Tuhia he haere tonu mo tenei whitianga - I te wa o te tau 1992, i noho a Timlin ki te Dunedin Blue Jays Kotahi-A (e ono nga keemu), te Triple-A Syracuse Chiefs (whitu nga keemu), me te riiki nui Blue Jays (26 nga keemu). Ki a Toronto i kohia e ia he rekoata 0<unk>2 me te whakaora kotahi me te 4.12 ERA. I te wa o muri, i puta ia i nga putanga awhina e rua i te ALCS
i te whakataetae Oakland Athletics, e rua hoki ngā tukinga āwhina i te whakataetae World Series ki te Atlanta Braves. I tuhia e ia tana whakaoranga tuatahi i te wa o te whakataetae i te kemu whakatau 6, i te aroaro o te kaitakaro kotahi, a Otis Nixon, i peia e Timlin i te turanga tuatahi i runga i te ngana ki te peke i te wahanga 11, mo te whakamutunga o te raupapa.