Whakakihia te rerenga e whai ake nei: Kua whakahaeretia e Culbreth te Ropu Wahanga o te Ropu Amerika i te 2002, 2007, 2012, me te 2014; me te Ropu Wahanga o te Ropu Motu i te 2004 me te 2008. I whakahaeretia e ia te American League Championship Series i te tau 2000,
2009, 2010 me 2011; me te National League Championship Series i te 2003, 2006 me te 2019. I whakawakia a Culbreth i te Toa o te Ao i te tau 2008 me te 2012. Kua whakahaerehia e Culbreth i roto i nga keemu 87 o te waa i te waa 2019, ko ia te kaiwhakawa mo te 11 o aua whakataetae. He mema ano ia o te roopu mo te 2006 MLB All-Star Game i Pittsburgh. I hinga te Rōpū Amerika i te Rōpū Motu, 3 ki te 2.