 
(Background)On roll. 3rd point. Action. Clap. (Claps himself!)
Nobel prize winning Economist, Prof. Dr. Amartya Sen wrote a book a while ago.
"The Argumentative Indian"
In this book he said Indians love to argue
and Government of India also understands this
And that is why every day a new issue comes up in India.
But it becomes a concern when the issues discussed
are discussed just for the sake of it
 
There is a new issue now in the country
Whether NRC should be implemented or not?
NPR should be implemented or not?
What are NPR and NRC? Why was CAA implemented?
My Question is
That CAB became CAA;
but, what did the country gain?
Waah! What poetry? *LOL*
What needs to be understood is the link
between CAA, NRC and NPR
The Home Minister of our Country is busy explaining the chronology.
Actually, he is just distracting us.
You understand the chronology.
First CAB will come,
After CAB, NRC will be implemented.
the idea of NRC is linked with CAB
I want to EMPHASISE this!
First, Citizenship Amendment Bill will pass *Reporter repeats the same*
Yes, then NRC will come
Now, let's dissect each of these with calmness
and better understanding of the same
First, we'll understand how
CAB became CAA
CAB stands for Citizenship Amendment Bill
When some bill is proposed in the parlimanent
Till it gets passed by the parlimanent
And then signed by the President of India,
It can't become an Act. Hence, CAB got passed after going through
the parliament and then through the President Of India,
It became CAA
Citizenship Amendment Act
This CAB means
Anyone in India
Who is
An Hindu, Sikh, Jain, Buddhist,
Christain
Any Hindu immigrant who has come here
will be getting
Citizenship of India
Forever!
The crux of the bill is
That certain immigrant coming from outside
are our own for whom the doors are open
But for some, we are telling them to go out
And who are those? The Muslims.
So, what are you saying?!
That any Muslim coming from anywhere should get citizenship?!
I wanna EMPHASISE again! Hindu, Sikh,
Buddhists, Jain and Christain immigrants
 
will be getting Citizenship under any circumstances
 
Now, how is CAA an irrelevant issue?
Our Constitution already states that
If any person comes to India and requests for refuge,
He/she will be provided the same
And if he/she promises faith to the law of India,
faith the the Constitution of India,
and wants to become a Citizen of India
Then, they will be provided Citizenship also
Then, why was CAA implemented?
The reason for passing CAA was so that NRC can be implemented
all over the Country. We are very clear on this
NRC will be implemented in India
By when will it be implemented? What's the roadmap for NRC?
Before every election you promise for it, everytime
you promise for it
Tentatively and definitely, before 2024.
NRC IS GONNA COME!
IT'S A LIE! A LIE! A LIE! *deadpan*
Since I came to power *fuming*
Since 2014, till now
I wanna tell 130 Crore Indians,
 
Nowhere have
the words NRC
been discussed. No talk on it.  *dafaq*
While the real issue is that
they want to implement NRC all over the Country.
It should be done.
The name itself is NATIONAL Registration of Citizens.
So, what is NRC?
NRC stands for National Register of Citizens
Is a test for proving your Citizenship
which was implemented first in Assam. Under this,
every citizen of Assam had to provide documents
for each and every generation of their family.
To prove that they are citizens of India
 
But, when NRC was implemented in Assam
the results of it were so, that they had to
bring CAA.
So, what happened in Assam?
Supreme Court ordered the list of NRC to be finalised.
When the list was made public
19 Lakh people did not meet the criteria of NRC.
BJP had predicted that out of these 19 Lakh,
15-16 Lakh would be Muslims
First you told 1.9 crore illegal immigrants are there,
Then, it became 42 lakhs, ultimately, it was 19 lakh.
Out of those, 13 lakh were Hindus. That means 68% are hindus.
 
Now, you are just using CAA to protect those Hindus.
 
So,  the final NRC list had
out of the 19 lakh in the list 15 lakh were NON-MUSLIMS
So, there was pressure on BJP,
to retain their vote bank.
To appease their vote bank, the same people they used to spread propaganda to,
eventually BJP fell in their own trap.
 
Indian Government will first pass CAB
Followed by NRC.
Once CAB is implemented, the Hindus, Sikhs, Christains,
Buddists, Jains of Assam will
be provided
Citizenship of India.
The type of vote bank politics BJP has reduced itself to
is the worst. In Assam, the target is
the retainment of the Bengali Hindu vote bank.
In case they turn against us, we'll lose.
In West Bengal, we have to win the 2021 elections.
 
And there is only one way to win, by creating communal tension between Hindus and Muslims
 
It will benefit us.
And by 2024,
if we do something by which
Around 1-2 Crore Muslims can't vote,
That will clear our route
to win the elections.
And by the time this could reach the masses,
PM stated one thing which contradicts the Home Minister's statement,
to create an issue, akin to whether the chicken came first or the egg.
The real question is,
whether it's chicken or the egg, you need Onions to prepare the dish.
 
And the state of onion is, it is selling at Rs 200 per KG.
And, so that this issue is not discussed,
the reason behind why it is being
sold to the public sector is not discussed,
They are distracting you
So you keep discussing whether Superman is Clark Kent or not?
Superman or Clark Kent? Superman or Clark Kent?
Is NPR the same as NRC?
NRC or NPR?
NPR is register of Citizens.
NPR is registration of Population, a list of population.
 
NRC is registration of Citizens. A proof of their citizenship
is asked on the basis of documents
to prove how they can be called
citizens of India.
These two (NRC and NPR) have no relation,
they have no link.
Nor can their surveys be used for each other.
Now, I wanna clear for you,
that NPR is the egg from which,
NRC's omelette will be prepared.
It has been clearly stated,
in the Citizenship Amendment Act, 2003,
that first NPR will be implemented, understand the chronology ,
First NPR will take effect,
for it to work, government officials will come to your house
ask you questions regarding the same,
Take note of your answers, and then in the comfort of their
offices, create a list of doubtful citizens.
And those that make that list,
they will be ordered by the Government,
to provide the directed documents
that will prove their citizenship
So, first NPR
then the list of "doubtful citizens"
and then a country-wide NRC.
The process of NPR , can never be linked
and used for NRC. They are seperate.
I am EMPHASISING again, they are seperate laws.
The two cannot be linked. The survey of NPR cannot be used for NRC.
Not related to NRC.
IT'S A LIE! A LIE! A LIE! *dafaq*
 
NPR was mentioned in Citizenship Act, 1955, to which
amendments were made in 2003, under Vajyapayee Government (BJP)
that to identify and register citizens of India,
an NRC can be formed
If such a register is made,
the laws and provisions of it,
the laws and provisions of it,
 
will be based on NPR.
How will they create the register in NPR?
It will be separate from the Census of India, which is
done every 10 years
A separate setup will be created.
All state governments will be directed to release instructions on NPR
will have to instruct and teach the government officials about it.
And a list of questions will be formed,
the list will then
be asked at every home
by the officials and the
answers to those questions, will be brought back
to the offices, compiled
and the data
categorised, assessed and a list of
"doubtful citizens" will be prepared
"Doubtful citizens"? Those citizens
whose citizenship is doubtful or questionable.
Now, the power to identify such citizens
will be in the hands of those Government bureaucrats
that you cannot trust.
For instance,
there is Rs 40 crore unclaimed amount in the PF offices,
and that amount belongs to the
poor and the labours of our country.
Why are they not able to get this amount?
Because their names are different in voter IDs,
to that in the addhar card, the spelling is different.
For example,  Neelam is spelled N-I-L-A-M,
or N-E-E-L-A-M,
this difference of 'E' and 'I' , bars them from
their own cash from their accounts.
So, this criteria based purely on paperwork,
to decide the citizenship of a citizen
or to take away their citizenship
the onus of which is in the hands of the government bureaucrats and officials,
is very dangerous and problematic. Along with this
there is one more thing,
that if one individual is suspicious of another,
or feels the other is not a citizen
he/she can go and appeal in the court,
that a certain individual is not a citizen of India.
And then, that individual will be put in the "doubtful citizens" list.
If someone holds a personal grudge against you,
can go and appeal to the government, or write to the government,
for suspicion of your citizenship.
then, even with all the proofs,
your name will be in the "doubtful citizens" list.
And those whose name is on that list,
they have to submit the proof of their citizenship.
and the list of the documents necessary to prove
has not been made public by the government.
Your passport, PAN Card,
Voter ID, and other official documents,
might NOT be accepted by the government.
Their has been no clarification by the government on this.
So, Aadhar, voter card and the other documents,
will they be considered as proof of Citizenship?
NO! Not at all!
This is not what decides the citizenship. And definitely,
NOT by Aadhar.
NRC clearly states that a list of citizens
should be prepared. You have the list.
You have the voters' list.
You have the Census List. Why do you need more lists?
It should be done only where there is a big issue of discrepancy
between the voter list
or in the Census List.
There was a problem of that in Assam.
But there is no problem like that in India.
The citizens of this country, our country,
whose ancestors and forefathers gave their blood and sweat
for this country. To make and develop our country,
to help mould this country,
their children will now have to go and prove
their citizenship.
And on the basis of what? A mere piece of paper.
 
The problem with that piece of paper will be such
that you will be forced out of
your citizenship first,
then your home,
your farms,
and then all your property.
what is the problem?!
or what big issue is this
that unemployement, low growth rate,
farmers' issues and plights,
are not discussed and looked after by the Government,
but a lot of stress is given to CAA and NRC. Why?
Like we say that Britishers had a devious motive,
to Divide and Rule,
like that where Modi JI is not having his way, he makes it about Hindu-Muslim.
Now along with Divide and Rule,
there is Divert And Rule.
If the public is distressed by an issue,
if the public is distressed by the hiked prices of onions,
distract them with this issue of chicken and egg.
(CAA, NRC or NPR)
So, this pan-India NRC,
will not be needed separately anymore
because once NPR is implemented and completed,
NRC will be completed automatically.
The Government officials will not go to peoples' homes for NRC.
They can implement NRC from their offices.
And once implemented,
all the citizens of India, will be
issued a National Identification Card. (NIC)
This NIC, has already been given to people
in the form of Aadhar Card.
So, Gautam, a lot of money and funds were used for Aadhar card
and its biometric number,
can't aadhar card's identication number
fulfil the criteria for NPR?
I am asking this because
the Home Minister, Mr Amit Shah, has stated that
to form Government programmes,
to fix the provisions, NPR is necessary
Mr Ravish ji, there is a whole history behind this,
in 2010 and 2011,
the UPA government of that time, had a lot of heated debates over this
whether to choose NPR or go with Aadhar
Eventually, Aadhar was chosen, and you are right,
in the last 6-7 years, first by the UPA,
and now by BJP,
have been repeating that for government programmes,
to reach the people, Aadhar is a reliable and complete way to do so.
BJP's advocates have stated the same in the Supreme Court.
That Aadhar is a reliable and sure-fire way to do it.
Because it is impossible to fake the biometric identity.
So, if we believe that,
there is no reason for NPR if
we already have Aadhar.
Just in Assam, Rs 1600 crore were spent for NRC.
Final verdict was
that the BJP government  is ruling in Assam,
BJP's Chief Minister is ruling in Assam, and he is stating that this NRC
should be disbanded and redone again  in Assam,
with pan-India, whenever it is done.
NRC will be done all over the country.
At that time, NRC will be carried out in Assam too,
will be redone in Assam.
So, the  funding from the tax of an Indian citizen,
Rs 1600 crore, has gone to waste .
You calculate and make an estimate,
if Rs 1600 crore were used to do NRC in one state,
how much will be spent to do it in the whole country?
The cost of doing it for one person is Assam,
was Rs 399.
 
Now, if we take that Rs 399 and
multiply it to the population of India, (137 Crore)
 
the total cost
comes out to be
*look at the f'n screen* *OMFG*
 
So, can this be justified at a time,
when the country's Growth rate is going through such distressing times.
when the country's core sector is going through negative growth,
when the manufacturing sector is also going through trouble.
when the unemployment rate is at it's highest in the last 45 years.
These are Government data, I am not making them up. (F*** You ARNAB)
The other point is that this Rs 1600 crore is Government's loss,
but, the people whose name has come in the "doubtful citizens" list,
how much money and trouble did they have to go through to provide documents of proof?
To rectify their parent's identity and proof.
You look at the process,
every person had to leave their work and household for 5-10 days,
had to leave their labour and daily wage,
to stand in queues in front of offices,
to show documents, bribe the government officials, get harrassed by the officials.
Asking for bribes to write your name in the list, harassing you by removing your name from the list.
So, who suffered in this process?
Only the poor. In Assam,
there was no rich millionaire Muslim who suffered,
there was no rich/millionaire Hindu who suffered,
If we do NRC,
in the whole country,
the poor demographic of this country will suffer a lot
Now, the whole process has become clear.
Not only a certain community, or caste gonna suffer
But, the poor of this country,
that suffered by standing in long queues during Demonetisation also,
because you never saw,
any rich person standing in queues or suffering.
They were fine and comfortable.
Only the poor suffered,
Once again, to make and show documents of proof
to prove ones' own citizenship in one's  own country
they have to stand in queues.
80 KM from Guwahati, Assam, in Dalimbadi, 71 year old
Sarv Bala Malik and her son Paritosh
have been put in the "doubtful citizens" list.
They are being labelled as Bangladeshis.
Before this, in 1983, during the Assam Civil Protests and unrest,
her husband, Madan, died in the violence.
Their house was burnt down,
The All Assam Student's Union, which was protesting at that time, did get Madan to be declared as a martyr.
But, the name of Madan Malik was written as Madan Sarkar.
And this mistake, cost this family dearly.
Our family does not have 13 members identified in NRC.
Because 2 family members, me and my mother, are de-voters.
Even though we belong to a martyred family, we are de-voters.
And labelled illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. What's the point of such a life?
This whole exercise of NRC, deflects us  from the basic and human problems,
like, food, emplyement,
clothes, housing, education, health
roads, electricity, water, development and self empowerment.
 
That's why anyone who loves this country,
are this Country's citizens, whose ancestors fought for the
freedom of India,
fought against the British empire.
They'll have to think and introspect. That our ancestors fought against the British.
Now we have to fight against these thiefs.
And these thiefs that refuse to show the Rafale douments.
are asking documents of your forefathers from you!
This whole is illegitimate and unnecessary.
It should be protested and fought against.
And those that are protesting against them, it's valid.
The one's that are not,
should rise above the communal propaganda of Hindu-Muslim
and fight for our Country, our Constitution.
For tomorrow you might also suffer and run around the offices , harrassed
to show your documents. Fight for your right.
Fight for justice.
And speak up against this anti-national law.
YOU ALL KNOW RIGHT?!?!
NOPE! YOU DON'T KNOW!
After this video, this question is legitimate.
CAB became CAA, but what did we get?!
WAAH, MODI JI, WAAH!
There is no one more dangerous for this country than you.
 
 
