Whakarāpopototia te tuhinga:  I werohia a Pennie Davis (i te pikitia) kia mate i roto i te ngana ki te 'whakamutu' i a ia mai i te haere ki te pirihimana me nga whakapae mo te whakaeke moepuku, kua rongo te kooti. I werohia he whaea-wahine ki te mate i roto i te mara i a ia e tiaki ana i ana hoiho na te mea i utua e te tama a tana hoa o mua kia 'ngenge' ia, i rongo te kooti i tenei ra. Ko Ben Carr, 22, he 'kino me te riri tonu' ki a Pennie Davis na te mea i whakapae ia ia mo nga mahi taatai tawhito, i kii. Ko Mrs Davis, 47, e mahi ana i tētahi hokomaha, i kitea mate e tana tāne i te 2 o Hepetema i tētahi mara i Leygreen Farm, i Beaulieu, Hampshire. Ko Justin Robertson, 36, kahore he wāhitau pūmau, e whakakahore ana i te kohuru me te whakatikatika ki te kohuru, i kitea e te pirihimana i muri i tana whakahekenga i tētahi huinga kī motokā i te wāhi kohuru, i korerotia ki te Kooti Karauna o Winchester. Ko Benjamin Carr, 22, o Edward Road, Southampton, ko Samantha Maclean, 28, o Beech Crescent, Hythe, e whakawakia ana hoki mo te whakatikatika i te kohuru, e whakakahoretia ana e raua. I kii a Richard Smith QC, te kaiwhakawhiwhi: 'I haere a Penelope Davis ki te tiaki i ana hoiho i te mara i tetahi pāmu tata ki Beaulieu i te pito o te Ngahere Hou. 'I a ia i reira, i a ia anake hoki i roto i tētahi pāmu iti i roto i te mara hoiho, i whakaekehia ia, ā, i werohia e te kaiwhakawā, e Justin Robertson. 'I kitea te tinana o Penelope i muri mai i taua ahiahi tonu e takoto ana i te mara e tana tahu, e Pita Davis, i haere mai i te mahi, i haere mai hoki ki te awhina i a ia ki nga hoiho. He marama noa iho i marenatia ai raua. I haere tonu ia: 'I whakaae te kaiwhakawā, a Justin Robertson, ki te patu i a Penelope Davis mō te moni. I whakaae ia ki te whakamate i a ia mo te kaiwhakapae a Ben Carr. Ko ia, ko Ben Carr, nāna i whakarite te mahere, nā Robertson rāua ko Carr i whakatinana taua mahere ki te whakamate i a Penelope Davis me te āwhina o to rāua hoa whakawātea a Samantha Maclean.' I kii a Mr Smith i hiahia a Carr kia 'ngenge' a Mrs Davis na te mea i whakapono ia ka whakapae ia ki te pirihimana kua whakaekea e ia tetahi tangata, he amuamu i tukuna e ia i mua. Ka mea ia: 'He aha a Ben Carr i hiahia ai kia whakamatea a Penelope Davis? Ko te whakautu ki tērā...
I kitea a Pennie Davis, 47, kua werohia ki te mate i roto i te mara i te New Forest. E kiia ana ko te tama a tana hoa o mua i utu £ 1,500 kia patua ia. I whakapae a Mrs Davis i a Ben Carr mo nga mahi taikaha o mua. I whakawhanakehia e te 22-tau-tau te 'kino pumau' ki a ia, e ai ki nga kaitohutohu. E kiia ana i utua e ia a Justin Robertson £ 1,500 kia 'ngenge' ai a Mrs Davis. Ka whakakahore rāua i te whakapae mo te kohuru, ā, ka whakakahore a Robertson i te whakapae kohuru.