Ka taƙaita labarin:  Tun lokacin da aka bayyana cewa Andreas Lubitz <unk> mataimakin matukin jirgi wanda da gangan ya yi hatsarin jirgin saman Germanwings Flight 9525, wanda ya kashe mutane 150 <unk> an yi masa magani don rashin lafiyar kwakwalwa, an yi muhawara kan ko ya kamata dokokin tsare sirri game da bayanan likita su zama marasa tsauri idan ya zo ga sana'o'in da ke da alhakin musamman. An yi jayayya da yawa cewa dokokin tsare sirri na Jamus sune ke da alhakin bala'in. Alal misali, jaridar The Times ta buga wani talifi mai jigo: 'Girmanci da ke son zaman kansa ya ƙyale matukin jirgi mai kisa ya tashi.' Hakazalika, wani talifi da aka wallafa a cikin TIME ya ce: 'Dokar tsare sirri ta Jamus ta ƙyale matukin jirgi ya 'ɓoye' rashin lafiyarsa daga masu aikinsa.' Duk da yake Dirk Fischer, dan majalisa na Jamus kuma mai magana da yawun sufuri na kungiyar Christian Democratic Union (CDU), ya yi kira ga kamfanonin jiragen sama su sami damar yin amfani da bayanan likitancin matukan jirgin, Frank Ulrich Montgomery, shugaban kungiyar likitocin Jamus (BÄK), bai yarda ba. Mataimakin matukin jirgi Andreas Lubitz, wanda da gangan ya yi hatsarin jirgin saman Germanwings Flight 9525, ya kashe mutane 150, an yi masa magani ne saboda rashin lafiyar kwakwalwa, daga baya ya bayyana. Binciken ya haifar da muhawara kan ko ya kamata a bai wa kamfanonin jiragen sama damar samun damar yin amfani da bayanan likitancin matukan jirgin. Mista Montgomery ya yi imanin cewa dokokin da ake amfani da su yanzu sun dace, tun da likitocin jiragen sama sun riga sun sauke nauyin da suke da shi na sirri idan sun yi tunanin cewa matukin jirgi zai iya sa rayukan wasu mutane cikin hadari. Idan likitan Lubitz bai faɗakar da Germanwings ba, dole ne ya kasance saboda Lubitz bai yi kama da barazana ba. Akwai hujjoji guda biyu game da dalilin da ya sa likitan Lubitz ya yi abin da ya dace ta wajen rashin bayyana baƙin cikin Lubitz ga mai aikinsa. Na farko, dangantaka mai kyau tsakanin likita da mai jinya ta dangana ne ga amincewa da juna. Idan aka karya sirrin da ke tsakanin marasa lafiya da likitoci, marasa lafiya ba za su ƙara amincewa da likitocinsu ba. Kuma rashin amincewa zai sa (aƙalla wasu) marasa lafiya su ɓoye wasu alamun su ko kuma su guji neman likita gaba ɗaya saboda tsoron mummunan sakamako, kamar zargi da kuma hukunce-hukuncen da suka shafi aiki. Mafi hatsari fiye da matukin jirgi da ke da hauka...
Andreas Lubitz ya yi hatsarin jirgin saman Germanwings Flight 9525 a cikin tsaunukan Faransa, inda ya kashe kansa da sauran mutane 149 da ke cikin jirgin. Tun daga wannan lokacin ya bayyana cewa Lubitz ya sha magani saboda rashin lafiyar kwakwalwa. Labarai sun haifar da muhawara kan ko ya kamata kamfanonin jiragen sama su sami damar yin amfani da bayanan likitancin duk matukan jirgin, don gwadawa da hana irin wannan bala'in. Carissa Veliz ta kammala karatun falsafa ne daga Jami'ar Oxford kuma tana rubuta karatunta a kan batun tsare sirri.