Tuhia he tomokanga mō tēnei wāhanga - I muri i a Fort Donelson, i whakawhiwhia te 41st Illinois ki te 1st Brigade i roto i te Stephen A. Hurlbut's 4th Division of the Army of the Tennessee. I muri tata mai i te tīmatanga o te whawhai i te Pakanga o Hiroha
I te mutunga o te pakanga, i whara kinotia te rangatira o te 1st Brigade a Colonel Nelson G. Williams, a ka hurihia te rangatira o te brigade ki a Pugh. I arahi a Colonel Pugh i te parirau i roto i nga ra e rua o te whawhai i Shiloh i te taha o "Pond Blood".