['ardèche river', 'southern france', 'less quarter mile', 'three explorers set', 'days christmas', 'came along way', 'seeking drafts air emanating ground', 'would point presence caves', 'eventually sensed subtle airflow', 'began clearing away rocks', 'revealing narrow shaft cliff', 'narrow', 'person could barely squeeze', 'descended unknown', 'make one greatest discoveries', 'history human culture', 'first cave appear', 'contain anything special', 'aside particularly beautiful', 'deep inside found', 'would turn cave pristine', 'perfectly sealed tens thousands years', 'contained far oldest cave paintings', 'dating back years', 'fact oldest paintings ever discovered', 'twice old', 'honor leading discoverer jeanmarie chauvet', 'cave bears name chauvet cave', 'road ardèche gorge', 'leading cave', 'early spring', 'given unprecedented endorsement', 'french ministry culture', 'film inside cave', 'first day discovery', 'importance cave immediately recognized', 'access shut categorically', 'small group scientists allowed enter', 'archaeologists art historians', 'paleontologists geologists among others', 'perform studies together', 'short weeks end march', 'beginning april', 'one rare times', 'anyone exception two guards', 'allowed inside cave', 'cave like frozen flash moment time', 'reason pristine condition', 'rock face', 'years ago came tumbling', 'massive rock slide', 'sealing original entrance cave', 'creating perfect time capsule', 'wooden walkway leads entrance chauvet cave', 'narrow tunnel discoverers crawled', 'widened', 'locked massive steel door', 'like bank vault', 'pass door locked behind us', 'compromise delicate climate inside', 'first exploration cave', 'using tiny nonprofessional camera rig', 'first narrow holding room', 'fitted sterile boots', 'given safety instructions', 'okay', 'youve set rope', 'dont touch', 'jean clottes first scientist', 'inspect cave days discovery', 'five years retirement', 'served head scientific team', 'guide leads us first sloping tunnel', 'ends vertical drop cave floor', 'since film crew limited', 'maximum four', 'must perform technical tasks', 'addition time cave', 'severely restricted', 'take one light well', 'five past', 'one hour', 'apart time constrictions', 'allowed touch anything cave', 'ever step twofootwide walkway', 'use three flat cold light panels', 'powered battery belts', 'see made passageways', 'protected stalagmites', 'nice touch', 'inevitably moving along single file', 'film crew hiding places', 'get shot', 'first large chamber come', 'original entrance cave', 'prehistoric times rock slide', 'daylight must illuminated', 'left arrived inside cave', 'see entrance', 'archaeological entrance', 'people came cave level', 'like us ladder', 'cliff collapsed', 'weve got rubble cliff', 'outside see', 'inside', 'youve got dots', 'red dots', 'red dots saw first', 'came cave', 'big dots made palm hand', 'well big cave bear skull right', 'male probably', 'youll see many others', 'see big chamber really huge', 'biggest cave', 'paintings except right end', 'probably relevant', 'entrance still open', 'must light', 'put paintings really complete dark', 'see', 'cave bear painted black', 'paintings looked fresh', 'initial doubts authenticity', 'picture layer', 'calcite concretions', 'take thousands years grow', 'first proof forgery', 'beautiful horse', 'one beautiful cave', 'touching', 'looks done yesterday', 'look fresh looks technique', 'behind horse', 'two mammoths big mammoths', 'see cave bear scratches', 'cave bear scratches color', 'look like might made', 'years earlier', 'coming one great spots cave', 'famous panel horses', 'one size small recess', 'small hole', 'water comes gurgling', 'theres something like week rain', 'probably explains', 'animals painted around hole', 'one great works art world', 'paleolithic painters', 'play light shadows torches', 'could possibly looked something like', 'animals perhaps appeared moving living', 'note artists painted bison', 'eight legs suggesting movement', 'almost form protocinema', 'walls flat', 'threedimensional dynamic', 'movement utilized artists', 'upper left corner another multilegged animal', 'rhino right', 'seems also illusion movement', 'like frames animated film', 'painters cave seem speak us', 'familiar yet distant universe', 'seeing', 'part millions spatial points', 'today scientists mapped every single millimeter', 'cave using laser scanners', 'position every feature cave known', 'shape cave entirety', 'end end feet long', 'map basis', 'scientific projects done', 'working create new understanding cave', 'precision scientific methods', 'thats think main goal', 'main goal create stories', 'could happened cave past', 'like creating', 'phone directory manhattan', 'four million precise entries dream', 'cry night', 'hopes', 'families', 'youll well never know phone directory', 'definitely', 'never know past definitely lost', 'never reconstruct past', 'create representation', 'alre exists today', 'human', 'human', 'come cave', 'course things', 'background', 'background may ask', 'well used circus man', 'switched archaeology', 'circus', 'lion tamer', 'well mostly lion tamer', 'mostly unicycle juggling yeah', 'first time entered chauvet cave', 'chance get five days', 'powerful', 'every night dreaming lions', 'every day shock', 'emotional shock', 'mean im scientist human', 'five days decided go back cave', 'needed time relax take time', 'absorb', 'absorb yeah yeah', 'dreamt paintings lions', 'real lions', 'definitely', 'yeah', 'afraid dreams', 'afraid', 'afraid', 'feeling powerful things deep things', 'way understand things direct way', 'uh sorry', 'silence please', 'please dont move', 'going listen silence cave', 'perhaps even hear heartbeats', 'images memories', 'longforgotten dreams', 'heartbeat', 'ever able understand vision', 'artists across abyss time', 'aura melodrame landscape', 'could straight wagner opera', 'painting german romanticists', 'could connection', 'staging landscape operatic event', 'belong romanticists alone', 'stone age men might similar sense', 'inner landscapes seems natural', 'theres whole cluster paleolithic caves', 'right around', 'chauvet cave top cliff', 'chauvet cave also associated', 'natural feature', 'beautiful arch called pont darc', 'maybe pont darc mythology people', 'landmark mark also', 'imagination stories', 'mythology', 'important understand world', 'kind world', 'paleolithic people back', 'years ago europe', 'europe covered glaciers glacial europe', 'imagine climate dry cold sun also', 'important', 'place example', 'imagine woolly rhinos', 'mammoths along rivers', 'forest', 'megaloceros deers horses reindeers bisons', 'also ibex antelopes moving', 'rich', 'biomass part europe', 'important', 'development human also carnivores', 'imagine lions bears leopards', 'wolves foxes large numbers', 'among carnivores predators human', 'could set fires chauvet cave', 'theres evidence cast shadows', 'panels horses example', 'fire necessary look paintings', 'maybe towards staging people around', 'look flame moving light', 'imagine people dancing shadows', 'like fred astaire', 'fred astaire yes', 'think image dancing shadow', 'strong old images human representation', 'first representation walls', 'white wall black shadow', 'presence humans cave', 'fleeting like shadows', 'bear skulls everywhere', 'skulls belong cave bear', 'species like mammoth woolly rhino', 'vanished face earth long ago', 'tens thousands years patient water dripping', 'left thick coating calcite skull', 'appearance porcelain sculpture', 'menagerie bones', 'theres single human specimen', 'scientists determined humans never lived cave', 'used painting possibly ceremonies', 'michel philipe studied bones chauvet cave', 'caves constitute favorable place', 'preservation bones', 'result lot bear bones', 'overall represents finds', 'also wolves', 'two skulls several bones', 'ibexes', 'magnificent skull wet sand calcite', 'quite lovely', 'shine light', 'calcite crystals glisten', 'truly quite lovely', 'horses well', 'cave hyena', 'else', 'theres also eagle skeleton', 'golden eagle practically whole', 'may little recent', 'carried run water', 'wedged big rocks edge waterway', 'see bones spread', 'ten feet length', 'goal say bones', 'also try understand lived', 'moved transported', 'bears bring bones', 'several bones chewed little', 'could bears hyenas', 'scientists lodged', 'nearby sports complex', 'although special field', 'compare combine findings', 'interested work two', 'carole gilles explain youre', 'yeah oui', 'cave', 'trying reveal contours', 'underlying designs', 'hard follow naked eye', 'supposed touch wall', 'take series photos put together mosaic', 'trying achieve maximum detail', 'take transparency', 'put top photo', 'trace underlayers engravings', 'later return cave check contours', 'designs see', 'markings bears well', 'understand figure event', 'bear scratches', 'magnificent drawing mammoth done finger', 'scratches done mammoth', 'succession important', 'understand took place', 'computer one see three phases', 'first dates years back time', 'one bear scratched walls', 'second phase drawings', 'stretching eight feet height', 'therefore made stick followed main phase', 'sometime around years less', 'starts scraping wall', 'get white rock', 'first figures put place', 'two rhinos attacking one another', 'bottom', 'came three bulls', 'finally ended', 'series horses going top bottom', 'final phase adding beautiful horse', 'confronts viewers arrive cave', 'synthesis composition', 'kind dynamic circular movement', 'going bottom right', 'towards center like circle', 'obviously creates strong dynamic', 'reinforced', 'oblique movement horses', 'force contrast', 'fact theyve played contrast', 'shape wall', 'like easel', 'theyve used surface made use material', 'mixed material create strong impression', 'comparing paintings cave', 'seems certain horses panel', 'created one single individual', 'immediate vicinity horses', 'figures animals overlapping', 'striking point', 'cases like carbon dating', 'strong indications', 'overlapping figures drawn', 'almost years apart', 'sequence duration time', 'unimaginable us today', 'locked history', 'despite blurring time', 'anonymity artists', 'theres one individual singled', 'dominique baffier scholar paleolithic culture', 'right examines cluster palm prints', 'colleague valérie feruglio', 'currently working', 'large panel', 'covered positive handprints', 'weve able put forward evidence', 'number positions individual assumed', 'movements', 'started crouching stretched', 'reach way highest palm prints', 'panel comprised prints single man', 'must measured roughly six feet tall', 'single human', 'meter tall thats big', 'one person', 'une personne une personne', 'one person person measuring six feet', 'youll notice prints', 'significant detail', 'slightly crooked little finger', 'thats extraordinary', 'gives physical reality', 'prehistoric individual years ago', 'came cave us', 'even surprising', 'youll find traces deeper cavern', 'well able recognize crooked little finger', 'printed hand farther cave', 'follow mans path', 'madame baffier took us tour', 'serves custodian cave', 'rules engagement strict', 'entirely reasonable', 'given precious fragile nature', 'unique place', 'cave bear tracks', 'forepaws hind paws', 'longest cave bear tracks', 'currently known cave', 'sparkly', 'crystals glitter', 'junction panel panther', 'see drawing panther', 'one known paleolithic wall painting', 'date', 'weve arrived place', 'concretion growth important', 'ground walls see', 'rimstone calcite ridges covered everything', 'sparkling formation kind cascade', 'waves', 'take look bear vertebra', 'entirely coated calcite', 'held calcite crystals', 'front us wall', 'also overflowing draperylike concretion', 'kind niche', 'see traces ancient red paintings', 'washed away water seepage', 'find extremely original images', 'like insectshaped one', 'one shaped like butterfly', 'bird flight', 'also find rock pendant', 'hanging ceiling large small', 'coupled two vertical ocher stripes', 'follow pendants contours', 'front', 'large panel red paintings', 'also extremely intriguing item', 'mound stones', 'see didnt fall ceiling', 'prehistoric man grouped stones', 'know', 'panel first', 'little rhinoceros large horn', 'stripe abdomen', 'also whole series underneath', 'positive handprints', 'see hand', 'man printed palms', 'first room cave', 'recognize crooked little finger', 'words weve followed', 'animals', 'front part big rhinoceros', 'large horn', 'torch swipe marks', 'men would light way torch', 'wood burnt', 'would scrape torch wall', 'rekindle flame', 'traces fresh see', 'small fragments coal fallen', 'one tiny fragments', 'tested radiocarbon dating', 'torch swiped years ago', 'painting quite interesting', 'represents couple nowextinct cave lions', 'male', 'hes behind larger one', 'hes outlined single stroke', 'six feet length', 'front female', 'smaller seems rub flank male', 'representation cave lion', 'allowed us shed light mystery', 'archaeozoologists didnt know', 'whether cave lion mane', 'like lion today living africa', 'representation cave lion', 'years old', 'shows us didnt mane', 'look outline head clearly delineated', 'without doubt male', 'weve got scrotum right tail', 'one beautiful panels cave', 'along lion panel far end', 'see', 'technique prehistoric man', 'also see keen knowledge', 'animal world', 'tell us stories', 'ensemble horses', 'open mouths suggest animals whinnying', 'say images', 'become audible us', 'see two rhinos fighting', 'see signs fury towards', 'movement legs thrown forward', 'almost hear sound', 'horns colliding', 'movement fight', 'another story story lions', 'male courting female ready mating', 'sits growls', 'look hear female growling', 'shes raising lips', 'shes baring teeth', 'happy', 'finish', 'flight bison', 'hear hooves', 'make multiple legs indicating movement', 'escaping alcove', 'following auroch', 'madame baffier takes us', 'farthest chamber cave', 'mysterious chamber lions', 'serious level toxic co gas', 'emanating roots trees', 'seeps cave porous limestone', 'time even constricted location', 'possibility get close paintings', 'unfortunately', 'things wont able show film', 'wont able see', 'cant get closer', 'case absolutely marvelous paintings', 'farthest chamber grouping lions', 'especially case rock pendant', 'lower portion womans body', 'painted', 'pubic triangle', 'legs separate starting knee', 'diverge reminiscent', 'wellknown small early stone age statuettes', 'archaeological digs swabian jura germany', 'see part lower half female body', 'access side pendant', 'walk grounds', 'fragile', 'would destroy charcoal remains', 'would destroy tracks', 'left bears humans', 'youll make partial image', 'completed half female body', 'legs symmetrically', 'could see connected bison head', 'would somewhat human arm', 'years later', 'myth endured days', 'also find association', 'female bull', 'picassos drawings minotaur woman', 'partial representation', 'human entire cave', 'time', 'side rock pendant', 'must remain unreachable us', 'people created equally enigmatic', 'things left behind', 'practical items like flint tools', 'easily read', 'boxes', 'local museum filled', 'artifacts region', 'made excavation site', 'jeanmichel geneste lead us', 'handful findings chauvet cave', 'things preserved', 'two three boxes area', 'prepared', 'shed light enigmatic female image', 'prepared similar figurines regions', 'precious archaeology', 'see like willendorf venus', 'copy made limestone found austria', 'period', 'chauvet cave', 'lower part belly preserved', 'embedded bison', 'seems existed', 'visual convention', 'extending way beyond baywatch', 'male representation clearly found', 'lion man', 'comes site', 'hohlensteinstadel swabian alps', 'amazing mixture', 'anthropomorphic shape', 'human body head lion', 'spirit lion man', 'marriage', 'new', 'thats question ask reproduction', 'people lived valley', 'left behind great art', 'primitive beginning', 'slow evolution', 'rather burst onto scene like sudden explosive event', 'modern human soul awakened', 'even astonishing consider time', 'neanderthal man still roamed valley', 'must forms artistic expression', 'like music example', 'look around nearby regions', 'southwestern germany years ago', 'connected valley icefree corridor', 'also noted alp mountains covered', 'feet ice binding much water', 'sea level feet lower today', 'hunter could walked paris london', 'crossing dry seabed english channel', 'walking miles direction', 'would lead swabian alb germany', 'museum blaubeuren', 'find replicas bestknown paleolithic venuses', 'one venus hohle fels stands', 'found sensational age', 'venus hohle fels probably oldest depiction', 'kind figurative object know', 'earliest representation human', 'absolute root figurative depiction', 'know', 'later see range animals depicted', 'think animal depictions ivory', 'fabulous depictions grotte chauvet', 'mammoths lions', 'see clear connection', 'swabian finds depictions chauvet', 'whats also fascinating time', 'years ago', 'see evidence musical instruments', 'range personal ornaments', 'mythical depictions clearly show', 'people religious concept', 'evolving transformation humans animals', 'original statuette', 'carved mammoth tusk', 'look venus hohle fels bit closely', 'see clearly instance', 'figurine head right', 'instead head figurine ring', 'perhaps worn times', 'suspended string sort', 'also sexual attributes key', 'clearly link depiction', 'ideas reproduction fecundity sexuality', 'ideas absolutely essential', 'humanity also today', 'also important realize time', 'much europe occupied neanderthals', 'dealing critical phase', 'human evolution', 'two forms human beings testing boundaries', 'find', 'neanderthals', 'although theyre sophisticated', 'never kind symbolic artifact ever', 'small ivory mammoth', 'also found near hohle fels cave', 'beautiful horse comes region', 'also found fragments flutes', 'asked dr conard show us original', 'ivory flute really remarkable artifact', 'maria malina discovered years back', 'think whats extremely important', 'realize archeology today', 'heroic adventure spades picks', 'hightech scientific work', 'thats done incredible detail', 'really millimeter millimeter sediments removed', 'deposits age grotte chauvet', 'sites', 'years ago', 'detailed work allowed maria', 'identify whole range finds', 'able piece together', 'maybe explain worked', 'yes inventory', 'artifact pieces', 'pieces came', 'first years excavation', 'really small pieces', 'see picture', 'tiny ivory pieces', 'remained unexplained full three decades', 'pieces significant look', 'found pieces part finger holes', 'notches side', 'pieces thought already', 'could part ivory flute', 'course question important', 'flute made', 'see long axis', 'split going flute', 'inside two halves hollowed flute', 'little notches along axis along split', 'helped refit two halves together precise', 'flute one eight', 'far recovered area southwestern germany', 'caves paintings', 'yield many objects art', 'cave geissenkloesterle cave', 'many important findings ice age made', 'found little ivory statues bear mammoth', 'tiny mammoth lovely', 'part excavation team', 'people lived years back time', 'time cold', 'alp mountains covered glacier', 'meters thick', 'valley', 'reindeer mammoth passing', 'cold', 'thats reason im dressed like inuit', 'presume way', 'people ice age clothed', 'reindeer fur boots made reindeer fur', 'reindeer leather', 'otherwise couldnt stand cold', 'one important finds made cave', 'tiny flute made radius vulture', 'astonishing flute', 'pentatonic', 'tonality used hear today', 'like ill try play small tunes', 'first reconstructed instrument', 'tried play tunes came across ones', 'sounds little bit like starspangled banner', 'back france near chauvet cave', 'explorers using primal techniques', 'search stillhidden underground chambers', 'roam landscape', 'professional cave explorers', 'techniques finding underground chambers', 'air currents', 'use back hands cheeks', 'feel faint draft air', 'may coming cave', 'im trying things differently', 'habit using sense smell profession', 'try sniff smells', 'coming interior cave', 'didnt smell anything except exterior landscape', 'outside smell earth wild thyme ivy', 'smell range things', 'nothing specific related cavern', 'thats closed thousands years', 'personal technique design perfumes', 'matter trying experience', 'different manner', 'ive ive always created perfumes', 'notably president', 'french society perfumers', 'years', 'plans', 'build theme park tourists', 'precise replica cave', 'miles', 'replica may even contain recreation', 'odor prehistoric interior', 'evidently odor smell right', 'quite attenuated', 'subtle', 'many emanations imagination permits us', 'try reconstruct scene', 'scene odors years ago', 'animals would found', 'bears wolves perhaps even rhinoceroses man', 'presence lives meaning burnt wood resins', 'odors everything natural world', 'surrounds cave', 'go back imagination', 'herzog sense wonder', 'cave transforms', 'enchanted world imaginary', 'time space lose meaning', 'crystal formations take thousands years grow', 'artists cave never even saw', 'many started form', 'landslide sealed entrance', 'forbidden recess cave', 'theres footprint eightyearold boy', 'next footprint wolf', 'hungry wolf stalk boy', 'walk together friends', 'tracks made thousands years apart', 'well never know', 'dwarfed large chambers', 'illuminated wandering lights', 'sometimes overcome strange irrational sensation', 'disturbing paleolithic people', 'work', 'felt like eyes upon us', 'sensation occurred scientists', 'also discoverers cave', 'relief surface aboveground', 'back outside ask jeanmichel geneste', 'hunting techniques paleolithic people', 'millennia invention bow arrow', 'ohauvet oave aurignacian people', 'hunted lot really big games', 'hunted everywhere france europe', 'settlement found lot bones', 'reindeer bison horses sometime mammoths', 'developed specific hunting technology', 'example system aurignacian bone point', 'ingenious', 'bone point wooden shaft', 'piece bone point', 'strongly associated shaft', 'system using fork piece inside', 'strong', 'made developed', 'kill bison horses like', 'aggressive', 'also strong powerful', 'kind weapon spear thrown', 'hand like efficient', 'l suspect', 'beginning paleolithic', 'developed technology spear thrower', 'spear thrower beginning hook', 'sometime tooth piece antler', 'like one long handle', 'elongated arm gave lot power like', 'also time precision keep', 'give spear good direction', 'show', 'yes', 'see spear flint point', 'use necessary', 'small depression back spear', 'suspect sometimes used feathers', 'keep direction moment throw', 'try show kill horse', 'okay', 'efforts may look convincing', 'powerful weapon', 'spearheads found deeply embedded', 'shoulder blades horses mammoths', 'see fly', 'straight meters', 'stay', 'paleolithic man better guess', 'oh suspect', 'could really difficult', 'shot kill horse really', 'midapril', 'scientific research ended year', 'allowed full access cave', 'even restricted', 'single week four hours day', 'famous cave lascaux shut', 'breath scores tourists', 'caused mold grow walls', 'enter chauvet cave', 'aware may last opportunity', 'film inside', 'mystery minotaur female began unfold', 'guides allowed us mount small camera', 'stick reached', 'bison seems embrace sex naked woman', 'traditional people think', 'people paleolithic probably', 'two concepts change vision world', 'theyre concept fluidity concept permeability', 'fluidity means categories', 'man woman horse dont know tree et cetera', 'shift', 'tree may speak', 'man get transformed animal', 'way around given certain circumstances', 'concept permeability barriers', 'speak world', 'world spirits', 'wall talk us', 'wall accept us refuse us', 'shaman example send spirit', 'world supernatural', 'receive visit inside', 'supernatural spirits', 'put two concepts together', 'realize different life must', 'people way live', 'humans described many ways right', 'homo sapiens', 'still called homo sapiens', 'man knows', 'dont think good definition', 'dont know', 'dont know much', 'would think homo spiritualis', 'strongest hint something spiritual', 'religious ceremony cave', 'bear skull', 'placed dead center rock resembling altar', 'staging seems deliberate', 'skull faces entrance cave', 'around fragments charcoal found', 'potentially used incense', 'exactly took place', 'paintings could tell us', 'want understanding', 'must go outside cave', 'mean must start cave go outside', 'far outside', 'would go', 'well would say everywhere', 'look different culture', 'would good way better understand', 'different culture could coped rock art', 'example australia north america', 'south africa', 'aborigines australia', 'lived recently almost like stone age people', 'sure example used paint', 'create rock art', 'places think still', 'traditions creating rock art', 'well course changed', 'since beginning century', 'discovered', 'tell us different ways', 'looking rock art', 'way looking rock art', 'example', 'yeah sure course', 'north australia example', 'ethnographer field aborigine', 'informer', 'arrived rock shelter', 'rock shelter', 'beautiful paintings', 'decaying', 'aborigine started become sad', 'saw paintings decaying', 'region tradition', 'touching paintings time time', 'sat started touch paintings', 'ethnographer asked question', 'every western person would asked', 'painting', 'man answered', 'answer troubling', 'answered', 'painting', 'thats hand hand', 'spirit actually painting', 'hand spirit', 'yeah man part spirit', 'think paintings chauvet cave', 'somehow beginning modern human soul', 'constitutes humanness', 'humanness good adaptation', 'world', 'soc human society', 'needs adaptate landscape', 'beings animals', 'human groups', 'communicate something communicate', 'inscribe memory', 'specific hard things', 'like walls like pieces wood like bones', 'invention cromagnon', 'music', 'yes also things mythology music', 'invention figuration', 'figuration animals men things', 'way communication humans', 'future', 'evocate past transmit information', 'better language', 'oral communication', 'invention still world today', 'camera example', 'rhone river', 'one largest nuclear power plants france', 'chauvet cave located miles crow flies', 'beyond hills background', 'surplus warm water', 'used cool reactors', 'diverted half mile away create tropical biosphere', 'warm steam fills enormous greenhouses', 'site expanding', 'crocodiles introduced brooding jungle', 'warmed water cool reactor', 'man thrive', 'already hundreds', 'surprisingly', 'mutant albinos swim breed waters', 'thought born surreal environment', 'long ago ten thousands years back', 'glaciers feet thick', 'new climate steaming spreading', 'fairly soon albinos might reach chauvet cave', 'looking paintings make', 'nothing real', 'nothing certain', 'hard decide whether', 'creatures dividing', 'doppelgaengers', 'really meet', 'imaginary mirror reflection', 'today possibly crocodiles', 'look back abyss time', 'see paintings chauvet cave']