Rubuta ci gaba ga wannan sakin layi - A ranar 5 ga Maris, 2003, Toronto ta yi musayar McCauley, Brad Boyes, da kuma zabin zagaye na farko na Toronto a 2003
zuwa San Jose Sharks, tare da ikon gaba Owen Nolan zuwa Toronto a musayar. Canjin yanayin kamar ya amfane McCauley. A cikin cikakken kakar wasa ta farko tare da Sharks a 2003-04, ya kafa mafi girman aiki a raga (20) da maki (47). An san McCauley ne saboda wasan sa na biyu da kuma karfin sa na kisa, wanda ya ba shi lambar yabo ta Selke Trophy a 2003-04 a matsayin mafi kyawun tsaron baya na gasar.