ya zira kwallaye 50 daga 2002-03 zuwa 2005-06. Koyaya, burinsa da samar da maki zai ragu da sauri a ƙarshen kakar.