Kammala jumla mai zuwa: Bayan kakar 2013, Hinske ya koma Yankees, a wannan lokacin a matsayin mai kallo. Ya taimaka wajen shawo kan Brian McCann ya sanya hannu tare da Yankees. Bayan wata daya a matsayin dan wasan Yankees, Chicago Cubs ta dauki Hinske aiki don zama mai horar da su a ranar 3 ga Disamba, 2013. A ranar 9 ga Oktoba, 2014, ya ɗauki matsayin mataimakin kocin bugawa a cikin wannan ƙungiyar. A shekara ta 2016, Hinske ya lashe lambar yabo ta uku a gasar cin kofin duniya lokacin da Cubs suka doke Indians a gasar cin kofin duniya ta biyu.
Gasar cin kofin duniya ta 2016 a wasanni bakwai. Los Angeles Angels sun dauke shi aiki a ranar 23 ga Oktoba, 2017 don zama mai horar da su. Bayan kakar wasa daya, Jeremy Reed ya maye gurbinsa. An ɗauke shi aiki a matsayin mataimakin mai horar da buga wasa ta Arizona Diamondbacks a cikin 2019. A ranar 10 ga Yuni, 2021, an sauke Hinske daga matsayinsa tare da kulob din.