Okay Joss, I want to start with an experiment
where we swap TikTok login information
to see just how different our feeds actually
are.
I don't know what it's going to reveal about me.
I do wonder how different it's going to be.
Nurse turns into a hot lady.
OK so I just got literally the male version
of that on yours. Look.
Oh my god.
Male nurse. Female nurse.
Joss there are so many animals on yours.
List of underrated horror movies.
I would never get that.
I've never seen this pushup challenge.
Yeah, I think TikTok recognized that I would
prefer a funny version of this.
It recognized that I share a sense of humor
with this person in Indonesia.
TikTok's frictionless personalization is what
made the app an instant success around the world.
But now that global success is crashing
into international politics, putting TikTok
in the middle of a worldwide battle over how
open the internet should be.
"President Trump threatening to ban TikTok in the United States as Microsoft is hoping to acquire it."
WEI: I think Chinese tech companies traditionally
have really struggled to get a cultural foothold
in the U.S. because the culture is just so
different.
That's Eugene Wei, a Tech Product Executive
who has written about how Tiktok, which is
owned by a company called ByteDance, became
the first globally-successful Chinese app.
How they did it all comes down to design.
When you first open up TikTok, you don't have to follow anyone,
or tell the app about your
interests, or even choose what to watch.
It shows you a video, and the only decision
you have to make is how long you watch it.
WEI: So if you look at the history of social
media, most of the giants in social networking today
started by having people essentially
build up a social graph from the bottoms up.
A social graph is the web of accounts you
follow and it determines most of the content
you see on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and
Snapchat.
The problem with that approach is that it
can feel like work: building up a social network
takes time, you're not necessarily going to
like every post from the accounts you follow,
and it's hard to find accounts that you would
like but don't know about.
TikTok took a different approach. It bypasses
the social graph, and instead builds an "interest graph,"
by watching you interact with videos.
TikTok isn't the first platform to do that--
it's basically how YouTube works too -- but
because TikTok videos are less than 60 seconds
long, you watch more of them, which means
more data.
WEI: People talk about the TikTok algorithm
as if it's some magic piece of software that
is just miraculously better than every piece
of software out there. But the truth is that
it's not necessarily that the algorithms themselves
have gotten that much better. But if you massively,
massively increase the training data set that
you train the algorithm on, you can achieve
really amazing results. And that's why I think
a lot of people will describe the algorithm
as eerily accurate. Eerily personalized.
TikTok's interest graph introduces you to
like-minded people. And because the videos
are often music or meme-based rather than
language-based, you may find that some of
those like-minded people live on the other
side of the world.
They might be a dancer in Nepal, a family
in Mexico, or kids in the U.K,
or this guy, as long as the algorithm predicts
that it'll entertain you.
WEI: And so in that way, the TikTok algorithm
kind of allows ByteDance to gain traction
in markets all over the world, with languages
that they don't understand, subcultures they
don't understand.
TikTok's global appeal enabled it to reach
a billion users faster than the other social
media giants had. But it also set the app
on a collision course with a different trend:
the rise of internet nationalism.
"India is banning TikTok and dozens of other
Chinese apps." "Australia has cited concerns
about national security. So too has South
Korea." "President Trump issued executive
orders that would ban TikTok and messaging
app WeChat from operating in the US in 45
days."
Bytedance is based in China, which means it's
subject to surveillance by a regime known
for censorship, human rights abuses, and cyber
espionage.
But TikTok says they have never provided any
US user data to the Chinese government.
For his part, President Trump has hinted that
this is actually about getting revenge for
the coronavirus.
VAN SUSTEREN: Why would you ban it?
TRUMP: Well, it's a big business. China -- look
what happened with China with this virus,
what they've done to this country and to the
entire world is disgraceful.
But whatever the motivation, the US targeting
a globally popular app is a big deal -- because
it throws a wrench into one of the biggest
debates over what the internet should be.
A New America Foundation report plots that
debate along a spectrum-- of how open the
internet is within a country.
SHERMAN: So on the one pole, we can visualize
the free and open model, so that's the democratic
model, very little state involvement in Internet
content.
As the original home of the internet and many
of the world's biggest tech companies, the
US has traditionally advocated for the free
flow of information online.
SHERMAN: The opposite end of the spectrum
is what we see in countries like China, where
there is heavy state involvement in content,
where they do go to Internet companies and
say, you have to censor all of these keywords,
you have to censor all these foreign websites.
China's Great Firewall famously blocks sites
like Google, YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, Wikipedia,
Netflix, WhatsApp, and many western news outlets.
But it's not just China anymore.
SHERMAN: What we see in the middle are countries
who I think are going to play a pivotal role
going forward in this global scale tipping
we see.
According to analysts surveyed for this report,
many of these countries shifted toward less
openness between 2014 and 2018.
In 2019 Russia moved to build an internet
that is isolated from the rest of the world,
following years of increasing government censorship.
Turkey has been blocking some news websites
and recently passed a law giving the government
sweeping powers over social media.
And India, the world's largest democracy,
leads the world in deliberate Internet shutdowns.
"Turning off the internet is becoming a defining
tool of government repression." "Internet
access shut down" "Imposed an internet blackout"
"Ethiopia" "Liberia" "Venezuela" "Pakistan"
"taken offline."
As governments decide that a world wide web
doesn't suit their interests, we end up with
a fractured internet, what some call "the
splinternet" where national borders increasingly
dictate what information people can access
online.
Now it's up to democratic countries to reimagine
an open internet worth fighting for. Instead,
the US is threatening to ban a platform used
by millions of Americans.
SHERMAN: The US benefits from having technological
leadership, it benefits from promoting a democratic
Internet model and contesting authoritarianism.
And so abdicating leadership on that front
is not good in the own interests of the US either.
TikTok created a uniquely international platform.
But it emerged onto an internet that wasn't
quite ready for it. It arrived in the midst
of rising nationalism, from a country that
has never respected internet freedom.
So now it's forcing the issue: When authoritarian
states assert control over online speech,
should the US respond by doing the same thing?
