Whakarāpopototia te tuhinga:  He wahine taitamariki i wero i te maripi kīhini e iwa inihi ki tētahi hoa kaihauhau i roto i te rārangi i runga i te waipiro, kua herea mō te 10 tau. I werohia e Samantha Houlgrave, 20, a Samuel Madden nā te mea i hiahia ia ki te inu i ngā inu kāore i tuwhera i kawea mai e ia ki te pōti i tōna kāinga. I whara i a ia ona whatukuhu me tana ate, a ka korerotia ki a ia mena he hawhe inihi te whara, ahakoa he aha, ka mate ia. I whai wāhi a Mr Madden ki tētahi pokanga nui hei whakarite kia kore e whara i a ia te kino o roto. I mauheretia a Samantha Houlgrave mō te 10 tau mō te wero i a Samuel Madden i runga i te haurangi. Ka tukuna mai te 20-tau-tawhito, i whakaahuatia i runga ake nei, mai i te whare herehere ka mahi ia i te wa e toru tau te roa o te raihana. I kii te Kaitiaki Kaitiaki a Rob Sledge kua mahue a Mr Madden me nga mate tinana me te hinengaro na te whakaeke, i puta i te kaainga o Houlgrave i Blackburn, Lancashire. Ka mea ia: 'Kua inu raua tokorua i te whare o Houlgrave.. He pōwhiri i te whare i hē. 'Kua whakatau a Mr Madden ki te haere, ā, i hiahia ia ki te kawe i ngā inu i utua e ia. I whakahe a Houlgrave. Ka mea a ia i tiki ia i te maripi i runga i te tarutaru i waho o te whare, a ka wareware ia i ia i roto i tona ringa. I kī a ia i haere ia ki te pana atu i a Mr Madden, ā, ko te wā i werohia ai ia e ia.' I hiahia a Mr Madden ki te pokanga hei whakatika i ngā 'kōkō' i roto i ana okana. I tāpiri atu a DC Sledge: 'Ka mau tonu i a ia ngā tohu o te ora katoa, ā, he maha ngā mahi pokanga nui i mahia ki a ia. 'Kua tino waimarie a Mr Madden nā te mea i kī te taote mēnā i neke te maripi i te hawhe inihi i ngā taha e rua o te wāhi i mahia ai, kua mate ia.' I whakawakia a Houlgrave e te huinga kaiwhakawa mo te whara kino ki te tinana i muri i te whakawakanga e rima-ra i te Kooti Karauna o Preston. I mauria a Houlgrave ki mua i te marae i muri i tana whiunga i muri i tana tahu hikareti i roto i nga ruma. I whiua ia ki te 10 tau o te herehere, tae atu ki etahi atu e toru i runga i te raihana whakawhānui. Heoi anō, i kawea anō te whakawātea ki mua i tētahi atu kaiwhakawa i muri i tana tahu hikareti i roto i tētahi ruma, nā reira i rangona ai ngā whakaoho ahi, ā, ka...
I whakawakia a Samantha Houlgrave mō te tūkino kino i te tinana e te huinga kaiwhakawa. I werohia e te 20 tau te pakeke a Samuel Madden i runga i te inu waipiro. I ora ia i te whakamomori engari i whara i ana whatukuhu me tana ate. I mauheretia a Houlgrave mō te 10 tau e tētahi kaiwhakawa i Preston Crown Court. I korerotia ano hoki e ia ka tu ia mo te toru tau i runga i te raihana ina tukuna ia.