Kammala wannan jumla: Tobey ya yi alkawarin zuwa UVA a kan makarantu kamar Maryland, Pittsburgh, da Xavier. A lokacin da yake a Virginia, ya raba lokaci tsakanin kasancewa mai farawa da kasancewa ɗaya daga cikin masu maye gurbin farko daga benci. Wasansa daga benci ya sa ya sami lambar yabo ta ACC ta Mutum na shida a shekarar 2015. Tobey ya kasance a cikin 'yan wasan kwando na kasa da shekaru 19 na Amurka wanda ya lashe gasar
2013 FIBA Under-19 Gasar Duniya. Tobey ya ƙare aikinsa na koleji a matsayin jagorancin Virginia a duk lokacin da aka buga wasanni, ya bayyana a wasanni 138 a cikin shekaru hudu.