Whakarāpopototia te tuhinga:  I te Oketopa 2012, i whakaekehia a Elisa Lopez i a ia e moe ana i runga i te tereina o te tereina i New York City, a ko te kaupapa katoa i mau ki te ataata me te horapa i runga i te ipurangi. I te mutunga o te wiki kua hipa, neke atu i te rua tau i muri i te whakaekenga ohorere, i whakawāteatia a Ms Lopez i te wā i hopukina ai e te pirihimana tana kaitukino, i mōhiotia ko Carlos Chuva, 43-tau te pakeke. I mauheretia te kainoho o Kuini i te Rāpare kua hipa, ā, i whakawakia mō te hara nui tuatahi, he whakaeke i te taha o te tangata. Panuku ki raro mō te ataata. Te whakaeke kino: I te Oketopa 20, 2012, i te moe a Elisa Lopez (matau) i runga i te tereina o te taone nui 4 i te wa i noho ai tetahi tangata o waenga-tau ki tona taha, a ka maka tona ringa ki raro i tana koti (maui). I hopukina te katoa o te tūtukitanga ki te ataata. I heke atu te tangata ke i te tereina, ka ngaro i muri i te whiunga a Lopez i a ia ki te mata, ka rere. E ai ki tētahi amuamu hara i whakahuahia e Gothamist, i whakaae te whakapae ko ia te kaiwhawhai i te wā i whakaaturia ai e ngā pirihimana tētahi pikitia mata mai i te ataata metro rongonui. I tū te whakaeke kino i te 4 karaka i te ata i te 20 o Oketopa 2012, i runga i te tereina o te taone nui 4 e tata ana ki Lexington Avenue me te 42nd Street i Manhattan. Ko Elisa Lopez, he mema 21-tau te pakeke o te Air National Guard, i a ia e haere ana ki te taone nui ki te whakatau i tana hoa rangatira i muri i tana tae atu ki tetahi huihuinga i The Bronx i te wa i moe poto ai ia i runga i te tereina, ka mau tonu ki tana putea. Ka oho ake ia i muri iho, ka kite i tētahi tangata kē e kopikopiko ana i tōna huha me tōna mata, e ngana ana hoki ki te kihi i a ia. I werohia e te kaiwhaiwhai i te tangata kino i te mata, a, ka rere atu i roto i te rori o raro. Kāore ia i mōhio ki te nui o te tukino ā-waha i whakamanawanui ai ia, tae noa ki te wā i tukuna mai e tētahi hoa mahi ki a ia te riipene whakaata i tāia e tētahi hoa pāhihi i runga i te tereina 4. Justice for Elisa: neke atu i te rua tau i muri mai, i hopukina e te pirihimana a Carlos Chuvo, 43-tau te pakeke (maui), e whakapae ana ki a ia mo te tukino i a Elisa Lopez. Ko te whakaahua waea pūkoro i tuhia e te tangata o Brooklyn a Jasheem Smiley e whakaatu ana i tetahi tangata o waenganui-tau e kakahu ana i te koti denim me te tarau e maka ana i tona ringa i raro i te koti o te wahine moe me...
Ko Carlos Chuva, 43, no Queens, e whakawakia ana mō te hara nui o te reanga tuatahi o te whakaeke ā-ira. E whakapae ana a Chuva i te whakaeke i a Elisa Lopez i runga i te tereina o te taone nui 4 Oketopa 20, 2012. Ko te whakaekenga ki a Lopez i whakaatahia e te kaihihi tahi a Jasheem Smiley, kātahi ka tohaina ki te ipurangi. I whakawakia a Smiley mō tana kore āwhina i a Lopez engari i kī ia he āwangawanga ia mō tōna ake haumaru. Ko Lopez, he Air National Guardsman me te akonga o te whare wānanga, i korero mo te whakaeke i te marama o Tihema 2014.