Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Bayan wani lokaci a kan kewaye mai zaman kanta da shekara guda bayan abin da ya faru a gidan wasan kwaikwayon, Finlay ya koma WWE a ranar 11 ga Yuli 2012 a matsayin mai samar da backstage. Bangarorin biyu sun kasance suna tattaunawa tun daga WrestleMania XXVIII, amma akwai yanayi da suka jinkirta kammala yarjejeniyar. A cikin shekaru masu zuwa, Finlay ya yi wasu bayyanuwa, yawanci ya raba 'yan wasan kokawa. Ya kuma kasance ɗaya daga cikin 'yan dambe huɗu waɗanda suka gabatar da Tyler Bate tare da WWE UK Championship bayan Bate ya lashe gasar da ta dace a watan Janairun 2017. Bayan da Lana ba ta iya yin gasa a
2019 mata Royal Rumble wasan biyo bayan harin da Nia Jax a lokacin da ta shiga, Finlay ya ba da ɗan'uwan Irish Becky Lynch izinin maye gurbin Lana; Lynch za ta ci gaba da cin nasarar wasan kuma daga baya ta yi taken WrestleMania 35, inda za ta lashe duka Raw Women's Championship da SmackDown Women's Championship a Winner Takes All wasan barazanar sau uku da Ronda Rousey da Charlotte Flair.