Tuhia he haere tonu mo tenei whitianga - I te tau 2016, i eke a Scheffler ki tana US Open tuatahi. I whakatuwherahia e ia te rauna tuatahi 69, engari ka pupuhi i te rauna tuarua 78 kia ngaro ai te tapahi ma te whiu kotahi. Ano i te tau 2017, i tohu a Scheffler mo te US Open
i muri i te oranga o te 4 ki te 3 o te whakataetae ki te whiwhi i tetahi waahi i te mara. Ko ia me Cameron Champ anake nga kaiwhaiwhai e rua i eke ki te US Open 2017. I mutu a Scheffler i te amateur iti i te 1-i raro i te-par, kotahi te whiu i mua o Champ.